- ImpalerShrike
- Registered User
-
Member for 10 years, 1 month, and 27 days
Last active Thu, Sep, 28 2017 18:23:31
- 0 Followers
- 339 Total Posts
- 82 Thanks
-
ImpalerShrike posted a message on Is it time to allow Planeswalkers as Commanders Officially?I'm going to also offer a "no". I do not believe commander is the place to allow planeswalkers to lead decks. I feel planeswalkers commander should be a separate or variant format because it would need to maintain it own ban list for cards like Sorin Markov and Doubling Season and certain Proliferate cards or else the format would quickly degeneratePosted in: Commander (EDH)
-
ImpalerShrike posted a message on Selvala 1.0 vs 2.0I played both for a while but after a few games I realized how similar they were and took explorer returned apart because they were both elfball decks and heart of the wilds would almost always go off faster. However if you like to interact stick with w/gPosted in: Commander (EDH)
-
ImpalerShrike posted a message on Who are the good Energy generals?I feel like a general that has artifact synergy will be the best choice for an energy deck because most of the best energy cards are artifacts as are most of the best proliferate cards. Muzzio, Visionary Architect; Arcum Daggson; Sydri, Galvanic Genius; Karn, Silver Golem; and Sharuum the Hegemon all seem good for an energy deck, particularly the ones with blue for proliferate overlap.Posted in: Commander (EDH)
-
ImpalerShrike posted a message on Meren or Jarad? Deck Help EDHI agree with xoth, meren is better in your build due to all the etb's you're running. For a Jarad deck I'd expect more "ramp into worldwide worm" kinda stuffPosted in: Commander (EDH)
-
ImpalerShrike posted a message on Would Brisela Human "Tribal" Be Viable?I think it would absolutely be viable. Just realize that the "humans" play much better as "soldiers" or "knights" because that's what most of the human lords are and that's what most of them effect. With angels backing them up it should be a decent deckPosted in: Commander (EDH)
-
ImpalerShrike posted a message on Custom cards in EDHThat's why no one gets to use the legendary they made in my local league. It also helps balance things as no one will make something busted for fear of having to play against it. We do D20 rolls to establish pick order with the caveat that you can't pick your own. Sometimes we add a challenge, like each one is a different color id, or weird tribes, etc. One of the most fun was "missing" legends for characters who never got a card.Posted in: Commander (EDH)
-
ImpalerShrike posted a message on Massacre Wurm vs Demon of Dark Schemes (edit: Poll added)If I could only choose 1 I'd choose the demon. Flying is super relevant and preferable to an additional point of power, and the resurrection ability should always have some juicy targets in a multiplayer game. The life loss on wurm is only better in corner scenarios where you manage to wipe a token army or it etb's multiple times in a turnPosted in: Commander (EDH)
-
ImpalerShrike posted a message on UG Evolve EDHIn my experience, evolve is not a good mechanic for edh. It requires a lot of set-up and is very easily disrupted by commonly played cards. It's also very narrow. Maybe consider u/g proliferate instead? It would use a lot of similar cards but it is inherently more powerful and versatilePosted in: Commander (EDH)
-
ImpalerShrike posted a message on Custom cards in EDHWe have a local league that uses custom legends in the cmdr spot. There is also an entirely custom made commander cube around here that I've played. With the custom legend league each participant designs a new legend and then we draft them so nobody gets the one they designed. I think this sort of use of custom cards is fine because its equalPosted in: Commander (EDH)
-
ImpalerShrike posted a message on Help me find my friend a commander!I'd like to suggest Radha, Heir to Keld. Lots of different directions to take her when building (ramp, aggro with tricks, elves, etc) and she is relatively non threatening. Also having a mana dork in the command zone is always cool. And she's cheap on cmc and $Posted in: Commander (EDH)
-
ImpalerShrike posted a message on Mono Green Control - Nissa, Vastwood SeerI want to second hall of gemstone, that card is awesome. I used to play a mono g control deck that ran dosan, the falling leaf as the commander. Nev's disk and oblivion stone are additional high quality wipes. You should make room for at least the disk if the stone isn't in your budgetPosted in: Multiplayer Commander Decklists
-
ImpalerShrike posted a message on Possible Mana Sinks for Either Selesnya or GruulHow did this get to post 8 before helix pinnacle? Squall Line is a great win con that nobody ever really expects from the green deck. Burn the whole pod to deathPosted in: Commander (EDH)
-
ImpalerShrike posted a message on Ninja mastery (Theory Crafting)I forgot to mention that you should also run a lot of rocks, the deck gets very mana intensivePosted in: Commander (EDH)
-
ImpalerShrike posted a message on SUGGESTIONS NEEDED, unconventional wins via B/W Life-swapping/suicideSince you are already running soul conduit and Garza's assassin I'd recommend murderous betrayal and lurking evilPosted in: Multiplayer Commander Decklists
-
ImpalerShrike posted a message on Commander 2016 FoilsThis is good news. I always get foil versions of my commanders if they're availablePosted in: The Rumor Mill
- To post a comment, please login or register a new account.