This thread was marked as Locked by Torpf.
What cards do you want UNBANNED in Modern? - Multiple Choice
Ended Apr 24, 2017
What cards do you want BANNED in Modern? - Multiple Choice
Quote from Billiondegree »Just curious, but has the MTG Salvation Poll ever coincided with what actually occurred?
Quote from Earthbound21 »
I will not be replying to rebuttals that are not at least as fleshed out as my assertion. If you're grown up enough to use the internet, you are grown up enough to understand that posturing, nit picking, and corner cases are not enough to constitute a rebuttal to an argument. You will attack my argument in full or you will not be getting a response from me.
Quote from gkourou »Quote from Billiondegree »Just curious, but has the MTG Salvation Poll ever coincided with what actually occurred?
People screamed for Ancestral Vision and Sword Of The Meek for months before its unbanning, so yes. About bans, Summer Bloom had to go according to nearly everybody in here, and that was the case for Dredge 6 and Eye Of Ugin.
Gitaxian probe was something only some people wanted to get banned(the majority was on no bans or ban Become Immense on the aggro pump decks).
Splinter Twin was something nearly nobody wanted to see getting banned.
For older bans, I dont know as I was not a member, but I think people wanted TC to get banned, but not DTT. And about Pod the community was uncertain(correct me if I am wrong)
Quote from cfusionpm »Quote from Nyzzeh »Twin alone made nonflash 3 drops not viable in Modern so I don't think it's getting unbanned any time soon.
Horrendously false claim with absolutely no supporting evidence. Never mind the fact that the current format has an average CMC of 1.75 and nearly everything higher than 3cmc is either cheated into play, accelerated into play, or never actually cast for it's true cost. Another perpetuating myth that holds no ground whatsoever.
Quote from Nyzzeh »Twin alone made nonflash 3 drops not viable in Modern so I don't think it's getting unbanned any time soon.
Quote from hotshot162 »how many time before the announcement?
Quote from damagecase »Not having this on the list, what do you guys think the critical mass of infinite combos will be before they ban Collected Company? I'd hate to see the card go (because its one of my best specs ever) but with the printing Vezier of Remedies and already having devoted druid, Melira, Kitchen Finks and a sac outlet (Viscera Seer) and also helix pinnacle (as janky as it is) one has to wonder. I mean I know a deck is gonna use it, some already do I believe, so will they wait until it reaches 12-14% of the meta or will they hit it sooner? You'll might think I'm crazy but I was among the first to see both pod and twin being hit. CC unfortunately fits the mold as well with all these undercosted weapons running around.
Or does the copious amounts of discard and cheap removal keep it in check for the time being?
Curious to your thoughts?