Quote from rantipole »I don't like the cut of Broodmoth but the rest seems really solid.
Quote from calibretto »Agreed with rant. I don't care for the Broodmoth cut either. Even more so, I'd prefer Basri's Lieutenant to Emiel. I also think I'd cut Shalai over the moth, especially if you hadn't gotten much play time with the moth yet.
Quote from armando.zuffi »
1 - Pelt Collector vs Experiment One vs Kessig Prowler ? What order ?
2 - Alesha, Who Smiles at Death vs Pia Nalaar vs Rampaging Ferocidon ? What order ?
3 - Devoted Druid vs Incubation Druid ?
4 - Wildborn Preserver vs Mayor of Avabruck ?
Quote from IMorphling89 »The absolute floor of bouncing a thing and drawing a card for 3 Mana is not bad
Quote from IMorphling89 »I think Cultivate and Kodama's Reach are better than this card because
1) They provide awesome mana fixing, which this doesn't do
2) They thin your deck of two lands, which is great for future draws.
This card's ok, but I'm not really interested in playing it.
Quote from armando.zuffi »1 - Zealous Conscripts vs Glorybringer vs Terror of the Peaks ? What order ?
2 - Blue draw section: Boon of the Wish-Giver vs Waker of Waves vs Deep Analysis ? What order ?
3 - The First Iroan Games vs Garruk's Harbinger ?
4 - Forsake the Worldly vs Leonin Relic-Warder ?
Quote from opterown »
Pick 1 - Imposing Sovereign or Seasoned Hallowblade
Pick 1 - Robber of the Rich or Heartfire Immolator
Quote from Foxantes »1)Elspeth, Knight Errant vs Elspeth,Sun's Nemesis?
2)Top 3 white 5 drops? (counting Gideon Jura if he makes your top3)
3)Looter il-Kor vs Teferi, Master of Time?
4)Voracious Hydra vs Questing Beast?
Quote from JuiceBOX »I would usually agree, but a form of built in protection kind of melts that argument for me. I like that I can play him on the top end of a deck and to remove him still achieves my aggressive objective and if he sticks around it is going to close the game. I don't think it is as good as Thundermaw Hellkite but I do think that it is better than Glorybringer.
Quote from calibretto »Quote from Metamind »Initiate > Paladin = Eidolon > Skyfisher
Out of curiosity, what makes you rank Skyfisher so low?
Quote from Metamind »Initiate > Paladin = Eidolon > Skyfisher
Quote from armando.zuffi »1 - 2cc: Kor Skyfisher vs Accorder Paladin vs Glory-Bound Initiate vs Eidolon of Obstruction ? What order ?
2 - 3cc: Ranger-Captain of Eos vs Benalish Marshal vs Mirran Crusader vs Hanged Executioner ? What order ?
3 - 4cc: Gisela, the Broken Blade vs Leonin Warleader ?
Quote from wtwlf123 »It's not. A lot of the test drafting was done on CubeCobra, which only supports regular drafts. All of the companions were easily built around if drafted early. Some are harder than others, but they're all very doable, and they're all very good.
Quote from opterown »I don't know about you but the decks I build on CubeCobra tend to be far better than the decks I get in paper draft - I suspect bot and human drafting patterns are different enough that it's not really representative.