2019 Holiday Exchange!
 
A New and Exciting Beginning
 
The End of an Era
  • posted a message on Copy Enchantment and Clever Impersonator v.s. Bestow
    Copy Enchantment/ Clever Impersonator

    I saw different answers for this one. So when Copy Enchantment copies a bestow creature in aura form (say, Celestial Archon), it copies the aura status of Archon and I could enchant a creature with it, and when the enchanted creature dies CE becomes an Archon as well.

    However, the same post I saw stated that if it's Impersonator that's copying the Archon, it only copies the creature part of it i.e. CI enters as the 4/4 flying first striker.

    What's the correct answer?
    Posted in: Magic Rulings
  • posted a message on Dominaria United Story, Worldbuilding and Lore
    Ajani's good eye widened with horror. He shook his head in denial and mouthed no, no, no gripping his own arms as if he could restrain the Phyrexian fibers beneath his skin and prevent them from emerging. But they engorged, ripping open muscle and fur, to reveal a sleek, dense Phyrexian musculature that had been installed beneath his own.

    Chapters of nothingness, but this one really hits me. The struggle and suffering is palpable.
    Posted in: Magic Storyline
  • posted a message on Dominaria United Story, Worldbuilding and Lore
    The new Weatherlight crew is a far cry from the original team. Shanna should be banned from even evoking her ancestor's name.
    Posted in: Magic Storyline
  • posted a message on Maro Teasers for Domnaria United
    Quote from Ryperior74 »


    Squee, Multani, and...


    Replace Multani with Karn, I think. Karn was a Weatherlight crew too.
    Posted in: The Rumor Mill
  • posted a message on Dominaria United Story, Worldbuilding and Lore
    I'm NOT happy about Ertai's return. While Phyrexian is capable of reanimating corpses, Ertai's body would be dust within the first century of his death, what COULD they possibly reanimate after centuries? And I don't believe Phyrexians are capable of summoning souls (in Ertai's case he should be far, far gone by now). My guess is that the Ertai we see here is just a replica, similar to Hanna at one point, not a reanimation.

    Regardless, it's rather pointless to put Ertai back into the pic. While I understand WotC's purpose of evoking nostalgia, the arrogant mage had done his part, and can current writers handle old characters faithfully? Base on this chapter, I cannot imagine.
    Posted in: Magic Storyline
  • posted a message on Dominaria United Story, Worldbuilding and Lore
    Quote from Ryperior74 »
    So they have a hard time believe karn but then teferi steps in and mentions jin on kamigawa and Vorinclex on kaldheim…and they instantly believe him…man karn can't get a break. (And worse teferi didn't even tell that tezzert is the source with the planar bridge



    It's understandable. When an info is mentioned a second time it tends to serve as a supporting evidence, which makes the first more believable. Besides, people constantly live in denial, it's much easier to believe a terror in neighbor's house than believing it to be in your house.

    I'm more surprised that the group couldn't handle a few Phyrexians at the negotiation room.
    Posted in: Magic Storyline
  • posted a message on Dominaria United Story, Worldbuilding and Lore

    The story felt pushed. Karn can be emotional, yes, but this reckless isn't like him.

    Consider Sheoldred is dormant, how long had it been her? Each Phyrexian faction appears to have plan of their own, I wonder how that'd play out in the upcoming war.

    Good to see Rona again, I wonder how many of the Dominaria legends would return this time. Weatherlight crew v.2 was slightly disapointing, I hope they do better this time.

    Karn couldn't planeswalk. In the comic, Tezz utilized the Immortal Sun to trap planewalkers to Ravnica again, would Phyrexians create a version of their own, as they did with the World Tree?
    Posted in: Magic Storyline
  • posted a message on Dominaria United Story, Worldbuilding and Lore
    Isn't it a little brash and inconsiderate, for Amazon to leak stories via preview? Perhaps the people doing it didn't realize how severe the story spoiler is.

    Oh, why must all my favorite PWs suffer. Frown Frown Frown

    Quote from Spaz350 »

    Honestly, I wouldn't be surprised if that connection to Tamiyo and the story circle is what gets him targeted for compleation. Tamiyo going for those she knows.


