Your lands seem too good to me compared to basic lands. The best comparison would be the pathway lands. Compared to these, these have basic landtypes, can tap for colorless and don't have to choose between providing one color of the other. The only downside being these have a restriction on the producing the off-color mana, but it's a pretty light restriction and could be an advantage if you don't have enough mana sources of the off-color.
I also agree w others that Burning Aurora is not red. Red could do a version of this with life payments though.
- Registered User
Member for 7 years and 17 days
Last active Sat, Jun, 12 2021 22:32:26
- 0 Followers
- 3,621 Total Posts
- 663 Thanks
May 23, 2021Posted in: Custom Card CreationQuote from Kryptnyt »I think when the Audience dies, you should gain life equal to its power. You're not putting a show on for free, right? Get paid.
In addition to what rowanalpha said, I'd note that life gain is not in mono red.
Apr 3, 2021DJK3654 posted a message on [STX] Daemogoth Titan and Containment Breach— r/MagicArena previewsPosted in: The Rumor MillQuote from The Lord of Tresserhorn »I just noticed there's actually a scale human in the picture.
Yes, it's BIG.
Weirdly, it also looks very peaceful. Like it is carefully making its way through the forest, taking care to not topple any trees.
Well it is a green demon
Apr 1, 2021DJK3654 posted a message on [STX] Devastating Mastery and Secret Rendezvous Aus Gamers Previewhttps://www.ausgamers.com/news/read/3634575/magic-the-gatherings-strixhaven-expansion-to-bring-the-devastation-and-morePosted in: The Rumor Mill
You may pay rather than pay this spell's mana cost.
If the cost was paid, an opponent chooses up to two nonland permanents they control and returns them to their owner's hand.
Destroy all nonland permanents.
You and target opponent each draw three cards.
Pretty solid looking planar cleansing variant. And there's the white card draw spell. Kinda meh, but the art on that card....hmmmmm…..
Mar 29, 2021Posted in: The Rumor MillQuote from Dontrike »That flavor text is basically "while you were getting girls I was studying the blade."
Nothing personnel kid.
Quote from Guesswork »"We gimped your hexproof."
"Fine, we gimped it again. Pray we don't gimp it any further."
I guess this is partly why they kept hexproof.
Mar 29, 2021DJK3654 posted a message on [STX] Elite Spellbinder— Paulo Vitor Damo da Rosa previewThe 2 mana tax here may 'only' be 2 mana, but considering that you get to look at your opponents hand and target a specific card, this can seriously disrupt your opponents gameplan. You can stop your opponent from playing a key card, especially larger cards, within the next couple turns, maybe even longer if they don't draw enough lands. Let's say they are playing genesis ultimatum, now they need to wait for a whole nine mana. That could potentially seriously put your opponent on the back foot while waiting for their swing card to come through. Or maybe they have a single mass removal and you give your aggro/tempo deck two whole extra turns to try to beat down your opponent with creatures.Posted in: The Rumor Mill
I like this is a new area for white as well. Natural extension of White's abilities.
Feb 24, 2021The land side of these is quite strong alone. Compare to the mythic cycle from ZNR. The lands here seem like they might be better than those and all of the other land sides of the ZNR cards are weaker than those. The problem being that the more powerful the land side the weaker the other side needs to be, and you don't want the nonland side to be too overcosted or it's not as fun to play with.Posted in: Custom Card Creation
Feb 24, 2021I second rowanalpha on everything.Posted in: Custom Card Creation
Choice and interactivity are good, but more is not always better. Especially for a set mechanic. Layer on more complexity and strategic depth on top of the mechanic, don't build too much into it. It limits your options for what kind of things you can add onto cards with the mechanic and prevents you from making nice simple commons with the mechanic.
Feb 23, 2021DJK3654 posted a message on Journey- Variant of unreleased 'Quest' mechanic from ZND, ELD & ZNRPosted in: Custom Card CreationQuote from megatog201 »Really like the idea. White one does seem like the least useful. I'd say they should be played and remain in exile facedown until all conditions are met. That way the opponent can't see what exactly is coming. If you have a few of them in each color then it could throw the opponent off and they may not guess correctly.
As rowanalpha said, I think face down is a bad idea. Your opponent seeing what's coming isn't much of a problem, especially compared to the difficulties involved in tracking the conditions of a facedown card.
Feb 21, 2021DJK3654 posted a message on [STX] Commands, Mystical Archive, and the first look at Commander 2021Posted in: The Rumor MillQuote from Marek14 »Here's a question: is Strixhaven the name of the school? If so, we don't actually know the name of the plane? Or is the plane named after the school itself?
Strixhaven is the school, Arcavios is the plane.
Feb 16, 2021Best guesses based on the individual namesPosted in: The Rumor Mill
Colour balanced, mixed ally/enemy-
Assuming enemy colours-
Assuming ally colours-
Ally colours feels probably the hardest to match to me.
Feb 12, 2021DJK3654 posted a message on Maro confirms strixhaven is no Reskin of any version of “magic school” and a bottom up setPosted in: The Rumor MillQuote from JuiceBOX »Quote from SimicNuggets »Relax, he didn't say anything about not using tropes. He's just saying it's not a reskin of an existing property. Like how Theros is a reskin of greek mythology rather than being their own take on mythology as a medium.
Will it have deus ex machina spells, and important objects to drive the story, and guilds/houses/dark wizards/fantastic beasts? Yes. Because this is their take on the genre and those are tropes that exist in the genre. He just literally means (and literally says) there isn't going to be reskins aka intentional parallel versions of any one of the existing magic school takes.
The problem here is that people already associate wizard schools with things outside of MTG. I am reluctant to say that this won't feel like Harry Potter or something similar, because humans are creatures that observe patterns and make associations based on them.
It will feel like Harry Potter *and* something similar. It will feel like Harry Potter in the same way other magic school stories feel like Harry Potter and the same way Harry Potter feels like other magic school stories.
I'm not sure what the confusion is about. Remember Innistrad? That was also a genre-based setting. It felt like Dracula, and the Wolfman, and Frankenstein and a number of other stories of the like. But it wasn't a reskin of any of those stories, it was it's own world and story that used a combination of familiar elements. Expect something similar here.
Quote from JuiceBOX »Really, there isn't a good way to do this without it having a Harry Potter feel anymore than it is possible to remove Mindflayers from the feel of Cthulu, Theros from Greek Mythos, Ixalan from Un'Goro, etc.
See, Ixalan is actually a perfect comparison here, because it's not based on Un'Goro, it's based a classic subgenre of 'lost world' stories including Marvel's Savage Land, the Dinotopia series, and the original Lost World by Arthur Conan Doyle.
- To post a comment, please login or register a new account.