Playing just few games here I think I don't have much to say in this matter, but this is also due to the fact I only played mafia for two years and few months now.
I don't think MU is a cold place, I always enjoyed the environement, possibly because my homeforum was Vbulletin until they switched to Xenforo late in 2018. I learned there a lot of things during the Mentor games and I still have in mind a game from February 2019 when I played with Achromatic. I think I admired his playstyle and his years of play were impressive for me at the time, and now after playing with this community I understand why I am feeling, like in that game, like a kid joining adults conversation every time when I am playing here. This is not a feeling related in any way with my real age, but with my mafia (game experience and capability) age.
I wish this community to keep playing and I will play here as much as I can from now on, here, on MC, on MU or wherever you decide to go.
My soul would go to MC, because Osie's effort in making that site welcoming for everyone pays off in a game environement easier to play in and very enjoyable.
The reverse of "what if MC will die as well" is what if the migration of MtGS there will make a stronger community, attracting players there?
MU has the fascinating tools and the subforums where several communities who lost homeforums are having games. I played on CFC an unusual game and I would always return to play there, and also I noticed GDS has an active community of players who know well each other from over a decade.
I think I agree with Rand, and follow the community to have the opportunity to play with them.
@WMU That post was meant to say I thought GJ was town. “is” becomes “be” in the pirate translator I was using.
The reason for my roleplay is that I tend to take mafia too seriously and wanted to try to have more fun with it like tom does.
I think the mafia team is within CC, tubba, Bur, Azrael, WMU, BoomFrog, Cantrip.
I try to have more fun in a game myself and one thing into that direction is taking it slower.
I am probably the only one who didn't understand your posts here, thanks for the clarification.
When I will finish to read all the posts I will post my own Poe.
I know I wasn't active, I can play today all day and make myself useful, same answer for everyone who put me in the Poe
I have to admit a tardiness in reading because again I tried to understand each post and I went back every time to the reference post.
I like what you said about meta in P#129 'I am a verbal/constant both in games and outside of them about not using meta', meta it's not set in stone and reads only based on meta are not usually accurate fmpov.
@Rhand - P#145 the RP makes again hard to understand what you want to say, for me your sentence there 'GJ be town' looks like a prod and if I am right I wish to know the intent behind it
@Vaimes - p#185 about KJ 'Innocent until proven guilty, is how I usually handle him.'
How do you usually find the proof for him being villagery or guilty?
Tammy's self meta is sustained by others from what I understood and this looks good, P#197 looked like she is focused on the game
From the first pages I liked Sloth, Tammy, GJ and KJ
Scum leans on Rhand (the RP makes posts hard to get) and Wisp
Can someone, actually like a few people give a summery of the game state? It seems wisp has claimed some kind of vampire,
Do you guys do read lists? I'd love to just see everyone give an ordered list of town to scum at this point, or link to a recent list if you already made one.
I don't want to come off as (more of) a dick, but read. 17 players giving you a read list, when we have under a week to lynch (and unlike MU, we function on majority, not plurality for the deadline, so no maj = no lynch). I am even quote on my own short list on this very page.
Summary of the game is that there hasn't been any real hard discussion. RVS - individual hunting - LW claiming neutral when he thought I was unfairly getting pressured, CC is the currently the most popular wagon via votes. Deadline in 6 days and some odd hours.
<snip>
@Wake
While I do hate his tone, I still mostly hate his posts
I don't remember from you to use this kind of read, I hoped you can give me something concrete but I understand thinking at your claim that you don't have a real motivation to solve.
<snip>
Don't remember why I quoted this but I am in favor of lynching scum rather than a claimed Neutral on D1.
<snip>
@WakeMeUp: Nice to meet you, as well. I don't play over on MU, but I do have one important question for you: Inside, When September Ends, or Before You Go Go?
<snip>
Agree with not lynching Wisp
Inside is my favorite, I have When september ends in my heart too for a reason and Before you go go is the kind I want to listen on the beach in a summer day.
I would prefer to have a real game related question from you
Lynchwise, my short list is Cropcircles, LW, Silver, Wakemeup in descending order. Bur/Tubba have been down trending for me lately, but not enough that I don't care to see a flip today.
I know I wasn't active, I can play today all day and make myself useful, same answer for everyone who put me in the Poe
Sunday is still a lazy day, and I made the mistake to take notes like the day would be longer but i checked and is still 24 hours. I will not do this anymore because I want to read as much as I can today.
Page 2
I like GJs activity, he is focused on the game, I noticed Wisp says his tone is not from his town self but I started to distrust meta lately so I am waiting to see what i find in the next pages.
@Wisp i understand that GJ didn't play in long time, do you think meta remains the same after a break? Also what means the case for Kj is up in the air (P#88)?
@Rhand if you reformulated P#92 somewhere, I think I will find it. If not, please tell me what's about.
I realised after reading page 1 that I played with the majority of the players, but is the first time playing with Iso, Bur, GJ, Tammy and Azrael, except they have on MU a different username and we played in the last 2 years and i don't know this.
