Why do you both think I am town and not just power wolfing?
Have you read you're posts? Maybe I'm biased, but that's just not the mindset I'd expect from scum, even in a power wolf setting.
Also, you have literally no need to townclear me as scum in a game this small.
Why do you both think I am town and not just power wolfing?
Have you read you're posts? Maybe I'm biased, but that's just not the mindset I'd expect from scum, even in a power wolf setting.
Also, you have literally no need to townclear me as scum in a game this small.
You haven't answered me about DV though.
DV I need to see more posts from. If I had a ranking system right now
GJ
Ophie
Shadow
ZomG
Meteor
DV
Anak
But it is really raw. I would be shocked if that tier stayed the same by the end of today, unless me and you are just shooting ***** and no one else comes on. Yes, I guess DV could be scum but the only reason he is a tier below is ZomG is completely null, Meteor had a slightly better entrance, and Ophie is lock town.
Well while we wait out everyone, I think we should figure out today what we want to do with claiming tomorrow. Everyone will have to claim a target and a result, and I think doing that before anything else is smart. I'd like to do a random order, or Oph could give a T/S list near the end of day and we could use that.
Thoughts?
@Gj In a post where I asked someone what game they read me in, and anotherabout their experience, making a somewhat joking question jumps out? Would love to prove myself, just need more than one post.
Also since you removed Zomg, who would you pair with me?
Oph is obvtown from not being counter claimed for sure.
Calling anyone lucky less than 24 hours in to game start and on page one feels disingenuous, even in a micro like this. Feels like an excuse to sow suspicion where there isn't any, Shadow I'm looking at you.
Well while we wait out everyone, I think we should figure out today what we want to do with claiming tomorrow. Everyone will have to claim a target and a result, and I think doing that before anything else is smart. I'd like to do a random order, or Oph could give a T/S list near the end of day and we could use that.
Thoughts?
What are you hoping to gleam from this? In a game where results are designed to be full of WIFOM. If I got a result of town on GJ, what would you take from that?
Unvote I'm wary of GJ taking control of the town so quickly but he seems town.
Disagree with him on Shadow and wonder why he put himself above Ophidia.
Also, why did no one say we should simply no lynch today?
GJ said something about No lynch in the sign up thread, and I replied that it is not optimal in this setup. (It takes us from one free mislynch to none).
@Anak: who did I call lucky, I did a quick skim of my posts and didn't see that, am I blind?
Of course the results are all WIFOM, but not at least trying to use them seems like a terrible idea. And I'd especially like to determine an order before anyone has results so that we give scum the least opportunity to manipulate them.
unvote vote zomg I do not like that intro at all
... unvote Arrrrrgghhhhjdvdidvwkdof, I am not leading a lynch on zomg, not in the near future anyway, I am not burning myself on that again.
I really hate that entrance though. Hate it.
@Gj In a post where I asked someone what game they read me in, and anotherabout their experience, making a somewhat joking question jumps out? Would love to prove myself, just need more than one post.
Also since you removed Zomg, who would you pair with me?
Oph is obvtown from not being counter claimed for sure.
Calling anyone lucky less than 24 hours in to game start and on page one feels disingenuous, even in a micro like this. Feels like an excuse to sow suspicion where there isn't any, Shadow I'm looking at you.
Unvote
You have seen me before. In either alignment, how likely am I to stay on the same target at the beginning of day 1 until the end?
DV I don't like how hedgey he was being with me taking control versus me being town, and not a huge fan of the shadow shade.
But shadow, I am surprised you didn't address it. He was clearly saying that if he didn't agree with my read, he thinks you are scum. Why didn't you answer that part?
@GJ I didn't address his (DV) calling me scum because it had zero substance, came shortly after I said he could be scum, and he threw shade at you in the same breath. I honestly didn't find it necessary to even give him credence.
Interestingly, he then puts you in his not lynching pile, also above Oph.
Why do you both think I am town and not just power wolfing?
Not sure what power wolfing but all your posts seems to come from a town player.
Honestly, what kind of a mafia player would question people that call him town? Posts like this exactly makes me think you are town.
It also isn't hard to get early scum reads in a 7 player game. 1 is basically a lock town, and 1 is me. That means even at random, I have a 40% chance of getting one scum correct.
Of the entrances thus far, I have liked Anak's the least.
Yeah, easy for you to say because its not really random for you.