    So Narset might be next? Going after all those with better wisdoms eh.
    Posted in: Magic Storyline
  • posted a message on Aboleth Spawn and target-less triggers
    Aboleth Spawn

    I presume if the copied trigger is something dealing with the card itself, like, "Put a +1/+1 counter on ~", Aboleth Spawn would just assume the role of ~?
    Posted in: Magic Rulings
  • posted a message on Double Strike + Trample via equipment, w/ Multiple Blockers + Death Effect
    Thanks for the reply.

    Quote from Rezzahan »


    3a) You assign a creature's combat damage in order of the damage assignment order, that was chosen when blockers were declared. To get to the next creature in line, the creature before it has to have been assigned lethal damage first. You can assign more than lethal damage to any creature, so long as you assign all of the damage dealing creature's power in damage. You can't pull punches, but you can choose where they land. So yes, you can stop at any point in the conga line of death and spare the following creatures. Only the first creature in line you can't avoid. Trample doesn't change that at all.

    3b) Since the 5/5 is blocked by two creaturtes with combined toughness 6, and it doesn't have deathtouch, there is no trampling over on the first strike regardless of how combat damage is assigned. The seond combat damage step would let it trample over the remaining blockers, but only if it still has both trample and double strike.


    In regards to 3b, I was asking if I deal all 5 damage to one of the blockers on first strike, would trample rdamage oll over (since both have 4 or less toughness), or can I only trample over when the last blocker(s) is assigned lethal. I assume there's no trample damage on first combat damage since the other blocker is still alive.
    Posted in: Magic Rulings
  • posted a message on Double Strike + Trample via equipment, w/ Multiple Blockers + Death Effect
    Sorry for a mouthful title, this is a complicated question.

    1a) I have a 5/5. It equips Shadow Spear and backed by Silverblade Paladin, so it has both DS and trample.
    1b) The 5/5 attacked, blocked by a Molten Primordial and a Duergar Hedge-Mage.
    1c) Opponent controls a Hofri Ghostforge, which means whichever blocker dies would create a copy.

    2a) If Primordial died first, can the created copy take control of Paladin, thus remove the second strike?
    2b) If Hedge-Mage died first, can the created copy destroy Spear, thus remove trample damage from rolling over?

    3a) Can I avoid killing both of them at the same time, by applying all 5 damage from either strike onto ONE of the blockers, despite having trample? (My guess is yes)
    3b) And in doing so, no trample/roll over damage on the first strike?
    Posted in: Magic Rulings
  • posted a message on Hofri and Storm of Souls
    Hofri Ghostforge
    Storm of Souls

    When creatures brought back by Storm of Souls die, does Hofri create the copies as 1/1 or as their original p/t?
    Posted in: Magic Rulings
  • posted a message on Connive and Sun Titan
    So it doesn't matter if the Sun Taitan clause is a "may". I remember asking a similar question regarding Land Tax and Opposition Agent about the searching, but LT doesn't have a target requirement.
    Posted in: Magic Rulings
  • posted a message on Connive and Sun Titan
    Sun Titan/Kamiz, Obscura Oculus

    If I arrange the triggers, resolving Kamiz's connive trigger before Sun Titan's trigger, is it possible for Sun Titan to reanimate whatever I discarded, or does Sun Titan needs to have a target right as its trigger goes to the stack?
    Posted in: Magic Rulings
  • posted a message on A Garden of Flesh- Another one shot story featuring Elesh Norn
    Quote from 5colors »
    Quote from cyberium_neo »
    Funny they use the pronoun "they" for Ashiok. I thought Ashiok is beyond pronouns.


    Nope just unknown/ambiguous along with what species Ashiok is.

    For an outside reason as well, Ashiok was created when they/them wasn't as widely known by the general public as pronouns used by people who don't identify in the gender binary and using they/them is now used to better reflect this (and better writing flow as it can be clunky just to use Ashiok all the time).


    I prefer Ashiok without a pronoun, it shows how much Ashiok doesn't give a S about norms.

    I suspect Ashiok is a djinn, as seen with Inniaz, the Gale Force.
    Posted in: Magic Storyline
  • To post a comment, please or register a new account.