No but I am not worried about Puddle, it will sort itself out if he lied.
Uuuufgggghhhhhhhhhhhxhskxnakxjs
But if he isn't town, and he isn't bound to be truthful, why would he not lie? I almost wish you told me he was bound to be truthful, just so we'd have one confirmed townie.
Unvote. Vote Snurfy for trying too hard to blend in
But why did you announce that you used it on Puddles? As it appears neither you nor him have the intention of elaborating on the interaction. What did you hope to achieve by letting it be known that it was used and whom it was used on, but not saying what it did?
[quote from="snurfy8 »" url="http://www.mtgsalvation.com/forums/outside-magic/mafia/596878-animal-mafia-day-1-welcome-to-finchtopia?comment=256"]
Also, I come from the school of thought that a Townie SHOULD be a little more reserved on day one. To ME, coming out guns blazing picking at words and declaring the day done and over with is absolutely scummy as hell. You should not be that sure in your reads 7 pages into a game.
Ugh. Yeah. It really rustled my jimmies in XKCD when Iso was basically like, "_____ is scum. Game over." as soon as the game started, and wouldn't be convinced otherwise until I claimed I was in a masonship with that person. Bleh.
[quote from="snurfy8 »" url="http://www.mtgsalvation.com/forums/outside-magic/mafia/596878-animal-mafia-day-1-welcome-to-finchtopia?comment=256"]
The fact that Seppel thinks that just running with this will work out for the town is stupid. The fact that the town is buying into this line of reasoning is stupid. When I flip town I hope to god you people have the sense to lynch that fool on the spot. He knows what he is doing. He knew the way I would react because he watched me react the same way in my first game (Deathspeaker). He knows EXACTLY what he is doing and how to play this to get me mislynched, which he freaking knows is a mislynch. He is scum.
I remember feeling this exact way in Iji Mafia 2 with Sir Karn attacking me when I said " any other townsperson" instead of "any of the rest of us". I was certain he was contriving evidence against me for the purpose of mislynch.. because that's what Mafia do, they mislynch townspeople. As it turns out, we were both town. So yeah. I think a lot of the beginning arguments on day one are town against town. Statistically, that would make sense because there are more townspeople. Anyway, if you provide some of your T/S lits I will find this all reasonable enough to unvote you.
[quote from="snurfy8 »" url="http://www.mtgsalvation.com/forums/outside-magic/mafia/596878-animal-mafia-day-1-welcome-to-finchtopia?comment=256"]
This is all pointless anyway, as I sent something to Sir Chris that will be able to clear me.
So, when you get a chance Sir Chris, please let them know what I gave you…
I'm not sure, but I think you replaced in for me in XKCD So if you want to share any T/S lists from that game, cool.
Share a T/S list from Deathspeaker?
or literally any T/S lists that you have made outside of this game at all ever
Pretty sure Seppel is faking. This is likely scum Seppel. Specifically, there's a tone to his posts as town I'm not seeing here. Unvote, Vote Seppel
In Iji Mafia 2, TownSeppel did this same thing using theory and applying it to people's word choice. How would you determine whether he's faking it or not? Be more specific than "specifically there's a tone".
The theory is pretty on point. Scum tend to hedge more. Town still does, but less. The thing I'm wary of is that it could also be just something Hunt personally does more.
And I would have done that as town too. Maybe not go as far as to say everyone on your wagon was scummy, but you were pretty damn town that game.
Not so much this game though. You seem to be taking it a lot more seriously. Same goes for Sepriel.
To be fair, that was my first game. I'm trying to take it more seriously now.
But why did you announce that you used it on Puddles? As it appears neither you nor him have the intention of elaborating on the interaction. What did you hope to achieve by letting it be known that it was used and whom it was used on, but not saying what it did?
So.... I missed that statement in the OP after reading it over several times, as well as misunderstanding/misremembering my role pm. At first I didn't even remember having that part, then after reading it, I was thinking the "ability" I have was so plain and insignificant that it wouldn't be considered a "power role". But... I guess everything is a power role. So there we have it. Let's pretend I'm not dying of embarrassment right now.
Uuuufgggghhhhhhhhhhhxhskxnakxjs
But if he isn't town, and he isn't bound to be truthful, why would he not lie? I almost wish you told me he was bound to be truthful, just so we'd have one confirmed townie.
Unvote. Vote Snurfy for trying too hard to blend in
Did he have to answer 100% truthfully?
Ugh. Yeah. It really rustled my jimmies in XKCD when Iso was basically like, "_____ is scum. Game over." as soon as the game started, and wouldn't be convinced otherwise until I claimed I was in a masonship with that person. Bleh.
I remember feeling this exact way in Iji Mafia 2 with Sir Karn attacking me when I said " any other townsperson" instead of "any of the rest of us". I was certain he was contriving evidence against me for the purpose of mislynch.. because that's what Mafia do, they mislynch townspeople. As it turns out, we were both town. So yeah. I think a lot of the beginning arguments on day one are town against town. Statistically, that would make sense because there are more townspeople. Anyway, if you provide some of your T/S lits I will find this all reasonable enough to unvote you.
Why did you say "someone" instead of "Huntzilla"?
and so like what if you acknowledged me or the things I'm saying to you or something
Share a T/S list from Deathspeaker?
or literally any T/S lists that you have made outside of this game at all ever
Provide counter-evidence.
1-2 = 1 to 2 in the context you were using it in
1/2 = one half, universally
In Iji Mafia 2, TownSeppel did this same thing using theory and applying it to people's word choice. How would you determine whether he's faking it or not? Be more specific than "specifically there's a tone".
To be fair, that was my first game. I'm trying to take it more seriously now.
You're an interesting item
But why did you announce that you used it on Puddles? As it appears neither you nor him have the intention of elaborating on the interaction. What did you hope to achieve by letting it be known that it was used and whom it was used on, but not saying what it did?
Can you post T/S lists from your scum and your town games?
@Chris: I feel like I already play that way.
Why did you announce that you used the item?
Oh wait nvm jk