I prefer to talk to all the other guys here and try to make that percentage much higher than the random 40%..
It should be easier than for me. Ophidia is lock town for everyone, and you have me free and you 0-o
Still not enough. Glad to see you thought so too and engaged with all the other players, hope I get the chance too.
Why do you both think I am town and not just power wolfing?
Have you read you're posts? Maybe I'm biased, but that's just not the mindset I'd expect from scum, even in a power wolf setting.
Also, you have literally no need to townclear me as scum in a game this small.
You haven't answered me about DV though.
You didn't ask him anything about D_V here, maybe you confused this thread with your mafia chat?
(Oh god I hope not)
@Gj In a post where I asked someone what game they read me in, and anotherabout their experience, making a somewhat joking question jumps out? Would love to prove myself, just need more than one post.
Also since you removed Zomg, who would you pair with me?
Oph is obvtown from not being counter claimed for sure.
Calling anyone lucky less than 24 hours in to game start and on page one feels disingenuous, even in a micro like this. Feels like an excuse to sow suspicion where there isn't any, Shadow I'm looking at you.
Unvote
I liked the response alot, until the Shadow weird attack. He didn't call anyone lucky?
Well while we wait out everyone, I think we should figure out today what we want to do with claiming tomorrow. Everyone will have to claim a target and a result, and I think doing that before anything else is smart. I'd like to do a random order, or Oph could give a T/S list near the end of day and we could use that.
Thoughts?
What are you hoping to gleam from this? In a game where results are designed to be full of WIFOM. If I got a result of town on GJ, what would you take from that?
Can you really think of no scenarios where town benefits from the results as a whole?
unvote vote zomg I do not like that intro at all
... unvote Arrrrrgghhhhjdvdidvwkdof, I am not leading a lynch on zomg, not in the near future anyway, I am not burning myself on that again.
I really hate that entrance though. Hate it.
DV I don't like how hedgey he was being with me taking control versus me being town, and not a huge fan of the shadow shade.
But shadow, I am surprised you didn't address it. He was clearly saying that if he didn't agree with my read, he thinks you are scum. Why didn't you answer that part?
To be fair, it was directed towards your and you didn't answer him either.
Including the part about putting yourself above Ophidia btw
@GJ I didn't address his (DV) calling me scum because it had zero substance, came shortly after I said he could be scum, and he threw shade at you in the same breath. I honestly didn't find it necessary to even give him credence.
Interestingly, he then puts you in his not lynching pile, also above Oph.
My pile is literally I'm not lynching them it isn't a T/S list. Nice try to throw shade on me though.
@GJ I didn't address his (DV) calling me scum because it had zero substance, came shortly after I said he could be scum, and he threw shade at you in the same breath. I honestly didn't find it necessary to even give him credence.
Interestingly, he then puts you in his not lynching pile, also above Oph.
My pile is literally I'm not lynching them it isn't a T/S list. Nice try to throw shade on me though.
Guess I have to read Shadow now.
Honestly you're right, it was a cheap shot that I took for no real reason except I thought it was amusing.
Still not enough. Glad to see you thought so too and engaged with all the other players, hope I get the chance too.
Shrugs
To be fair, it was directed towards your and you didn't answer him either.
Including the part about putting yourself above Ophidia btw
I mean, I put myself above Ophidia because I know what my role says, but not his. The list is how I see it. Yes, he is lock town to me, but the law of absolutes says there is a non-100% chance he is town. There is 100% chance that I am town. This is known.
I also wasn't referring to me not responsing to shadow. I was referring to shadow not responding to DV.
If the framer is alive alone, does he have both framing and killing abilities, and can't do both same night?
I don't think scum would ask this question do you guys?
GJ let me ask this more bluntly.
Why do you like shadow? I've seen nothing to indicate to me to clear him.
Not Lynching
DV
GJ
Ophie
Meteor
Will Lynch
Shadow
ZomG
Anak
I said I like him for town. I didn't say he was lock clear, but his posting I feel has been better than most. And his tone felt good coming into the thread.
@GJ I didn't address his (DV) calling me scum because it had zero substance, came shortly after I said he could be scum, and he threw shade at you in the same breath. I honestly didn't find it necessary to even give him credence.
Interestingly, he then puts you in his not lynching pile, also above Oph.
My pile is literally I'm not lynching them it isn't a T/S list. Nice try to throw shade on me though.
