2019 Holiday Exchange!
 
A New and Exciting Beginning
 
The End of an Era
  • posted a message on [[MCD]] Which of these three to cut from Doran?
    I'd dump true conviction myself. Putting that on the board forces an impending sweep before you go ape on everyone -- I don't use big creature area buffs in my Doran deck for that reason. It also requires triple white in a 3 color deck which I'm not a fan of.

    I'd also dump Chameleon colossus but I just don't think it fits with Doran very well. Dies to too many of your one-sided sweepers (retribution of the meek, wave of reckoning, austere command, and potentially Punishment for 4, which happens more often than you'd think:P).

    He also gets gimped by ensnaring bridge, meekstone and marble titan, which I think synergize very very well with Doran as well.

    I'd skip the paladin guy as well.

    * I have seen Doran as big as 25/25 with a sword of fire and ice and lightning greaves. The Forgotten Ancient's ability doesn't target, which is very nice.
    Posted in: Commander (EDH)
  • posted a message on [[M14]] Voracious Wurm
    Seems like it'd be good in an extort deck and treated like a 3 (or 4) drop.
    Posted in: New Card Discussion
  • posted a message on [[Competitive]] So I Herd U Liek Permanents? (Maelstrom Wanderer)
    Some thoughts:

    1) into the web of war and concordant crossroads and fires of yavimaya, maybe anger of ogre battledriver (when that comes out). This deck begs for haste.

    2) sages of the anima is bonkers with sylvan library and pretty amazing with this deck as is.

    3) in my Momir Vig version of this deck I play four spells: Genesis wave, primal surge, creeping renaissance, and praetor's counsel. I'd at the least add Praetor's counsel. it's so, so good and would help you come back from some kind of post-surge blowout).

    4) Craterhoof Behemoth seems like a gimme in this deck. Also, Terastodon might be nice.

    Might consider a scroll rack as well. being able to stick all your creatures in hand on top of your deck seems good.
    Posted in: Multiplayer Commander Decklists
  • posted a message on Looking to build a FUN interactive deck for multiplayer. What are YOU playing?
    I'm running:

    Kiki-Jiki combo shenanigans
    Momir Vig genesis wave/primal surge elf tribal (primarily)
    Wort token shenanigans with vicious shadows/into the web of war/other token enablers.
    Doran wall tribal (mostly, with some voltron)
    Arcum Dageneratesson

    I'd say the most fun is Wort right now, with Momir Vig being the second. Doran is my goto - it's slow, steady, reliable and all around decent.

    Kiki-Jiki is just stupid as a general. Any two of about 20 different cards combo, and most of the rest tutor up combos.
    Posted in: Commander (EDH)
  • posted a message on [[M14]] Magic 2014 Underwhelming
    Like any set where there aren't lands there's a disproportionate number of very solid playable rares/mythics that'll be 5-15 bucks:

    -Scavenging ooze
    -Mutavault
    -Darksteel Forge
    -Door of Destinies
    -All of the planeswalkers are playable in at least something
    -Archangel of Thune

    And there's a ton of EDH playable deliciousness -- Scourge of Valkas in either Kaalia or Dragonstorm, Rise of the Dark Realms as a stupid black bomb, Shadowborn Demon as removal in a black deck.

    It's a bit of a sleeper but I predict Goblin Diplomats will be key in a lot of janky EDH combo decks - it's easily tutorable with goblin tutors, cheap, and you can make people swing at your various creatures that do dumb things when they block (e.g. Phyrexian Obliterator).
    Posted in: New Card Discussion
  • posted a message on [M14] Thoughtseize
    [edit - Zig beat me to it:P ]
    Well, millstone appears to have been downgraded to uncommon based on the pic in the gallery.
    Posted in: Speculation
  • posted a message on [[M14]] Pyromancer's Gauntlet
    Seems to synergize very well with past in flames as a late game finisher I guess. Past in flames - pillar x2 for 8. Don't expect most burn decks let it drag out that long though and pif is rotating out shortly.
    Posted in: New Card Discussion
  • posted a message on Chandra in M14 might be.... good?
    I'm hopin' for a sorcery/instant tutor on -1/-2, and anything else is gravy Smile
    Posted in: Speculation
  • posted a message on speculation (legendary dual lands)
    I'd expect lots of people would play 2 and risk the long odds of winding up with two over the course of the game (pretty slim in modern especially), versus the odds of hitting one being pretty solid.

    And having one is a huge value when you've got 8 fetches that can pull it. Odds of it coming out are pretty high Smile
    Posted in: Speculation
  • posted a message on [[M14]] Liliana's Reaver
    I don't think there is a lot of room for non-hasted non-evading 4drops with this kind of body in most competitive decks, but I could be wrong.
    Posted in: New Card Discussion
  • posted a message on That one General
    Quote from ISBPathfinder
    He is a lot of fun and generally people don't freak out about him quite as much as they do Sigarda and Uril. Plus he trolls people. How much more can you ask for Smile


    I wonder if there're enough trolls to make a troll tribal Smile Hmm. "This is my troll deck," usually has other connotations.
    Posted in: Commander (EDH)
  • posted a message on That one General
    I find Thrun, the Last Troll really compelling for some reason. Probably make something with him at some point.
    Posted in: Commander (EDH)
  • posted a message on Shadowborn apostle edh. White or blue?
    Vicious Shadows might make the list if you went black/red (maybe so you could haste the demons?). Maybe with Fecundity.

    Bloodbond march looks pretty amazing. for sure Smile

    Black/green/red might be the way to go. Not that many blue synergies.
    Posted in: Commander (EDH)
  • posted a message on Shadowborn apostle edh. White or blue?
    I've been looking at the apostles as tools to fuel "whenever a creature dies" effects. E.g.

    Vela the Night-Clad is my pick as a general.

    Then uh, some of the following with Thrumming Stone:
    Black Market
    Blood Artist
    Butcher of Malakir
    Grave Pact
    Deathgreeter
    Falkenrath Noble
    Ogre Slumlord
    Pawn of Ulamog
    Quest for the Gravelord
    Rotlung Reanimator

    And the mill demon, the card draw demon and the tutor demon of course.



    * White black would be very nice with cauldron haze Smile
    Posted in: Commander (EDH)
  • To post a comment, please or register a new account.