My MU name is Michelle, a translation in English of my name.
Nice to meet you!
Being the first page I think the fluff posting from some people is not a crime.
I wish to know why is P#34 the scummiest for @Sloth and if in the P#54 of @GJ the mention about Iso solving until page 4 is a meme.
I don't understand what Rhand posted but being RP I don't think he wanted to transmit important game informations that way.
@Chad can you reformulate for me P#23? Looks like an odd strategy and I want to know if I understood it correct.
Sorry for inactivity these days, I will wait for the weekend to read through but from what I skimmed I saw Cantrip has just one post.
I hoped my RVS vote may bring me an idea of his alignament but I doubt it's effective after so much time.
The VC (post 164) showed him with 3 votes and I don't like this.
Unvote
I just noticed he has 2 posts but this doesn't change my idea
Sorry for inactivity these days, I will wait for the weekend to read through but from what I skimmed I saw Cantrip has just one post.
I hoped my RVS vote may bring me an idea of his alignament but I doubt it's effective after so much time.
The VC (post 164) showed him with 3 votes and I don't like this.
I don't think MU is a cold place, I always enjoyed the environement, possibly because my homeforum was Vbulletin until they switched to Xenforo late in 2018. I learned there a lot of things during the Mentor games and I still have in mind a game from February 2019 when I played with Achromatic. I think I admired his playstyle and his years of play were impressive for me at the time, and now after playing with this community I understand why I am feeling, like in that game, like a kid joining adults conversation every time when I am playing here. This is not a feeling related in any way with my real age, but with my mafia (game experience and capability) age.
I wish this community to keep playing and I will play here as much as I can from now on, here, on MC, on MU or wherever you decide to go.
My soul would go to MC, because Osie's effort in making that site welcoming for everyone pays off in a game environement easier to play in and very enjoyable.
The reverse of "what if MC will die as well" is what if the migration of MtGS there will make a stronger community, attracting players there?
MU has the fascinating tools and the subforums where several communities who lost homeforums are having games. I played on CFC an unusual game and I would always return to play there, and also I noticed GDS has an active community of players who know well each other from over a decade.
I think I agree with Rand, and follow the community to have the opportunity to play with them.
It was a moment when I had to sub out because I could not be active at all due to RL reasons. I apologise for this, am an not doing it often.
I try to have more fun in a game myself and one thing into that direction is taking it slower.
I am probably the only one who didn't understand your posts here, thanks for the clarification.
When I will finish to read all the posts I will post my own Poe.
I have to admit a tardiness in reading because again I tried to understand each post and I went back every time to the reference post.
I like what you said about meta in P#129 'I am a verbal/constant both in games and outside of them about not using meta', meta it's not set in stone and reads only based on meta are not usually accurate fmpov.
@Rhand - P#145 the RP makes again hard to understand what you want to say, for me your sentence there 'GJ be town' looks like a prod and if I am right I wish to know the intent behind it
@Vaimes - p#185 about KJ 'Innocent until proven guilty, is how I usually handle him.'
How do you usually find the proof for him being villagery or guilty?
Tammy's self meta is sustained by others from what I understood and this looks good, P#197 looked like she is focused on the game
From the first pages I liked Sloth, Tammy, GJ and KJ
Scum leans on Rhand (the RP makes posts hard to get) and Wisp
this is useful, thanks
I don't remember from you to use this kind of read, I hoped you can give me something concrete but I understand thinking at your claim that you don't have a real motivation to solve.
Agree with not lynching Wisp
Inside is my favorite, I have When september ends in my heart too for a reason and Before you go go is the kind I want to listen on the beach in a summer day.
I would prefer to have a real game related question from you
I know I wasn't active, I can play today all day and make myself useful, same answer for everyone who put me in the Poe
going to see if I have answers/questions for me first
Page 2
I like GJs activity, he is focused on the game, I noticed Wisp says his tone is not from his town self but I started to distrust meta lately so I am waiting to see what i find in the next pages.
@Wisp i understand that GJ didn't play in long time, do you think meta remains the same after a break? Also what means the case for Kj is up in the air (P#88)?
@Rhand if you reformulated P#92 somewhere, I think I will find it. If not, please tell me what's about.
I see, I will take this in ocnsideration, thanks
My MU name is Michelle, a translation in English of my name.
Nice to meet you!
Being the first page I think the fluff posting from some people is not a crime.
I wish to know why is P#34 the scummiest for @Sloth and if in the P#54 of @GJ the mention about Iso solving until page 4 is a meme.
I don't understand what Rhand posted but being RP I don't think he wanted to transmit important game informations that way.
@Chad can you reformulate for me P#23? Looks like an odd strategy and I want to know if I understood it correct.
I just noticed he has 2 posts but this doesn't change my idea
I hoped my RVS vote may bring me an idea of his alignament but I doubt it's effective after so much time.
The VC (post 164) showed him with 3 votes and I don't like this.
Unvote
I wonder, is the bolded a real thing?
Starting from post 51
Why i don't have on mobile the menu of the answering box? :sadface: