@Seraph: I don't think ace was ever in any real danger. Everyone focused on you because they saw you as scummy. I didnt have to paint you any thing.
Quote from the fallen one »
pyrodwarf really threw him a line, which seems like a definite scum buddy act, I still didn't like the fact that he pretty much babied Seraph out of the vote.
I would like to think I would be a more slick scumbudy than that. Several people were still voting him, I just let him slide out of my vote.
I'm still kind of unsure as to inffering affiliations via lynch results
I'm definitly looking at JqlGirl and Seraph, Seraph is probably my main suspect for scum right now, his actions have been scummy through and through, but pyrodwarf really threw him a line, which seems like a definite scum buddy act, I still didn't like the fact that he pretty much babied Seraph out of the vote. One of my biggest suspicions is now pyrodwarf since I am thourely convincind that Seraph is scum.
He very well may be scum, I just saw him doing the same thing I had done. I didn't want our D1 lynch to just be "kill the newbie"
Sraph, what do you have to say for your self? No more newb card for you.
I'm just worried if he is scum that I will be linked to him. I had considerd this late D1, but what's done is done.
Well, I've been looking over day one and I'm willing to bet that ungluate man wasn't the only scum on seraph's wagon. I thought Zadria's post 51 was a bit scummy, going for an easy lynch. I had meant to ask him why he voted, but I typed rook instead of zadria... I wonder if rook's responce affected zad's?
Seraph responds in his post 52:
Quote from "seraph prime" »
I thought I was being subtle about it, but I guess everyone has me painted as scum. Who knows, but methinks after everyone kills me you should keep an eye on ace and pyrodwarf. The seem to have targeted me very quickly with an exit strategy as soon as Ace was close to being lynched...anyhoose.
What was he being subtle about? Is the "go ahead, lynch me" comment always a scum tell? As I said I said some thing very similar in my first mafia game, but I don't want to let seraph ride that.
If unglutarman is mafia, i doubt he'll have much of a say/ opinion in thier affairs. However rook seems to have a defensive attitude already. Combine this with his passive aggresive tone an, well, like i said does not ring pro town to me.
What are we learning if seraph is townie? What are we learning if he is scum?
If he is town, people just say dang and start looking at rook for pushing his wagon so hard. If he is scum, well we get lucky and then what?
I'm just thinking that we should go for someone that is more scummy on day one, and go for a newbie on day 2 or 3 if he shows more scum tells.
what makes you think he'll be a vocal mefia member? He is probly to bored to even suggest someone for a night kill. My vote is still with him, and i am starting to suspect rook as one of his scum buddies. It is the tone of his messages, i dont like passive aggresive, it just dosen't seem pro town to me.
If we can do better, who do you propose? I think a D1 mafia kill is pretty good.
Vote: ungulateman For reasons stated by ace, but i will say it again. He has dodged a question directed twords him and his posts are very thin, much like his "reason" for his most current vote. Now we have to ask him why he thinks TFO is evil, or if he is just attempting to bus one of his scum pals.
we have yet to hear from a few players. What do people that aren't chiming in think? At this point I really hope Seraph is not scum, but if he were I would never listen to another newb excuse. Maybe one of the reasons he got in his mood was because a scumbuddy voted for him?
I would like to believe that he is just a new mafia player, I made simmilar mistakes in my first game. What I don't like to see is him just rolling over like this. More often than not, "Go ahead and lynch me" type comments are scummy, no? The main reasons I unvoted him is because, like I have said, I acted the same way in my first mafia game when I was suspected scum on day one.
Zadira, what is your reason for voting Seraph?
BTW, rook, I meant to ask zadria this question first as you explained your vote in your post, while zadria is seeming to just kick him while he is down.
I thought I was being subtle about it, but I guess everyone has me painted as scum. Who knows, but methinks after everyone kills me you should keep an eye on ace and pyrodwarf. The seem to have targeted me very quickly with an exit strategy as soon as Ace was close to being lynched...anyhoose.
Vote Ace. At least someone should vote for real scum.
I don't know where this comes from, as I was mainly following rook's line of thought. What is this exit strategy of ace's that you bring up?
Ok, so lynch me. Here I'll draw all attention onto myself. I'm still going to watch this thread so that I can see how to play so that when I get my second game I'll learn from my mistakes.
this is pretty much what I said in my first game of mafia.It is really easy to get butt-hurt in your first few games.Just don't take it personally and try to move on.
unvote I got lynched in my first mafia game for doing what you did, so I can relate. Now I am at an impasse, Seraph has recieved my "get out of lynch free" card... for the moment at least. ungulateman's 3rd vote on ace seems innocent enough. as for ace having a quick exit strategy, what do you mean? Rook mentiond that ace had quite a few votes, then I agreed with him, then ace agreed with me.
I would like to think I would be a more slick scumbudy than that. Several people were still voting him, I just let him slide out of my vote.
I'm still kind of unsure as to inffering affiliations via lynch results
Sraph, what do you have to say for your self? No more newb card for you.
I'm just worried if he is scum that I will be linked to him. I had considerd this late D1, but what's done is done.
It was just the "go for the easy target" kind of move. It just didn't feel right.
Seraph responds in his post 52: What was he being subtle about? Is the "go ahead, lynch me" comment always a scum tell? As I said I said some thing very similar in my first mafia game, but I don't want to let seraph ride that.
What are we learning if seraph is townie? What are we learning if he is scum?
If he is town, people just say dang and start looking at rook for pushing his wagon so hard. If he is scum, well we get lucky and then what?
I'm just thinking that we should go for someone that is more scummy on day one, and go for a newbie on day 2 or 3 if he shows more scum tells.
If we can do better, who do you propose? I think a D1 mafia kill is pretty good.
Zadira, what is your reason for voting Seraph?
BTW, rook, I meant to ask zadria this question first as you explained your vote in your post, while zadria is seeming to just kick him while he is down.
I don't know where this comes from, as I was mainly following rook's line of thought. What is this exit strategy of ace's that you bring up?
this is pretty much what I said in my first game of mafia.It is really easy to get butt-hurt in your first few games.Just don't take it personally and try to move on.