Forestsguy - Love the idea of creating copies of your 2/2s to make an incentive to play more. Almost feel like it doesn't have to be "your creature" as blue can copy from anywhere. Flashback seems stapled on though...
Marglehaven - it works, but is pretty boring... also putting a 1/1 counter on a 2/2 creature makes them 3/3s which would negate any other 2/2 synergies going on in your deck
Volrath - seems like a really fun commander, but probably way too powerful for that costing as it would be policing the board and reducing all damage by half. Also, shouldnt it be creatures you control? as this could create some scary synergies with token/elf opponent decks
Subject16 - Love the callback to Shirei, who cared about 1/1s...
Void_Nothing - Interesting "Shock Hate" I feel like the static ability is uneeded though as the other two abilities are really powerful by themselves and as a 2/2 that comes ddown on turn 2, swinging for 4 on turn 3 and having removal protection is huge.
Honorable Mentions Go to Volrath and Void_Nothing
Winner is Subject16, for a really cool enchantment with a unique effect.
Path to the PantheonX4
Legendary Enchantment
Path to the Pantheon is All Colors
When ~ enters the battlefield you may search your library for X God cards. Reveal them and place them on top of your library.
Whenever you cast a God spell draw a card.
IIW: Update a Card from Alpha (make sure to mention the card you are updating)
Bumbog, Boggart Blightbringer2RR
Legendary Creature - Goblin Warrior
At the beginning of combat on your turn, creatures you control named ~ gain +1/0 and trample until end of turn.
At the beginning of your end step, create a token that is a copy of ~
~ is unaffected by the legendary rule.
1/3 "Bumbog, meet Bumbog, Bumbog and Bumbog..." - Bumbog
Curse of Charity2URR
Enchantment - Aura Curse
Enchant Player
At the beginning of your upkeep, Target opponent gains control of target nonland permanent you control.
IIW: Unstandard Card (A Standard legal card with a mechanic previously used in an Un Set)
I could see a future Unset experimenting with "write on" cards that let you write whatever you want on the card, within certain parameters. For example, letting you write any total power/toughness combination equal to 5 (0/5, 1/4, 2/3, 3/2, 4/1, 5/0) in the p/t box, writing any creature type in the subtype spot (even making up a new creature type if you like), or even naming creature cards/tokens (so you could name a Dragon "Charlie" for example). Rules text would be a little trickier, but maybe there could be spaces where you can write words or numbers. They could introduce "N Mana" costs, where you write a number in the mana symbol which then determines the value of N effects on the card, kinda like X but with the ability to set a fixed converted mana cost. For example, a red sorcery that costs NR and deals N damage to any target. You could write 4 on the N symbol, which will then cause the spell to cost 4R and deal 4 damage to any target.
This sounds awesome... I want a legendary creature that I can name my name and play as my commander!
Marglehaven - it works, but is pretty boring... also putting a 1/1 counter on a 2/2 creature makes them 3/3s which would negate any other 2/2 synergies going on in your deck
Volrath - seems like a really fun commander, but probably way too powerful for that costing as it would be policing the board and reducing all damage by half. Also, shouldnt it be creatures you control? as this could create some scary synergies with token/elf opponent decks
Subject16 - Love the callback to Shirei, who cared about 1/1s...
Void_Nothing - Interesting "Shock Hate" I feel like the static ability is uneeded though as the other two abilities are really powerful by themselves and as a 2/2 that comes ddown on turn 2, swinging for 4 on turn 3 and having removal protection is huge.
Honorable Mentions Go to Volrath and Void_Nothing
Winner is Subject16, for a really cool enchantment with a unique effect.
I will plan on judging Monday.
Path to the Pantheon X4
Legendary Enchantment
Path to the Pantheon is All Colors
When ~ enters the battlefield you may search your library for X God cards. Reveal them and place them on top of your library.
Whenever you cast a God spell draw a card.
IIW: Update a Card from Alpha (make sure to mention the card you are updating)
Legendary Creature - Goblin Warrior
At the beginning of combat on your turn, creatures you control named ~ gain +1/0 and trample until end of turn.
At the beginning of your end step, create a token that is a copy of ~
~ is unaffected by the legendary rule.
1/3
"Bumbog, meet Bumbog, Bumbog and Bumbog..." - Bumbog
IIW: 2/2 Tribal
Curse of Charity2URR
Enchantment - Aura Curse
Enchant Player
At the beginning of your upkeep, Target opponent gains control of target nonland permanent you control.
IIW: Unstandard Card (A Standard legal card with a mechanic previously used in an Un Set)
Good job, you're up.
Hard One, Had to dig deep for that one...
This sounds awesome... I want a legendary creature that I can name my name and play as my commander!