Guess I have to read Shadow now.
Honestly you're right, it was a cheap shot that I took for no real reason except I thought it was amusing.
I'm done taking cheap shots. One time I almost hurt a civilian, almost had to return my badge.
Oh stupid autocorrect, lucky should be lurky my bad
GJ mentioned lurky first at post #39, shadow just responded in #43. Why call out Shadow but not GJ?
Is it because he has more ability to sway people and you want to be careful as mafia?
It's cute how you defended D_V like that. Noted.
GJ thoughts on the Meteor idea for him probabally being town?
I can only pick two scum.
That doesn't answer my question.
I thought you were asking me why I was putting him in the town slot of my list.
If you mean his "question" I don't think it actually does anything. I have a question about the framer too, but I just want to ask it later, if at all.
GJ thoughts on the Meteor idea for him probabally being town?
I can only pick two scum.
That doesn't answer my question.
I thought you were asking me why I was putting him in the town slot of my list.
If you mean his "question" I don't think it actually does anything. I have a question about the framer too, but I just want to ask it later, if at all.
I feel that scum would ask this question in a PM. Asking questions like this ITT is town to me.
I don't like this. According to OP Mafia has Daychat only for day 1.
They are getting free time to discuss, and they will post here after they are in sync.
I'd like everyone to post a list of Not Lyncing/Will Lynch like D_V's one.
Here is mine:
Not Lynching
Myself
Ophidia
GJ
Shadow
Will Lynch
ZOMG
Anak
D_V
Liking D_V more than ZOMG and Anak, but I'm still not convinced about him.
No surprise about the night kill there..
Well, we gotta lynch correctly until the end of the game now.
OK so I'm guessing we get 2 guilty inspections, 1 is the framer and 1 is the framed one. No chance the framer won't use its ability.
I'll just share mine immediately since I got an innocent result.
The result was on Shadow. Did some predictions about the investigations and figured it was a good strategy that will get us information, even if it will by process of elimination. Not surprised at the innocent result, but I think its useful.
More interested on the guilty ones, would like personally Anak to go first and then DV, but if GJ or Shadow has an innocence result don't see why they can't post before.
After the 2 guilty result I plan to interrogate them and defend myself if its me who is framed in one of them. I expect everyone else to do the same, seeing as we have to get this right. Please put as much as effort as you can, and lets take our time with this one, specially as mafia has no day chat anyway.
I thhink that the one post by ZOMG is just soo scummy. And its his only post. Lurk much?
Vote ZOMG
I'll let someone hammer when ready that but I'm ready for the day to be done.
This post make me suspect that if D_V is a mafia and this is a "mistake" (AKA not really a mistake), he is a godfather and not the miller.
Can't see Miller trying to pull this off.
I'm actually inclined to disagree with you on DV, if he is the framer, he can claim being framed, because if he's town, he's the most likely frame target after that hammer.
I would like investigation results before diving into this anyway, the order doesn't have to be set, but I would like DV/Anak to go before GJ/myself.
No more claims until I get this question answered. Read the bloody thread before anyone votes or says anything. Those kind of mistakes shouldn't happen. ZomG I GUARANTEE has at least one scum on it.
No more claims until I get this question answered. Read the bloody thread before anyone votes or says anything. Those kind of mistakes shouldn't happen. ZomG I GUARANTEE has at least one scum on it.
Not even behaviorally but mechanically. Unless you're scum with Anak then there is no way the lynch could have even occurred without a scum vote.
No more claims until I get this question answered. Read the bloody thread before anyone votes or says anything. Those kind of mistakes shouldn't happen. ZomG I GUARANTEE has at least one scum on it.
Not even behaviorally but mechanically. Unless you're scum with Anak then there is no way the lynch could have even occurred without a scum vote.
I legit thought I was going to get shot over confirmed town Ophidia. I thought I was being annoying enough, being town read by the whole game. GUESS IMA GONNA SOLVE THE PUZZEL, PATRICK.
I just need tom to respond before I bury DV into a giant pile of crap.
No more claims until I get this question answered. Read the bloody thread before anyone votes or says anything. Those kind of mistakes shouldn't happen. ZomG I GUARANTEE has at least one scum on it.
Not even behaviorally but mechanically. Unless you're scum with Anak then there is no way the lynch could have even occurred without a scum vote.
