2019 Holiday Exchange!
 
A New and Exciting Beginning
 
The End of an Era
  • posted a message on Celestine, temporary control, and removal
    Quote from Rezzahan »
    No. When the Executioner's trigger resolves you still control Celestine. Because Threaten's effect ends in the cleanup step, while Executioner enters in the end step. Though you can just sacrifice her to your own Executioner and take out another of your opponent's creatures as well.


    I see, thank you for the answer.

    Does it mean if I revive a Zealous Conscripts instead, targeting Celestine, I'd still have to give Celestine back to the opponent that turn?
    Posted in: Magic Rulings
  • posted a message on Celestine, temporary control, and removal
    Celestine, the Living Saint/[c]

    I gain control of Celestine temporarily with Threaten, attack with her, gain life then revive a Merciless Executioner. Assuming she's my opponent's only creature, I can choose to give her back first then apply her trigger revival, then Executioner's trigger would force my opponent to sacrifice her, correct?
    Posted in: Magic Rulings
  • posted a message on Anikthea and Battle for Bretagard

    The ability fully resolves and makes the token, before you sacrifice the Saga (CR 704.5s).


    Good to know that, it actually helped me understand other Saga as well. Thx!
    Posted in: Magic Rulings
  • posted a message on Anikthea and Battle for Bretagard
    Anikthea, Hand of Erebos/Battle for Bretagard

    If I turned BfB into a zombie token with Anikthea, and then BfB's last chapter triggers, do I get to clone BfB again prior to sacrificing the saga?
    Posted in: Magic Rulings
  • posted a message on Soundwave
    Quote from MadMageQc »


    2) You'll be able to exile and copy multiple cards, but Soundwave will only convert once from those multiple Sonic Spy triggers, because of this rule :
    701.28f. If an activated or triggered ability of a permanent that isn't a delayed triggered ability of that permanent tries to transform it, the permanent does so only if it hasn't transformed or converted since the ability was put onto the stack. If a delayed triggered ability of a permanent tries to transform that permanent, the permanent does so only if it hasn't transformed or converted since that delayed triggered ability was created. In both cases, if the permanent has already transformed or converted, an instruction to do either is ignored.
    However, what will happen is that Sonic Spy will convert into Superior Captain from the first Sonic Spy trigger to resolve, and then if you also cast a spell with the second Sonic Spy trigger to resolve, since Soundwave is now Superior Captain, it will trigger one of the two abilities of Superior Captain and convert it back. The converting stops there for what results of this one combat damage step, though; if there are still other Sonic Spy triggers waiting to resolve, those still can't convert Soundwave because of 701.28f.


    Thank you for your answer. That's certainly a good rule to prevent endless transform per turn.
    Posted in: Magic Rulings
  • posted a message on Soundwave
    Soundwave, Sonic Spy/Soundwave, Superior Captain

    1) The front says, "You may cast the copy without paying its mana cost. If you do, convert Soundwave." Does it still convert even if I chose not to cast the spell?

    2) What happens when a trigger on one of the face trigger multiple times? For example, when I damage more than one opponents with my tokens while having Sonic Spy in play.
    Posted in: Magic Rulings
  • posted a message on WOE - Wilds of Eldraine worldbuidling and story
    Quote from Ryperior74 »
    Im wondering about eriette

    I'm wondering if this is rowan and wills birth mom? (She resurrected)


    I agree with you on this. I love her mantle is made of broken mirrors.

    So here is Ashiok, hiding on Eldraine. I'd think Ashiok would be on New Phyrexia to witness the end of Norn, or perhaps Ashiok was, just planeswalked to Eldraine right after.

