Taevar2UURR
Legendary Creature - Dragon (M)
Haste, Flying 1UR: Exile all creatures and return them to the battlefield under their owner's control. They gain haste. Activate this ability only once each turn.
7/7 Time is meaningless.
Critiques on Bulstan (I shamelessly stole the format. Thanks clcallag!)
Cardz5000BR
Card:
Gravewillow Elder
(:symbg:) Creature Land - Treefolk (R)
:symtap:: Add or to your mana pool.
Sacrifice a Swamp and a Forest: Return Gravewillow Elder from your graveyard to the battlefield tapped.
1/1
Critique:
I don't know why you would want to spend two lands to get one back. It would've made sense if the creature itself was worth having on the battlefield, but it's just a mana dork.
Jimmy Groove1
Card:
Adding GU to color identity.
Dreamwillow Dryads
Land Creature - Dryad (R) t: Add G or U to your mana pool. UG: Until end of turn, Dreamwillow Dryads is 3/3 and has "Whenever Dreamwillow Dryads deals combat damage to a player, draw two cards." At the beginning of your end step, sacrifice it. Korus dreams, and her dreams fill her with life as curious and fertile as she is.
0/2
Critique:
The ability makes this card have a new use when you have enough mana. I like.
MaokunUR
Card:
Burning Bush
((R/G)) Land Creature - Mountain Forest Elemental (U)
(t: add R or G to your mana pool.) t, sacrifice a creature or a land: Put a token that's a copy of Burning Bush onto the battlefield.
0/1
Critique:
I lol'ed It doesn't really make sense that this is a creature, but apart from that I like it a lot.
TeraparsecGU
Card:
Previous color identity: UG. Both colors removed, resulting in colorless.
Scrapyard
Artifact Land (U) t: add 1 to your mana pool.
Whenever you sacrifice a permanent, put a charge counter on Scrapyard. x,t, remove X charge counters from Scrapyard: Return target artifact card with mana cost of up to x from your graveyard to your hand.
Critique:
At first glance this card is good, but it needs many other cards to really do something. I think that by the time you have your sac engine going, this isn't really what you want to be doing with your mana. It would work if it either had a sac outlet itself or if the card went to the battlefield instead of your hand or if the tap ability didn't spend mana.
Raikou RiderWUBRG
Card:
Hegemon's Tower
Artifact Land {R}
Hegemon's Tower enters the battlefield tapped with X charge counters on it, where X is the number of other artifacts you control. t, Remove a charge counter from Hegemon's Tower: Add W,U, or B to your mana pool. t, Sacrifice another artifact: Add 2 to your mana pool.
Critique:
I would've loved it if the last ability would put a charge counter on it. As it is now, it isn't useful in the early game as it will dry out very quickly.
RithanielBGW
Card:
Roach Yard
• Land Creature - Insect R t: Add B to your mana pool.
When Roach Yard dies, each player sacrifices a land. "These are some of my most spiteful subjects. So much as disturb their home, and they will destroy everyone else's."
-Dol Embre
1/1
Critique:
This hurts you more than your opponent when it dies.
ced395WBR
Card:
WBR -> W
Sorry, don't have time to post my previous cards.
Tensi's Barrier
Land Creature - Plains Wall (U) (T: Add W to your mana pool.)
Defender
Whenever Tensi's Barrier blocks, add WW to your mana pool.
0/3
Critique:
Simple and good. I love it.
Top 3:
1.) Jimmy Groove
2.) Maokun
3.) Raiku Rider (I would've put ced395 here, but his land doesn't have sacrifice :/)
You're right about AG. I was trying to push shark more.
The sacrifice thing is all about mindset.
Ask someone who is a PR if he would sacrifice himself and he would say no.
Ask a vanilla and he'll think about who is more important than him.
The fact that you can't sacrifice yourself is irrelevant.
I reread Iso's case, and his jumpy behaviour reeks of scum indeed.
Taevar 2UURR
Legendary Creature - Dragon (M)
Haste, Flying
1UR: Exile all creatures and return them to the battlefield under their owner's control. They gain haste. Activate this ability only once each turn.
7/7
Time is meaningless.
Cardz5000 BR
Card:
(:symbg:) Creature Land - Treefolk (R)
:symtap:: Add
Sacrifice a Swamp and a Forest: Return Gravewillow Elder from your graveyard to the battlefield tapped.
1/1
Jimmy Groove 1
Card:
Dreamwillow Dryads
Land Creature - Dryad (R)
t: Add G or U to your mana pool.
UG: Until end of turn, Dreamwillow Dryads is 3/3 and has "Whenever Dreamwillow Dryads deals combat damage to a player, draw two cards." At the beginning of your end step, sacrifice it.
Korus dreams, and her dreams fill her with life as curious and fertile as she is.
0/2
Maokun UR
Card:
((R/G)) Land Creature - Mountain Forest Elemental (U)
(t: add R or G to your mana pool.)
t, sacrifice a creature or a land: Put a token that's a copy of Burning Bush onto the battlefield.
0/1
Teraparsec GU
Card:
Scrapyard
Artifact Land (U)
t: add 1 to your mana pool.
Whenever you sacrifice a permanent, put a charge counter on Scrapyard.
x,t, remove X charge counters from Scrapyard: Return target artifact card with mana cost of up to x from your graveyard to your hand.
Raikou Rider WUBRG
Card:
Artifact Land {R}
Hegemon's Tower enters the battlefield tapped with X charge counters on it, where X is the number of other artifacts you control.
t, Remove a charge counter from Hegemon's Tower: Add W,U, or B to your mana pool.
t, Sacrifice another artifact: Add 2 to your mana pool.
Rithaniel BGW
Card:
• Land Creature - Insect R
t: Add B to your mana pool.
When Roach Yard dies, each player sacrifices a land.
"These are some of my most spiteful subjects. So much as disturb their home, and they will destroy everyone else's."
-Dol Embre
1/1
ced395 WBR
Card:
Sorry, don't have time to post my previous cards.
Tensi's Barrier
Land Creature - Plains Wall (U)
(T: Add W to your mana pool.)
Defender
Whenever Tensi's Barrier blocks, add WW to your mana pool.
0/3
1.) Jimmy Groove
2.) Maokun
3.) Raiku Rider (I would've put ced395 here, but his land doesn't have sacrifice :/)
I have a hard time shrugging off the idea of FO vs Iso being town vs town. I've read it as such the whole game.
I'm going to reread FO.
Tom's FO vote doesn't make me feel any better about Tom. I'm going to focus on the possibility of them being buddies as well in my reread.
@Stormblind: how far are you in catching up?
The sacrifice thing is all about mindset.
Ask someone who is a PR if he would sacrifice himself and he would say no.
Ask a vanilla and he'll think about who is more important than him.
The fact that you can't sacrifice yourself is irrelevant.
I have a hard time believing that fishing for PR's wasn't your intent.
The way you put it, you're fishing for who AG reads as a PR. Why would he want to sacrifice himself for a vanilla?
I don't like the modgaming. We don't know if every vanilla got a pointless ability and if scum didn't.
He's fishing for PR's.
A vanilla townie will show much more willingness to sacrifice onseself than a PR.
Good answer to a bad fishing attempt.
unvote, vote Shark