I legit thought I was going to get shot over confirmed town Ophidia. I thought I was being annoying enough, being town read by the whole game. GUESS IMA GONNA SOLVE THE PUZZEL, PATRICK.
I just need tom to respond before I bury DV into a giant pile of crap.
Ha, I actually thought the same thing, I figured you were toast.
Have you read you're posts? Maybe I'm biased, but that's just not the mindset I'd expect from scum, even in a power wolf setting.
Also, you have literally no need to townclear me as scum in a game this small.
You haven't answered me about DV though.
DV I need to see more posts from. If I had a ranking system right now
GJ
Ophie
Shadow
ZomG
Meteor
DV
Anak
But it is really raw. I would be shocked if that tier stayed the same by the end of today, unless me and you are just shooting ***** and no one else comes on. Yes, I guess DV could be scum but the only reason he is a tier below is ZomG is completely null, Meteor had a slightly better entrance, and Ophie is lock town.
The GJ way path to no lynching:
Thoughts?
Also since you removed Zomg, who would you pair with me?
Oph is obvtown from not being counter claimed for sure.
Calling anyone lucky less than 24 hours in to game start and on page one feels disingenuous, even in a micro like this. Feels like an excuse to sow suspicion where there isn't any, Shadow I'm looking at you.
Unvote
Disagree with him on Shadow and wonder why he put himself above Ophidia.
Also, why did no one say we should simply no lynch today?
What are you hoping to gleam from this? In a game where results are designed to be full of WIFOM. If I got a result of town on GJ, what would you take from that?
GJ said something about No lynch in the sign up thread, and I replied that it is not optimal in this setup. (It takes us from one free mislynch to none).
Of course the results are all WIFOM, but not at least trying to use them seems like a terrible idea. And I'd especially like to determine an order before anyone has results so that we give scum the least opportunity to manipulate them.
...
unvote Arrrrrgghhhhjdvdidvwkdof, I am not leading a lynch on zomg, not in the near future anyway, I am not burning myself on that again.
I really hate that entrance though. Hate it.
Not hard to take control of the town when no one was really posting.
You have seen me before. In either alignment, how likely am I to stay on the same target at the beginning of day 1 until the end?
The GJ way path to no lynching:
ZomG: CONFIRM THE COUNTERCLAIM NAO
The GJ way path to no lynching:
The GJ way path to no lynching:
Ophie
Shadow
Meteor
ZomG
DV
Anak
About how I feel now.
The GJ way path to no lynching:
But shadow, I am surprised you didn't address it. He was clearly saying that if he didn't agree with my read, he thinks you are scum. Why didn't you answer that part?
The GJ way path to no lynching:
I don't think scum would ask this question do you guys?
GJ let me ask this more bluntly.
Why do you like shadow? I've seen nothing to indicate to me to clear him.
Not Lynching
DV
GJ
Ophie
Meteor
Will Lynch
Shadow
ZomG
Anak
Interestingly, he then puts you in his not lynching pile, also above Oph.
Still not enough. Glad to see you thought so too and engaged with all the other players, hope I get the chance too.
You didn't ask him anything about D_V here, maybe you confused this thread with your mafia chat?
(Oh god I hope not)
I liked the response alot, until the Shadow weird attack. He didn't call anyone lucky?
The game is hard enough as it is, please don't make it even harder lol
Can you really think of no scenarios where town benefits from the results as a whole?
Eww at this post.
So first you weren't here for discussion, then you come in and troll us?
Unvote
Vote zomgarcwind
Why did you take the vote back here Shadow?
To be fair, it was directed towards your and you didn't answer him either.
Including the part about putting yourself above Ophidia btw
My pile is literally I'm not lynching them it isn't a T/S list. Nice try to throw shade on me though.
Guess I have to read Shadow now.
I unvoted Zomg because I've successfully mislynched him in the past 2 completely games we've played together, one of them cost town the game.
Honestly you're right, it was a cheap shot that I took for no real reason except I thought it was amusing.
Shrugs
I mean, I put myself above Ophidia because I know what my role says, but not his. The list is how I see it. Yes, he is lock town to me, but the law of absolutes says there is a non-100% chance he is town. There is 100% chance that I am town. This is known.
I also wasn't referring to me not responsing to shadow. I was referring to shadow not responding to DV.
