For a kitchen table or even an FNM level? Sure. Give it a go, it could be fun.
At a competitive level? Almost certainly not. 1 mana for a Prowess/Constellation trigger each turn is very slow in a format where dying on turn 4 is going to happen a good 50% or so of you games. An indefinite number of Constellation and Prowess triggers at 3 mana a pop with an effect stapled on that isn't actually that useful? Probably not great, either.
Definitely give the deck a go - you might make it into a cool list that has success at the FNM level. But I'd be strongly surprised if it could cut it against the current tier 1 decks.
Private Mod Note
():
Rollback Post to RevisionRollBack
Well, I can saw a woman in two, but you won't wanna look in the box when I'm through.
I'd be willing to say a doomwake giant bloom deck with manabloom is playable. I'd put it into a pillow fort style deck with the card that makes angels as the backup/primary finisher. Giant would be used to clear out 1 or 2 toughness creatures and keep blocking tokens like lingering souls at bay.
Probably run 6 or so 1 Mana discard spells some combination of push path.
2 of Collective Brutality feels good here with lingering souls.
Creature base feels good at Tireless Tracker, giant, Mr gadget,
For a kitchen table or even an FNM level? Sure. Give it a go, it could be fun.
At a competitive level? Almost certainly not. 1 mana for a Prowess/Constellation trigger each turn is very slow in a format where dying on turn 4 is going to happen a good 50% or so of you games. An indefinite number of Constellation and Prowess triggers at 3 mana a pop with an effect stapled on that isn't actually that useful? Probably not great, either.
Definitely give the deck a go - you might make it into a cool list that has success at the FNM level. But I'd be strongly surprised if it could cut it against the current tier 1 decks.
I'd be willing to say a doomwake giant bloom deck with manabloom is playable. I'd put it into a pillow fort style deck with the card that makes angels as the backup/primary finisher. Giant would be used to clear out 1 or 2 toughness creatures and keep blocking tokens like lingering souls at bay.
Probably run 6 or so 1 Mana discard spells some combination of push path.
2 of Collective Brutality feels good here with lingering souls.
Creature base feels good at Tireless Tracker, giant, Mr gadget,
I'm a little out of the loop, what is card is mr gadget refering too?
If a "pillow fort" could work with green and black, doomwake giant not only clears out the wide and small, but he always goes in with an edge on similar size monsters in the decks that don't go wide.
I think theres a lot of potential for him. won't do much against valakut, storm, tron,
while I feel like this makes for strong aggro on aggro, its definitely vulnerable to non aggro match ups, such as tron and storm. discard spells typically aren't enough to keep that kind of strategy off its feet.
Private Mod Note
():
Rollback Post to RevisionRollBack
To post a comment, please login or register a new account.
As I dug through the cards I happened upon Doomwake Giant, Grim Guardian, that got the gears turning that maybe molting skin could be the engine for powering a deck that runs a trio doomwake giant grim guardian and monastery mentor.
If we add Mana Bloom to the combination, the engine gets some what cheaper.
do you think we can make a deck with those 3 might be viable?
At a competitive level? Almost certainly not. 1 mana for a Prowess/Constellation trigger each turn is very slow in a format where dying on turn 4 is going to happen a good 50% or so of you games. An indefinite number of Constellation and Prowess triggers at 3 mana a pop with an effect stapled on that isn't actually that useful? Probably not great, either.
Definitely give the deck a go - you might make it into a cool list that has success at the FNM level. But I'd be strongly surprised if it could cut it against the current tier 1 decks.
Probably run 6 or so 1 Mana discard spells some combination of push path.
2 of Collective Brutality feels good here with lingering souls.
Creature base feels good at Tireless Tracker, giant, Mr gadget,
ya i'm definitely thinking FNM with it.
I'm a little out of the loop, what is card is mr gadget refering too?
If a "pillow fort" could work with green and black, doomwake giant not only clears out the wide and small, but he always goes in with an edge on similar size monsters in the decks that don't go wide.
I think theres a lot of potential for him. won't do much against valakut, storm, tron,
I like the idea so far.
2 Tireless Tracker
4 Thraben Inspector
2 Nyx Weaver
2 Eidolon of Blossoms
2 Sigel of the Empty Throne
3 Manabloom
3 Inquisition of Kozilek
3 Thoughtseize
2 Collective Brutality
4 Lingering Souls
3 Commune with the Gods
Probably not truely competitive, but a decent foundation.
4 doomwake giant
4 monastery mentor
4 Brain Maggot
4 manabloom
2 molting skin
4 Helm of the Gods
4 Shambling Vent
4 utopia sprawl
3 Inquistion of Kozilek
3 thoughtseize
4 commune with the gods
18 land
this might be a good place for Grim Flayer, or Adanto, the First Fort
while I feel like this makes for strong aggro on aggro, its definitely vulnerable to non aggro match ups, such as tron and storm. discard spells typically aren't enough to keep that kind of strategy off its feet.