2019 Holiday Exchange!
 
A New and Exciting Beginning
 
The End of an Era
  • posted a message on Vintage Cube Card Explained
    Thanks so much! I will be working on revisiting some of my earlier explanations and expanding my list.

    Right now I'm working on providing a better explanation on the draw - 7 in the cube and how to effectively build your deck/ curve to full take advantage of these effects in a limited environment.

    Posted in: Articles, Podcasts, and Guides
  • posted a message on This or That discussion.


    Definitely Soul Shatter > Eat to Extinction. Soul Shatter is IMO the best Hero's downfall option

    Court of Ire needs to be tested. My inclination is Court of Ire is stronger than Frenzy.

    - Frenzy is an incredibly strong build around for red aggro/ artifact Mud decks. Any deck with lower curve/ high mana is good for frenzy. I might bring this card back - but I cut it because of all the draw 7s already in the cube.
    - Court of Ire seems to be at its best in red based midrange/ wildfire decks. Losing Monarchy isn't the worst - being able to shoot 2 damage per turn is a pretty good - even if it comes at the expense of a card.

    I'm not a fan of either Dream Eater/ Frost Titan. I would give it to the titan for its 6/6 body.

    Glint-Sleeve unless you have an enchantment package.

    Posted in: Cube Card and Archetype Discussion
  • posted a message on This or That discussion.
    I actually want to make a general comment about red two drops:

    Gore-House Chainwalker is what I use as the baseline - 2 mana for 3 power. Single Red, splashable in any aggro/ spells matter deck. Very stable - does not require additional land drop, does not opponent to have spells in graveyard, no double red requirement, no requirement for additional instant/ sorceries/ no requirements for bloodthirst etc.

    The consensus in this forum (for both constructed and limited) is the strength of red based aggro deck is more based off the number of relevant aggro cards drafted and less on the quality of the creatures themselves.

    I find if you're not sure which creatures to play, I would just play a few more vanilla aggro two drops like:

    Robber of the Rich
    Gore-House Chainwalker

    These two cards are a stable two drop that could fit into a lot of decks. Sure they may not be the best, but they do a decent job.

    Quote from tylorlilley »
    With Skyclave Apparition absolutely killing it in modern, I've been wanting to get him into my 540 power cube somehow. How have people who included him found him?

    Is Skyclave Apparition better than Fiend Hunter or Gideon Blackblade for example? Only so many 1WW options to consider swapping him for...


    I hate to have to rank these three ... they are all good!

    Fiend Hunter has some application in a flicker based deck where you can stack the ETB flicker trigger on top the exile - giving you a two for 1.

    Blackblade is a very resilient card in aggro decks .. If I have to pick, I would cut Blackblade as he feels a bit more narrow as Hunter/ Skyclave are more flexible in archetypes
    Posted in: Cube Card and Archetype Discussion
  • posted a message on [720][Powered] wtwlf123's Cube
    Quote from wtwlf123 »
    Well making infinite creatures is pretty deece, so I can't say that it's weak with Intruder Alarm.

    So ya, it's like a filler card ...that's also part of an infinite combo. More like a Voltaic Key kind of inclusion than a Dragon Fodder.

    Have you actually played with/against the card in cube or are you just speculating? I was pretty skeptical, but the card has played far better than it looks. Ambushing attackers in green is surprising, making sorcery-proof Order fodder, works well in Ambusher flash shells, and it gets silly out of control when you have an army of critters at your disposal. I thought it was gonna be butt, but it's surprisingly versatile.


    Well I have a policy with cube cards and its very simple: If white wolf recommends it, its prob pretty good. I'll give it a try next time.
    Posted in: Cube Lists
  • posted a message on Commander Legends HOT TAKES!
    Really great article! It's really great that people are writing more articles on cube these days.
    Posted in: Articles, Podcasts, and Guides
  • posted a message on [Lucky Paper] Zendikar Rising Cube Prospective Results
    I want to thank you for collecting these results.

    Luminarch Aspirant - this has been a surprisingly strong card - especially given how she can add +1/+1 the turn she comes out and additional +1/+1 the turn she attacks (essentially a baseline 3/3 for 2) which is incredibly strong. She's the exact type of card white decks in cube are looking for - help pump early drops, help with board stalls, help with +1/+1 synergies, and most importantly adds decisions to mono white.

    Roil Eruption - feels like an incredibly underwhelming card and I really would put Lightning Strike as the baseline for red burn. I recommend playing stuff like Roast or Magmatic Sinkhole - but this is prob more of a preference as an Modern/ Legacy Twin player where the 5 damage out of red was invaluable.

    Deliberate/ Hagra Mauling - feels way too overpriced.

    Nighthawk Scavenger - I have a preference to avoid vanilla style creatures.

