Anyone thought of using Mind's Desire? To me it seems like a great/fun card for this deck, though I can see how it could possibly be redundant with the amount of tutors and other stuff...
Anyone thought of using Mind's Desire? To me it seems like a great/fun card for this deck, though I can see how it could possibly be redundant with the amount of tutors and other stuff...
Funny thing is, it's banned.
Although I might try Solidarity in Vintage one time to see how it fares.
so i understand that solidarity's charm lies in the ability to go off at instant speed. would it be plausible to also run the palinchron high tide mana engine, as i've seen this used with stroke of genius as an alternate win condition? this would rack up a storm count for brainfreeze, and would also save the trouble of trying to find multiple copies of reset, which is incredibly expensive and hard to find. any opinions?
Hello, I'm interested in playing this deck, and if finding high tide is a major priority, shouldn't 1 be in the wishboard and up the count of cunning wishes? so you're running 7 high tides, and it also allows for more access to your board. I realize it slightly dilutes the curve, but I feel that it should not affect how the deck functions as a whole. I know people haven't posted on this in awhile, so I hope this gets answered.
so i understand that solidarity's charm lies in the ability to go off at instant speed. would it be plausible to also run the palinchron high tide mana engine, as i've seen this used with stroke of genius as an alternate win condition? this would rack up a storm count for brainfreeze, and would also save the trouble of trying to find multiple copies of reset, which is incredibly expensive and hard to find. any opinions?
Well yes and no, but if you ran Palinchron instead of the Resets you're playing a very different deck.
Solidarity's resilience comes from it's ability to combo off on your opponent's turn in response to an attack, or disruption or for him looking at you funny.
Using the Palinchron +High tide engine can only work on YOUR turn.
Reset only works on the OPPONENT'S turn. So if you start comboing off on your opponent's turn, palinchron is a dead draw and vice versa for Reset.
What you then have is a less consistent deck, so you'd fizzle a lot more often.
If you run one, you can't have the other. I'm not saying Palinchron + High tide is bad, it just requires a different approach.
Hope this helps.
Private Mod Note
():
Rollback Post to RevisionRollBack
They call me Hank Hill because I bring the pro-pain.
Funny thing is, it's banned.
Although I might try Solidarity in Vintage one time to see how it fares.
I am petitioning to get players to stop complaining about mythic rarity. Sig this to join the cause.
Well yes and no, but if you ran Palinchron instead of the Resets you're playing a very different deck.
Solidarity's resilience comes from it's ability to combo off on your opponent's turn in response to an attack, or disruption or for him looking at you funny.
Using the Palinchron +High tide engine can only work on YOUR turn.
Reset only works on the OPPONENT'S turn. So if you start comboing off on your opponent's turn, palinchron is a dead draw and vice versa for Reset.
What you then have is a less consistent deck, so you'd fizzle a lot more often.
If you run one, you can't have the other. I'm not saying Palinchron + High tide is bad, it just requires a different approach.
Hope this helps.
If you're interested in this deck, ask about it in the Legacy forums.
https://fieldmarshalshandbook.wordpress.com/
RUGLegacy Lands.dec
RUGBLegacy Lands.dec
RGLegacy Lands.dec
WUBRG EDH Lands.dec
UBR EDH Artificer Prodigy
B EDH Relentless Rats