So, i was just looking at the Theros spoilers and this Bow of Nylea pops out. Can't we play this? It recurses our living ends and cascade spells, gain us life, kills delvers and spellstutters. I can see this in the deck
I'm going to quote what I posted in a similar thread.
As for the planeswalker hint, do multiple instances of the word "planeswalker" count as one word? Because if so, it could be an Aura that says:
"Enchant planeswalker
You control enchanted planeswalker."
MaRo has been known for tricky loopholes like that.
Given that reminder text does not count (i think) towards word count:
Sorcery
Gain control of target planeswalker. (This effect does not end at th end of your turn.)
Im amazed that it sees no play in modern, that it has no place. I think is one of the best 4cc planewswalker. Its single green allows it to be used in a plethora of different decks.
Decks where i think it might have a place
Living End (as a one of in the side, it can be a nice surprise)
Pod (gives tokens to sacrifce, can act as an emergency pod if the main ones are disabled)
Hatebears (maybe)
Jund (Im not saying instead of LotV, but in addition to)
So, i was looking at the decks and the lists and the stuff and i can't help but wonder: Do Twisted Abomination (probably in a very fringe list) or Madblind Mountain have a place herE?. Madblind Mountain allows to reshuffle if you sent a lot of good stuff to the bottom when casting Living End, Trouble is it can't be fetched neither by Pale Recluse nor by Verdant Catacombs. Also, Khalni Garden might have a place? A chump blocker for free is very useful in a deck like this.
Frogtosser
Goblin spells and Rogue spells you cast cost 1 less to cast.
Prowl (Earwig Squad here, its all the same)
Prowl 2B (You may cast this for its prowl cost if you dealt combat damage to a player this turn with a Goblin or Rogue.)
Im not entirely sure, but the wording seems to allow so
Ral Zarek is not THAT bad. Probably will see some play, though not an GP/PT level. And i love the ultimate, i mean at least ONE turn you are going to get.
Melek is for edh. Period
Fuse is probably going to be like cypher. A great mechanic with a lot of potential that will only have two o three (make that six :p) playable ones due to balancing / unbroking things.
1) Thragtusk. Too hard to kill and no good removal in standard.
2) Garruk. We need a new green planeswalker. Maybe a Nissa that doesn't deserve the "Worst planeswalker" title.
3) Liliana. Same reason as Garruk, we need a diferent planeswalker (not another Sorin either).
Really? I bought one kit of KMC (about a year and a half ago), 80 sleeves, Matte Brown. In less than EIGHT MONTHS, they were all split, wide open on the bottom (to the point i could take out the card on any of the two ends. And that's without mention bent corners. That will be my first and last KMC pack. Im now trying MaxProtection (less than a month of use, considering the fact they've got foil stamp on the back and i shuffle a lot, they are holding fine). What's most funny is that, probably ultra pro are the most durable for me. I shuffle them quite hardly, had them a lot of time (blue matte) and they are still in good conditions.
EDIT: I should mention thought, that my style of shuffling is rare. Its rifle shuffling (i think its called that way), but i do it with the bottom of the cards, putting a lot of straing on the sealed bottom of all my sleeves. Still, all of my sleeves survived at least a year, except for the kmc. Maybe i just got a bad pack, but still no more for me.
Im the person who thinks "I want an aura", then thinks it'll probably suck and just vote for non-aura.
My idea for an aura
Necromantic tidings 1BB
Enchant Creature
Enchanted creature has "When this creature dies, you may exile it. If you do, you may return target creature from a graveyard to the battlefield under your control. If you do, put a Necrology counter on it."
Whenever a creature dies, if it had a Necrology counter on it and Necromantic Ties is in your graveyard, return Necromantic Ties to the battlefield attached to target creature you control. If you can't, exile your graveyard.
Hey Wizards: Would you consider releasing a brand new, entire set, ONLY legal in Modern? It doesn't have to be connected to any of the current sets(ex: Coldsnap), just think exactly what you did with Modern Masters without being mostly reprints.
The obvious reason is fetchlands because all multicolored decks use them. My point is, for example, take any deck. Number of colours dont matter. It has 4 or 5 fetches, has utility lands. Its always useful, yes. I asked if there were any... minimum requirements people has to play it.
Given that reminder text does not count (i think) towards word count:
Sorcery
Gain control of target planeswalker. (This effect does not end at th end of your turn.)
Decks where i think it might have a place
Living End (as a one of in the side, it can be a nice surprise)
Pod (gives tokens to sacrifce, can act as an emergency pod if the main ones are disabled)
Hatebears (maybe)
Jund (Im not saying instead of LotV, but in addition to)
Frogtosser
Goblin spells and Rogue spells you cast cost 1 less to cast.
Prowl (Earwig Squad here, its all the same)
Prowl 2B (You may cast this for its prowl cost if you dealt combat damage to a player this turn with a Goblin or Rogue.)
Im not entirely sure, but the wording seems to allow so
Melek is for edh. Period
Fuse is probably going to be like cypher. A great mechanic with a lot of potential that will only have two o three (make that six :p) playable ones due to balancing / unbroking things.
2) Garruk. We need a new green planeswalker. Maybe a Nissa that doesn't deserve the "Worst planeswalker" title.
3) Liliana. Same reason as Garruk, we need a diferent planeswalker (not another Sorin either).
EDIT: I should mention thought, that my style of shuffling is rare. Its rifle shuffling (i think its called that way), but i do it with the bottom of the cards, putting a lot of straing on the sealed bottom of all my sleeves. Still, all of my sleeves survived at least a year, except for the kmc. Maybe i just got a bad pack, but still no more for me.
My idea for an aura
Necromantic tidings 1BB
Enchant Creature
Enchanted creature has "When this creature dies, you may exile it. If you do, you may return target creature from a graveyard to the battlefield under your control. If you do, put a Necrology counter on it."
Whenever a creature dies, if it had a Necrology counter on it and Necromantic Ties is in your graveyard, return Necromantic Ties to the battlefield attached to target creature you control. If you can't, exile your graveyard.
EDIT: PlasticineGuy beat me to it...