The GJ way path to no lynching:
I said I like him for town. I didn't say he was lock clear, but his posting I feel has been better than most. And his tone felt good coming into the thread.
The GJ way path to no lynching:
I can only pick two scum.
The GJ way path to no lynching:
I'm done taking cheap shots. One time I almost hurt a civilian, almost had to return my badge.
I'm like a fungus. I'll grow on him.
GJ mentioned lurky first at post #39, shadow just responded in #43. Why call out Shadow but not GJ?
Is it because he has more ability to sway people and you want to be careful as mafia?
It's cute how you defended D_V like that. Noted.
He was asking you specifically about the question I asked tom.
I'm guessing you knew it and avoided the answer anyway. Cop out! (Pun intended)
That doesn't answer my question.
I thought you were asking me why I was putting him in the town slot of my list.
If you mean his "question" I don't think it actually does anything. I have a question about the framer too, but I just want to ask it later, if at all.
The GJ way path to no lynching:
I feel that scum would ask this question in a PM. Asking questions like this ITT is town to me.
They are getting free time to discuss, and they will post here after they are in sync.
I'd like everyone to post a list of Not Lyncing/Will Lynch like D_V's one.
Here is mine:
Not Lynching
Myself
Ophidia
GJ
Shadow
Will Lynch
ZOMG
Anak
D_V
Liking D_V more than ZOMG and Anak, but I'm still not convinced about him.
gentleman johnny (1) - ophidia
zomgarcwind (2) - shadowlancerX, mete0rshower
not voting: 4 (zomgarcwind, anaklusmos, gentleman johnny, D_V)
With 7 alive, its 4 to lynch
Will lynch:
Zom
Ank
Will not lynch:
GJ
Shadow
When Zom was town, he usually contribute a lot to the maf hunt, but here he purposefully ignored it. This really convinces me that he is maf.
Vote Zomgarcwind
I kind of wonder if ZomG was TWTBW, but no reason for an accidental hammer.
The GJ way path to no lynching:
Vote ZOMG
I'll let someone hammer when ready that but I'm ready for the day to be done.
The GJ way path to no lynching:
zomgarcwind (4) - shadowlancerX, mete0rshower, ophidia, D_V
not voting: 3 (zomgarcwind, anaklusmos, gentleman johnny)
zomgarcwind was:
Town Cop
It is now night 1
Do Not Post
Night actions are due in 36 hours.
He was:
Town Miller
It is now Day 2
With 5 alive, it's 3 to lynch.
not voting: 5 anaklusmos, gentleman johnny, shadowlancerX, mete0rshower, D_V
You may post
Well, we gotta lynch correctly until the end of the game now.
OK so I'm guessing we get 2 guilty inspections, 1 is the framer and 1 is the framed one. No chance the framer won't use its ability.
I'll just share mine immediately since I got an innocent result.
The result was on Shadow. Did some predictions about the investigations and figured it was a good strategy that will get us information, even if it will by process of elimination. Not surprised at the innocent result, but I think its useful.
More interested on the guilty ones, would like personally Anak to go first and then DV, but if GJ or Shadow has an innocence result don't see why they can't post before.
After the 2 guilty result I plan to interrogate them and defend myself if its me who is framed in one of them. I expect everyone else to do the same, seeing as we have to get this right. Please put as much as effort as you can, and lets take our time with this one, specially as mafia has no day chat anyway.
This post make me suspect that if D_V is a mafia and this is a "mistake" (AKA not really a mistake), he is a godfather and not the miller.
Can't see Miller trying to pull this off.
@D_V What happened here?
I would like investigation results before diving into this anyway, the order doesn't have to be set, but I would like DV/Anak to go before GJ/myself.
All of you
Thinking right now.
The GJ way path to no lynching:
(this is insane next level play, but targeting DV last night seemed obvious)
The GJ way path to no lynching:
The GJ way path to no lynching:
Not even behaviorally but mechanically. Unless you're scum with Anak then there is no way the lynch could have even occurred without a scum vote.
I legit thought I was going to get shot over confirmed town Ophidia. I thought I was being annoying enough, being town read by the whole game. GUESS IMA GONNA SOLVE THE PUZZEL, PATRICK.
I just need tom to respond before I bury DV into a giant pile of crap.
The GJ way path to no lynching:
Ha, I actually thought the same thing, I figured you were toast.
The GJ way path to no lynching: