As the title states I’m looking at the interaction between the two. With Lantern of Insight out does it let the player who is casting Ad Nauseam to see the top of the deck during each flip? Part of me thinks the whole spell needs to resolve before the top card is revealed, another part of me saw the ruling with Green Sun’s Zenith and noted the top card was revealed between the search and shuffle. Thanks!!
I heard LSV saying there is a distinct difference with day/night mechanic vs werewolf mechanic. From what I’m seeing they pretty much seem the same. No spells causes the werewolves to flip (become night) and two spells flips them back to the front side (back to day).
The big difference is when it’s night things come etb as the backside.
I know that Muldrotha, the Gravetide lets you play and MDFC card that is a land on the backside. What about something like Glasspool Mimic. If I already play a creature card from my graveyard can I still select it to play the landside?
There is no denying that Sheldon has done great things for this format. I believe those great things were necessary in the beginning. At this point in commander I think it needs to go further, I am sure the RC is aware of “problem cards” that cannot be outed by the “social contract” of commander. Would it hurt to try banning a card and see what happens then unban it? Would it hurt to unban a card because it was banned based off old meta or small sample size? Probably not but until him and his original group are gone it’s going to stay this way
What is the ruling for this? I thought it would not recognize the backside of the card. While paying arena cube I was able to play the MDFC green bolt land from the top of my deck.
Using card tags is mandatory in the Magic Rulings forum. Please check your private messages to learn how to use them. I've added them for this post.
-MadMage
I recently tossed out a thread and it appears many people are not happy with the way the RC approaches the banned list. Now after this whole walking dead fiasco it is clear they are making a lot of people unhappy.
Its a crazy idea, I know it would be extremely hard to manage this but what if the community could come together and make our RC, meaning our own banned list (done via voting through straw pull or something like that). The common idea is this is a community driven format, let’s make it that. We can just rename the format EDH-community format?
Again just spitballing this idea. Not trying to get people fired, just seeing what our opinions are.
I’ll give Sheldon and his group a little credit for promoting the format in its hay days but I seriously doubt they were a huge contributing factor to the popularity of the format.
Either way I think they need to take a look outside their tiny metagame
After watching some videos from SCG with Sheldon is anyone else particularly bothered by their reasoning? To me the rationale is “in our small play group we found this to be true”. I find it extremely disturbing that we have the rules committee basing their decisions off an extremely extremely small sample size.
Here are some of the videos in particular that raised some red flags:
The big difference is when it’s night things come etb as the backside.
E.g. Khalni Ambush
What is the ruling for this? I thought it would not recognize the backside of the card. While paying arena cube I was able to play the MDFC green bolt land from the top of my deck.
Using card tags is mandatory in the Magic Rulings forum. Please check your private messages to learn how to use them. I've added them for this post.
-MadMage
Its a crazy idea, I know it would be extremely hard to manage this but what if the community could come together and make our RC, meaning our own banned list (done via voting through straw pull or something like that). The common idea is this is a community driven format, let’s make it that. We can just rename the format EDH-community format?
Again just spitballing this idea. Not trying to get people fired, just seeing what our opinions are.
Either way I think they need to take a look outside their tiny metagame
Here are some of the videos in particular that raised some red flags:
https://youtu.be/kCzZbgsasYg
https://youtu.be/dGK8S94omcU
https://youtu.be/3oeTEhizjQQ
https://youtu.be/jtrD61cPPlo
https://youtu.be/LoY37QAOhII
Am I overreacting to their rationale or is it legit?