I certainly did not mean to step on Morphlings toes.
Is there some way we can move that thread to the main "cube forum" board. I would never have seen it if you had not told me. It has been up for over a month and only 8 people have voted and that includes me, just now. I think we want all the feedback possible.
So, it looks like it will be time consuming, but not that hard. Thanks to everyone who tried this. So, my strategy for doing this is to allow twenty entries for each color, 10 entries for each guild, and 10 non-dual land entries (I am curious what utility lands people play in cube). I was thinking about letting players list top shard cards, but I think we would have to do them all in one list.
A card would be assigned points based on where it ranks, and then its points average. so 20 for first place, 1 for 20th place. Any thoughts on this, and how long should we wait after allegiance to post the survey?
I really like a blind survey, to help prevent people copying others answers. Then we can just average the numbers. I have made a practice question below, can a couple of you take it, so I can see how practical it will be to sort the results.
Well, you would allow them to type their answers, then you could copy and paste them into word and sort them alphabetically... that would make counting them a lot easier even with typos.
I agree on waiting until after the new allegiance set. If guilds was any indication, there will be several cube-able cards in the new set. Both my pauper cube, and my eternal cube saw a lot of changes, but the rankings are so helpful, and really help me reevaluate my cube.
Maybe a online tool like survey monkey, could make sorting the ranks easier.
Thank you guys. I totally understand. They look like a lot of work. They were super helpful when I was looking for cards to consider for my first cube.
I was just curious to see how they might have changed since 2016. Are their rankings for last year? Sorry for all the questions. I am new to the forum, and I was just curious.
I certainly did not mean to step on Morphlings toes.
Is there some way we can move that thread to the main "cube forum" board. I would never have seen it if you had not told me. It has been up for over a month and only 8 people have voted and that includes me, just now. I think we want all the feedback possible.
A card would be assigned points based on where it ranks, and then its points average. so 20 for first place, 1 for 20th place. Any thoughts on this, and how long should we wait after allegiance to post the survey?
https://www.surveymonkey.com/r/FTY8FFF
For example how many red cards were they able to vote for?
And
Did they get to order them 1-20?
Maybe a online tool like survey monkey, could make sorting the ranks easier.
I was just curious to see how they might have changed since 2016. Are their rankings for last year? Sorry for all the questions. I am new to the forum, and I was just curious.
Why was my survey thread marked as spam? Not trying to be rude, just want to make sure I am adhering to the rules of the forum?
It looks like the forum did a survey of some kind in 2016:
https://www.mtgsalvation.com/forums/the-game/the-cube-forum/cube-card-and-archetype/760253-power-rankings-2016-cube-power-rankings-blue
I found looking at it really helpful, and would be curious to see updated power-rankings/play rates of cards by color and guild.