    Ashiok and Oko are made for each other. The greatest fear of any sensible people is "betrayal", and the two love those.
    Posted in: Magic Storyline
  • posted a message on Elenda and Azor and EoT triggers
    Elenda and Azor

    If there are multiple triggers at the beginning of end step, some with draws (like Monarch), I presume I can stack the triggers so by the time I resolve EoA I get more tokens?
    Posted in: Magic Rulings
  • posted a message on Faerie Mastermind/Sword of Fire and Ice
    Thank you!
    Posted in: Magic Rulings
  • posted a message on Faerie Mastermind/Sword of Fire and Ice
    Faerie Mastermind/Sword of Fire and Ice

    I attack with a creature equipped with Sword, deals 2 damage to Mastermind and draw a card, does my opponent gets to draw a card before Mastermind dies?
    Posted in: Magic Rulings
  • posted a message on Wrathful Red Dragon and Doublestrike
    Wrathful Red Dragon/Silverblade Paladin

    If a 2/2 soldier paired with Paladin, then it attacks and deals first strike damage to Red Dragon. Red Dragon deals 2 damage to kill Paladin.

    Will the soldier still deal a second attack or no? My guess is no.
    Posted in: Magic Rulings
  • posted a message on MOM/MAT- March of the Machine + Aftermath Worldbuilding, Lore and Story

    Probably. You can run "into" someone without penetrating them. And if the idea was penetration, then specifying the pommel would be a weird choice. Here "into" means direction "perpendicular towards the object", not extend "until it is inside".

    Going by the top two dictionary definitions:
    You thought (1): "expressing movement or action with the result that someone or something becomes enclosed or surrounded by something else", but they meant (2): "expressing movement or action with the result that someone or something makes physical contact with something else".

    Quote from Thamosh »

    Too literally. The amount of force it would take to drive a blunt round object like a pommel into someone's skull would leave them without a good chunk of their skull.


    I honestly would've preferred that. The original invasion was great because it left a very bitter taste, this one is a fairytale by comparison. Death on its own doesn't become a good tragedy, it's the part about dashing hope (Chandra) that makes the stake high.

    Quote from caulkwrangler »
    Theros getting christanized was definitely the funniest part.


    Will they start a Roman prosecution of Elspeth, Daughter of Serra? Tibalt is too dead to give a kiss. (Again, what a waste.)

    Quote from Flisch »

    Agreed. I think WotC has not yet understood that a protagonist does not necessarily need to be the most powerful character in a story.


    Yet, they're doing a Lord of the Rings set. *Eyeing Frodo*
    Posted in: Magic Storyline
  • posted a message on [MOC] Gavin’s hints for the commander decks
    Quote from Ryperior74 »


    well this clearly unmasks what the plane for the knight tribal deck is now it was Zhalfir


    Zhalfir without red though? Very odd.
    Posted in: The Rumor Mill
  • posted a message on MOM/MAT- March of the Machine + Aftermath Worldbuilding, Lore and Story
    Quote from Thamosh »


    Elspeth hit her with the back end (the pommel) of her sword, she didn't pierce her.


    "she drives the pommel of her golden sword INTO the back of Nissa's head"

    A weapon inside another person's head, regardless of sharpness, usually means death. Maybe I read it too literally?
    Posted in: Magic Storyline
  • posted a message on MOM/MAT- March of the Machine + Aftermath Worldbuilding, Lore and Story
    The story is questionable.



    Heliod being killed within a sentence is just rough, and while Kaya is a skill ghost-killer she was also facing a god, something that stays alive by the power of its followers. Making Theron gods so vulnerable to one mortal, a cut on their "ethereal" throat, is just... I don't know, lame? It's like how Ob Nixilis just swoop in on Capenna and suddenly defeated all five families with ease.

    And where's Caberetti?

    Being the smartest Phyrexian, Jin certainly picked the worst time to rebel. Plot armor much?

    Elspeth pierced Nissa's head from behind, that'd kill most phyrexians on the spot, and somehow she was alive for days to be cured? I suspect this is WotC's compensation for killing Chandra-Nissa relationship, back in the days when the company had less courage.

    Melira, being the cure and prevention of Phyresis, never had any chance to shine until her death. You'd think with all the invention rebels came up with they would've alchemically create a cure out of her now. Admittedly, I find it poetic that Karn gave up his spark on Zhalfir and will resides there, a plane from the first invasion with his best friend. We just need Jhoira there.

    As much as I'm happy to see Ajani alive and well, it does the story a disservice, much like how DC/Marvel kills off characters but always revive them, readers will stop feeling for the loss.

    WotC should stop building climaxes for a set then end it with such luke warm finale.
    Posted in: Magic Storyline
  • To post a comment, please or register a new account.