Mergatroid Jones - I like this, I feel it's really cool, and plenty in color. I like how each color has a function in the card, and I think you could have a lot of fun building around it.
Cardz5000 - I like this, but I feel there should be limits. I feel it's a little too easy to break. For example, if you equip this with anything granting it indestructible you have unlimited mana pretty quickly. The other thought is something like Rite of Passage. I like it, but it should limit itself to how many times in a turn it can do it.
JaceTheBodySculptor - I like trying to support an abzan weenie strategy. The problem here is he doesn't feel very black, with the other two abilities feeling a bit white and green. Overall solid, but a minor quip. At least to me I think he needs just a bit more.
Subject16 - This is a solid card. It feels pushed even, but with a mythic rare I wouldn't knock points off it for that. The only quip I could have with it, and it's minor, is I feel the first ability could come off as confusing for some. Very minor.
void_nothing - What an effect, very powerful! I don't know how good I feel about this guy, as he is just wreck sauce when he hits the board unless someone answers him immediately. At 9 mana I understand it should feel that way, but he feels primed to really be hated in Commander if nothing else. I really just don't know about the power level here, on one hand the cost is right for something ridiculous and it's fine with that body, on the other if you find a way to untap up quickly, then this should just be game as soon as played.
I think it's probably okay.
All things considered, this felt really hard. A very close one for pretty much everybody. Great job! In the end it really comes down to who I like best here. I think I have to give it to...
MERGATROID JONES!!!
The design here feels the most elegant to me, and honestly it's the one that most makes me want to play it. All the designs were good, but this one just screams some durdly fun, which I can get down with.
So next challenge is...
GERM TOKENS!!! Specifically he said living weapon, but with the caveat that you could do something else with them too.
Phara, Ender of all Sorrows - WUB
Legendary Creature - Avatar
Flying, Lifelink
When ~ enters the battlefield, exile target nonland permanent if you spent 3 or more mana to cast it.
When ~ enters the battlefield, you deal 6 damage to each opponent and gain 6 life if you spent 5 or more mana to cast it.
When ~ enters the battlefield, you win the game if you spent 11 or more mana to cast it.
4/4
Next - An Orzhov commander who encourages high risk, high reward gameplay.
1
Cardz5000 - I like this, but I feel there should be limits. I feel it's a little too easy to break. For example, if you equip this with anything granting it indestructible you have unlimited mana pretty quickly. The other thought is something like Rite of Passage. I like it, but it should limit itself to how many times in a turn it can do it.
JaceTheBodySculptor - I like trying to support an abzan weenie strategy. The problem here is he doesn't feel very black, with the other two abilities feeling a bit white and green. Overall solid, but a minor quip. At least to me I think he needs just a bit more.
Subject16 - This is a solid card. It feels pushed even, but with a mythic rare I wouldn't knock points off it for that. The only quip I could have with it, and it's minor, is I feel the first ability could come off as confusing for some. Very minor.
void_nothing - What an effect, very powerful! I don't know how good I feel about this guy, as he is just wreck sauce when he hits the board unless someone answers him immediately. At 9 mana I understand it should feel that way, but he feels primed to really be hated in Commander if nothing else. I really just don't know about the power level here, on one hand the cost is right for something ridiculous and it's fine with that body, on the other if you find a way to untap up quickly, then this should just be game as soon as played.
I think it's probably okay.
All things considered, this felt really hard. A very close one for pretty much everybody. Great job! In the end it really comes down to who I like best here. I think I have to give it to...
The design here feels the most elegant to me, and honestly it's the one that most makes me want to play it. All the designs were good, but this one just screams some durdly fun, which I can get down with.
So next challenge is...
GERM TOKENS!!! Specifically he said living weapon, but with the caveat that you could do something else with them too.
Good Luck.
1
Artifact
Next:
Blue Lotus
Broken Lotus
Lotus Obscurus
1
Legendary Creature - Avatar
Flying, Lifelink
When ~ enters the battlefield, exile target nonland permanent if you spent 3 or more mana to cast it.
When ~ enters the battlefield, you deal 6 damage to each opponent and gain 6 life if you spent 5 or more mana to cast it.
When ~ enters the battlefield, you win the game if you spent 11 or more mana to cast it.
4/4
Next - An Orzhov commander who encourages high risk, high reward gameplay.