    Soul Shatter - This is actually an incredibly strong card. Generally the highest CMC is what you would like to remove anyways - but it also nabs Blightsteel Colossus.
    Posted in: Articles, Podcasts, and Guides
  • posted a message on [720][Powered] wtwlf123's Cube
    Quote from wtwlf123 »
    Sprout Swarm is an enabler for Polymorph and a combo card with Intruder Alarm. It's also a halfway decent token support card, and can provide sacrifice fodder in various decks. I treat it as an Xcc card, since it has so many different places in the curve it can be played at. All my Xcc spells I place at the top of my curve, which is why it's listed at 7.

    Chord was cut after underperforming for a while. Fine card, but much weaker than the other creature tutors, IMO. Similar with Evolution. Fine card, but worse than the other options.


    Sprout Swarm feels incredibly weak, even in intruder alarm shells. This feels like a "okay everywhere, never great". Similar to something like Thraben Inspector or Dragon Fodder
    Posted in: Cube Lists
  • posted a message on Vintage Cube Card Explained
    Thanks so much!

    I wasn't playing standard myself when a lot of these cards were printed. This has been a huge learning for myself.
    Posted in: Articles, Podcasts, and Guides
  • posted a message on Vintage Cube Card Explained
    Just want to mention that I’m also reading and enjoying this! Thanks for the hard work.


    Thanks so much! I really like working on these articles myself
    Posted in: Articles, Podcasts, and Guides
  • posted a message on Vintage Cube Card Explained
    Thanks for reading it!

    Its really great to hear that people are reading this. I'll be working on this over the holiday quarantine to add 20-30 cards to this list.

    I will definitely cover Balance, Upheaval and Mishra's Workshop. I'm also planning to find some sample deck lists with the namesakes to help the explanations and I'll add some numbers of mana consistency and curve for some of the relevant cards.

    I've been learning a lot about these archetypes and cards myself while writing these articles - I've actually using my own guide when drafting the melira/ aristocrats combo to determine which color combinations I should be in.
    Posted in: Articles, Podcasts, and Guides
  • posted a message on Can expedition map find mdfc
    Playing a modal double-faced card starts with choosing one face.

    Finding one does not.


    Oh thanks - I didn't know that. That's REALLY interesting.
    Posted in: Magic Rulings
  • posted a message on ProsBloom Combo Cards: Squandered Resources and Cadaverous Bloom
    Hey. I think its great that people are experimenting in cube.

    Cadaverous Bloom and Squandered Resources are both cards I've thought about before, but I just feel they're a bit too narrow and there a slightly stronger alternatives.

    For Squandered Resource:

    Rain of Filth
    mana seism
    Lake of the Dead

    These cards are a slightly better improvement over Squandered Resource. I've thought about playing a 1 off Rain of Filth and Lake of the Dead before to help with the storm/ reanimator decks but eventually dropped these two as I realized the fast mana for cube is already sufficient and if I really wanted to push storm +1 Grim Tutor was the better option to go.

    For Cadaverous Bloom:

    This is an interesting card and I was looking for a second card to supplement Dream Halls - a card I really like. However, being in Black-Green is already a problem - you really need to be a blue deck to be able to fully use these cards.

    Fortunately, there are several similar effects:

    Wilderness Reclamation - Good for X spells - Nexus of Fate
    Dictate of Karametra - good for Blue-Green Hide Tide/ Hyper Ramp

    I've been really wanting a Yawgmoth's Bargain/ Necropotenance in my cube for a while ... but the problem is just does worse than the new blue draw 7. (Echoes of Econs, Commit - Memory)

    I might bring yawgmoth;s bargain back as a payoff for black-white lifegain.
    Posted in: Cube Card and Archetype Discussion
  • posted a message on WBg Lifegain.dec
    I actually want to reopen this thread. I don't think we need a full blown lifegain soul sister's style archetype, but I like the idea adding a few more lifegain payoffs:

    Already in cube:
    - Bolas Citidal
    - Sylvan Library
    - Dark Confidant
    - Heliod, Sun Crowned
    - Archangel of Thrune
    - Birthing Pod

    Could potentially add:
    - Necropotence
    - Ajani's pridemage
    - Ajani, Strength of the Pride
    - Lone Rider

    I think the cube naturally has enough rate cards that incidentally would gain life. I don't like the soul sister's direction - that is too parasitic and could be too oppressive to burn.
    Posted in: Cube Card and Archetype Discussion
  • posted a message on [720][Powered] wtwlf123's Cube
    Quote from philo.jh »
    I see you cut Jace, Mirror Mage for Jace Beleren. Did you find Beleren better or did you add it back in because of the mill card from CMR? I've had Mirror Mage in my cube for a while, but haven't gotten a lot of reps with him. My gut says Jace Beleren is the superior card.

    Cheers,
    Jacob


    Draw Denial is becoming a more important archetype in cube right now - both with the notion thief/ narset variants but also to hold back the Monarch.

    Quote from Cythare »
    Aw man, he was my cut for Tangled Florahedron, but I'll fiddle around with finding a replacement cut for Mayor too. Thanks!


    I have to think more about the humans archetype - I don't feel the payoffs are really worth it and its relatively parasitic.
    Posted in: Cube Lists
  • To post a comment, please or register a new account.