This is why I posted my build here, so that I could gleam wisdom from expert advice.
You are indeed correct in the listing of 3 CMC creatures I had in my previous build. I removed them to make room for cheaper/ better spells. They were indeed the Xathrid Necromancer and a Herald of Torment.
Thanks very much for clearing up the mishmash that my deck currently is, and why it's better to pick one strategy and stick with it. I wish to go for the Mid range, mono black devotion deck. As such, I'll price shop around to see what the costs of your suggested cards would be, and rebuild appropriately.
Greetings. I literally just began playing paper Magic again a couple of weeks ago. I used to play FNM at my local gaming store a number of times last year, however due to a hectic work schedule have been unable to do so recently.
I've still kept involved in MtG via the iPad iteration, DotP. I'm currently making an effort to get back into paper, or IRL MtG.
Future Additions:
I do plan on including a pair more of Thoughtseizes, if I could find any cheaper than the current going rate of ~$15.00. I'd also like to supplement and additional 3 X Hero's Downfall, and it's somewhat slightly more manageable thanks to a lower price point than the Thoughtseize. Also, contemplating adding an additional Underworld Connections.
Strategum:
The main battle plan would be to bum rush with tiny, but effective creatures in the form of the Cacklers and Assassins. The Rats are also supremely effective, by growing quickly to uncontrollable proportions. If the initial bum rush fails, or stalls, then I can move on to the backup of dropping bombs in the forms of the Demons and Merchants. The whips help to stabilize and keep the underworld connections as a viable option.
Greetings. I literally just began playing Magic again a couple of weeks ago. I used to play FNM at my local gaming store a number of times last year, however due to a hectic work schedule have been unable to do so recently.
I've still kept involved in MtG via the iPad iteration, DotP. I'm currently making an effort to get back into paper, or IRL MtG.
As such, I purchased this event deck, and traded for/ purchased a number of additional cards.
I was hoping for constructive critique of my current build.
I am (essentially) a n00b, and would appreciate any aid.
Also, if this is in the incorrect section, or if I've managed to break any rules, please forgive me, and instruct me on how to rectify my unwitting error(s).
And thanks for explaining your points thoroughly. It helps to put things in context.
You are indeed correct in the listing of 3 CMC creatures I had in my previous build. I removed them to make room for cheaper/ better spells. They were indeed the Xathrid Necromancer and a Herald of Torment.
Thanks very much for clearing up the mishmash that my deck currently is, and why it's better to pick one strategy and stick with it. I wish to go for the Mid range, mono black devotion deck. As such, I'll price shop around to see what the costs of your suggested cards would be, and rebuild appropriately.
Thanks very much for the helpful advice, mate!
I've still kept involved in MtG via the iPad iteration, DotP. I'm currently making an effort to get back into paper, or IRL MtG.
As such, I purchased this Underworld Herald Event Deck, and traded for/ purchased a number of additional cards.
I was hoping for constructive critique of my current build.
I am (essentially) a n00b, and would appreciate any aid.
Underworld Herald:
A MBD Deck built for [Standard][Casual] 1 V 1 play
Land: 24
Swamps X 20
Temple of Silence X 4
[mc]1[/mc]
Rakdos Cackler X 2
[mc]2[/mc]
Thrill-Kill Assassin X 4
Pack Rat X 4
[mc]4[/mc]
Desecration Demon X 4
[mc]5[/mc]
Gray Merchant of Asphodel X 4
Spells: 18
[mc]1[/mc]
Thoughtseize X 4
[mc]2[/mc]
Bile Blight X 2
Doom Blade X 3
[mc]3[/mc]
Hero's Downfall X 4
Underworld Connections X 2
[mc]4[/mc]
Whip of Erebos X 3
Sideboard:
[mc]1[/mc]
Dark Betrayal X 2
Duress X 2
[mc]2[/mc]
Pharika's Cure X 2
Ultimate Price X 2
Creatures: 7
[mc]1[/mc]
Rakdos Cackler X 1
Tormented Hero X 3
[mc]2[/mc]
Rakdos Shred-Freak X 3
Future Additions:
I do plan on including a pair more of Thoughtseizes, if I could find any cheaper than the current going rate of ~$15.00. I'd also like to supplement and additional 3 X Hero's Downfall, and it's somewhat slightly more manageable thanks to a lower price point than the Thoughtseize. Also, contemplating adding an additional Underworld Connections.
Strategum:
The main battle plan would be to bum rush with tiny, but effective creatures in the form of the Cacklers and Assassins. The Rats are also supremely effective, by growing quickly to uncontrollable proportions. If the initial bum rush fails, or stalls, then I can move on to the backup of dropping bombs in the forms of the Demons and Merchants. The whips help to stabilize and keep the underworld connections as a viable option.
I've still kept involved in MtG via the iPad iteration, DotP. I'm currently making an effort to get back into paper, or IRL MtG.
As such, I purchased this event deck, and traded for/ purchased a number of additional cards.
I was hoping for constructive critique of my current build.
I am (essentially) a n00b, and would appreciate any aid.
Creatures – 26:
1 Cost:
Tormented Hero X 3
2 Cost:
Rakdos Cackler X 4
Pack Rat X 4
3 Cost:
Herald of Torment X 3
Xathrid Necromancer X 2
4 Cost:
Spiteful Returned X 3
Desecration Demon X 3
5 Cost:
Gray Merchant of Asphodel X 4
Spells - 11
1 Cost:
Thoughtseize
2 Cost:
Bile Blight X 2
Doom Blade X 2
3 Cost:
Hero's Downfall X 1
4 Cost:
Whip of Erebos X 1
Lands – 23:
Mutavault X 4
Swamp X 19
Also, if this is in the incorrect section, or if I've managed to break any rules, please forgive me, and instruct me on how to rectify my unwitting error(s).