Yeah I'm not buying DV's Post #1310 at all, he's at L-2 -- not even close to a lynch so that reaction makes no sense as town.
@Killjoy - 1) Iso's current stated scum reads are You/Tom/DV & Maybe Empoof, he's not insisting that You+Tom have to be a scum team at all so your insistence that he needs to reasses that stance is one that looks overdefensive and 2) I'm aware that you're trying to "Run through your Tom scum read" and I even agree with you in that the post where Tom drops Pozzai well and truly behind the other two in his scum reads is a decent point, that said lots of the other reasoning you're presenting here are attempting to fit reasoning to match the read rather than determing the read based on reasoning.
We've talked about hammering him aggressively. I don't think he would be shrugging his shoulders in his position as town but to say that he's "not even close to a lynch" is a stretch.
Also I don't want to go find it but check out the interaction I had with him about Nacho. I commented on that specifically at EoD yesterday. Hopefully I put post numbers when I talked about it
Going to dump my analysis of the DV/Typhon slot, I'll post mine on other slots on Wednesday night.
The reasoning behind Typhons particular push on X=Y inside Post #209 is something I didn't have a problem with at the time and agreed with several sections of it but looking back at it now the over focus there instead of on Pozzai at a time where my reads were "Scum (S->W):Pozzai, Xequals" inside Post #205 has a lot of scum motivation behind it in that it fits scum attempting to redirect the focus towards a mslynch rather than a partner. His hammer on X=Y inside Post #679 is fairly problematic in that he's claiming Iso was one of his scum reads D1 and was the biggest pusher of the X=Y wagon. His reasoning behind the hammer inside Post #711 of it "providing information" doesn't mesh with his complete lack of analysis from it and the read on Nacho there and in follow posts feels very shallow and more of a "Comment on something someone said recently!" type post. The read and vote on Vaimes inside Post #721 and their following interactions doesn't feel like a genuine scum reading; feels more like scum attempting to find something to focus on and talk about, ignoring the plethora of information and content from Vaimes throughout the game and focusing on a singular comment from him is fairly hard to see coming from town here. His read on Newcomb inside Post #886 is very vague and continued postponement of actually getting to his analysis is a rather solid scum tell. The strongest scum tell inside this post is his stance on Pozzai "That being said I guess Pozzai Is probabally scum just based on how much I've already whittled down the list." the scum read via PoE doesn't fit his prior stances of scum reads on Vaimes/Iso/Nacho and a null read on Tom, it makes a *****load of sense coming from a partner though.
Finished going over Vaimes. Like Vaimes initial thoughts dump in the game inside Post #71, his comment directed to Pozzai inside Post #131 points slightly against them being partners and like his vote change towards Pozzai inside Post #247. His initial rainbow list inside Post #290 having Pozzai as his strongest scum read and most of the players I'm leaning towards being scum here down the bottom of the list is or in his PoE lynch list inside Post #297 a rather big town tell. I don't think Vaimes would be brazen enough to make the "Would anyone believe if I scumclaim" comment as mafia like he did inside Post #414. Reads and comments like his Post #560, Post #586 and especially Post #589 read as genuine scumhunting; especially don't see the "Post game cred read Newcomb is coaching Ophidia" type comment coming from him as scum. I really really don't see Vaimes coming out pushing Newcomb like he did inside Post #689 as mafia especially with Newcomb actually being town here. His comment directed towards Pozzai about his claim inside Post #1107 doesn't read like partner conversation and his comment re; Pozzai inside Post #1144 reads very town. The fact that his analysis of the game D3 so far inside Post #1212 mirrors mine fairly closely is reassuring too. So very confident he's town.
Cool ngl I was starting to get worried about a Nacho/Vaimes world. This definitely sets me at ease
I'll step it up next time and really snagem
well deserved imo.
You guys are fun to play with, I'll be back
Well I didn't need to know the intimate nature of your relationship but I'll keep that in mind.
Tom was saying he was being objectively townie, and that this lead to him being widely town read.
Well someone has strong opinions.
Don't see why my opinion about you guys is relevant to iso at all.
Echo tom about why you're satisfied with a DV lynch if tom is ~absolutely scum. Doyouthinktheirpartners.jpg
^ l a z y
For him to come in and say that that's why he's getting scum read is laughable
His pushes are bad and he's bad hmmmk
Also RegFan specifically put me more at ease about Vaimes. I'm guessing his meta is easy to follow.
I'll read nacho tonight after dinner I think.
Cool ngl I was starting to get worried about a Nacho/Vaimes world. This definitely sets me at ease
so that's cool