I'm sick of the whole "is good for limited" argument. It's balls.
/checks the format of the Gatecrash PTQ season
Oh look, limited.
It's obviously that some cards aren't good enough for constructed play, a lot of commons/uncommons aren't. But when they aren't up against constructed decks, they can be pretty good. That's the point of "It will be good in limited".
Wow. How can a group of people consider Titans overpowered, then call a card with an impact similar to a titan meh. She drops and has an immediate effect without even attacking yet. She has 6 power, evasion, and can become a massive beatstick.
I think because the Titan's effects happen regardless of what happens to them after they land, or if they attack into a clogged board state.
Primeval Titan will always get you lands, Frost Titan will always tap stuff. This could drop, and an opponent could just block it and whatever guys you have out, and nothing happens.
The 6 mana is not bad though it is triple black. Can a mono colored deck do well in this set? If not, better bring all your dual lands in your deck with this guy
Doubtful. Doesn't really win you the game if they can get rid of it, and if they can't, well, any large beater would win the game for you at that point.
If it were exile permanently, then I'd be more impressed.
Not nearly as good as maelstrom pulse for the fact that if they kill this enchantment, they get a ton of things back Worse if those things have ETB effects.
Maybe cast it on your own guys, and then kill it? Hm.
Still, u/w is shaping up to have some decent answers to the hordes of creatures.
/farseek
"intangible virtue"
/terminus
"ok, lingering souls"
/dsphere
"ok, flash back lingering souls and favorable winds"
/verdict
"ok talrand's invocation"
/terminus
"negate"
FFUUUUUUU--
Those limited late games where the board is stalled and people are trying to topdeck an answer
I'd still take Gelectrode over this card.
/checks the format of the Gatecrash PTQ season
Oh look, limited.
It's obviously that some cards aren't good enough for constructed play, a lot of commons/uncommons aren't. But when they aren't up against constructed decks, they can be pretty good. That's the point of "It will be good in limited".
I think because the Titan's effects happen regardless of what happens to them after they land, or if they attack into a clogged board state.
Primeval Titan will always get you lands, Frost Titan will always tap stuff. This could drop, and an opponent could just block it and whatever guys you have out, and nothing happens.
The 6 mana is not bad though it is triple black. Can a mono colored deck do well in this set? If not, better bring all your dual lands in your deck with this guy
Doubtful. Doesn't really win you the game if they can get rid of it, and if they can't, well, any large beater would win the game for you at that point.
If it were exile permanently, then I'd be more impressed.
I don't think zombies will fear this, with most probably going to try B/G and maindeck an Abrupt Decay or two.
Reset all my Messenger's and you take some damage? Ok fine.
Maybe cast it on your own guys, and then kill it? Hm.
Still, u/w is shaping up to have some decent answers to the hordes of creatures.
Can't we get some normal cards that people may actually use? :l
Funtastic.
"Loses to Trading Post", is that the new thing?
If they're playing Trading Post in RTR, I think you're already winning.
Yuck.
Give me dat life?