2019 Holiday Exchange!
 
A New and Exciting Beginning
 
The End of an Era
  • posted a message on MaRo's Gatewatch Announcement
    This is good news. Planeswalkers tend to open up new strategies and the gatewatch were eating up slots (e.i. Gideon). Not sure how this affects the story since it should allow a more focused story but pacing might be a bit difficult.
    Posted in: Magic Storyline
  • posted a message on Creature That Work As A Land.. (need input on short and concise oracle text)
    So a Dryad Arbor with an ability?

    Phiipan Spirit
    Land Creature - Forest Dryad Spirit (R)
    2G, Discard this card: Create a 2/2 green Dryad Spirit creature token. Activate this ability only any time you could cast a sorcery.

    2/2

    Not exactly what you had in mind but it's the closest to it I can think of.
    Posted in: Custom Card Creation
  • posted a message on Amonkhet General Discussion
    Brilliant story. I'm just excited we might get to see the remaining three gods in the new set.
    Posted in: Magic Storyline
  • posted a message on Speculation, Wishes, and Hopes for the MMO
    Quote from Apoquallyp »
    If done correctly, a MtG based MMORPG could be one of the best games to be released in a long time.

    Sadly, the MMORPG market is no longer very large that it would be justified investing a large amount of resources into an MMORPG game. So, it will probably end up like many so-called "WoW-killers" of the last decade. Fun to play for a short while, but the flaws quickly come to light, so the game is forgotten very quickly.


    Agreed. Since card based combat is out of the question, I see one other possibility. Remember how Witcher 3 had Gwent in it? Why now make something similar where people can play WoW type MMO and enjoy a TCG aspect within the game.

    IMO, the only realistic "WoW-killer" MMO can be no other than Pokemon MMORPG.
    Posted in: MTG MMO
  • posted a message on Soul of... sequel cycle
    Maybe gold colored cards since we already have mono colored ones?

    Soul of Amonkhet 4WB
    Creature - Avatar
    Lifelink
    4WB: Create two 2/2 black and white Zombie creature tokens.
    4WB, Exile Soul of Amonkhet from your graveyard: Create two 2/2 black and white Zombie creature tokens.
    6/6

    Feels a little too similar to soul of zendikar
    Posted in: Custom Card Creation
  • posted a message on 3 Cards from Hour of Devastation - Nicol Bolas, Black Sorcery and Samut Planeswalker
    2 blocks in a row with a 4-ability walker, anyone thinking this is a new trend? This bolas isn't bad tbh. In terms of power level, it's pretty close with the original one but geared towards multiplayer (flavor hit!)
    Samut, I think, was rushed. They probably originally had another gatewatch walker designed but replaced it with samut since people were getting bored of them. The card is mundane and you'd feel like her abilities would be closer to gideon.
    If the "Last Reckoning" is a cycle, we might just get to see some really good effects. These should be especially good in EDH given how common mana rocks are.
    Posted in: The Rumor Mill
  • posted a message on Magic events at HasCon including previews and exclusive promo cards announced
    Are these replacing SDCC promos? Or are we still getting our tourney legal promos each year?
    Posted in: The Rumor Mill
  • posted a message on Site Redesign Coming Soon!
    Any news about dark skin? Maybe someone can make a poll with suggested features/fixes the community wants so that mods can prioritize better. Maybe things like: Dark skin, mobile layout, front page reorganizing, etc...
    Posted in: Community Discussion
  • posted a message on Amonkhet General Discussion
    Quote from Dunharrow »
    Serious question - Do we know how Amonkhet is maintaining its population? Who is making babies if everyone is dying so young?

    The "abandoned" barracks from Samut's secret made me think that maybe the population is shrinking, thus why old barracks are out of use.

    Anyone think Grim Strider is one of the missing gods, a Bull-headed god maybe?


    It is mentioned in one of the previous stories that Bolas came 10-20 years ago and since then there has been no mating and all the natives are less than 20 years old.
    Posted in: Magic Storyline
  • posted a message on Harsh Mentor
    In modern, this card hits about 25% of any tier 1 deck. It represents a very harsh (pun intended) hate. My rough count based on the lists I could find on this site show something around 15 hits on average for any one deck with Affinity getting hit the most.
    Bant Eldrazi: 16 Hits
    RG Titan Scapeshift: 15 Hits
    Death's Shadow Jund: 16 hits
    Junk: 15 hits
    Gx Tron: 13 hits
    Affinity: 20 hits
    RG Breach: 12 hits

    I'm pretty confident this will see play in modern with its wide range of targets.
    Posted in: The Rumor Mill
  • posted a message on Harsh Mentor
    Quote from MTGS_User8233 »
    How is something an artifact, a creature or a land outside the battlefield?


    You are right, that this part of the sentence is redundant. However it increases clarity.


    New players are getting confused between "creature" and "creature card" is probably why this is worded the way it is.
    Posted in: The Rumor Mill
  • posted a message on Harsh Mentor
    Does this card play around Leyline of Sanctity. It doesn't say target so I'm guessing it does. If so, this card is even better than I thought.
    Posted in: The Rumor Mill
  • posted a message on Site Redesign Coming Soon!
    Quote from molster »
    does anyone have any colors they would like? the core theme wont be able to change drastically, but we could possibly pick a different color for the post bits, if there is something people like, instead of the off white we have now.


    Just by using the existing color scheme, I managed something in between. It's not perfect but I like it better than blinding white Smile
    Posted in: Community Discussion
  • posted a message on Site Redesign Coming Soon!
    Appreciate the effort put into the new design but allow me to suggest a few things:
    • Please bring back dark skin. One of the reasons I still frequent MTGS is the dark skin. I get to read/post a bit before sleeping without hurting my eyes. Same reason I didn't like the past few MTG market articles, too bright.
    • There is no point in putting the top 3 articles at the top of the main page when they are already below the spoilers bar. They take too much space, display half the article title, and the art is of lower quality (enlarged)
    • Instead of the "Featured New Article", which is promoted in 3 different places, you could show "Recent Forum Topics" with more than just 4 topics. After all, MTGS is a forum before everything else.

    Posted in: Community Discussion
  • posted a message on FETCHABLE Cycling Duals!
    It's nice to see lands with cycling enter modern. These might find a home in modern.

    Loving the art, especially the blue/purple lights behind the clouds.
    Posted in: The Rumor Mill
  • To post a comment, please or register a new account.