MTG Salvation

Quote from Syrenz »

Vote MandersHex

FoS Red Omega

I see your point. There actually is quite a strong connection between them. Interesting.

Quote from Syrenz »

Now here's an interesting thing. Our claimed Doctor wasn't the one killed last night, instead Seppel was. I don't see why scum would choose Seppel over Doctor, even if they wanted to WIFOM us into this situation. And Seppel was bodyguard which is essentially a doctor. It's hard to believe we have a bodyguard and a doctor, which would mean Chubbz is scum. But I need to check through Jerub's previous games to decide this. And Seppel being bodyguard would have thought about this when Chubbz claimed Doc which confuses me.

But keep in mind that Chubbz was RB'ed last night. so its possible that there's an RB among the mafia and they chose to block Chubbz and kill Seppel instead.

Quote from MandersHex »

Your continued attacks on my intelligence, stating that I cannot form my opinions and repeatedly ask for others' opinions, are unfounded. In every time I've asked for others' opinions on an issue, I have stated my own either before of after asking others. I asked of you guys because I was under the impression that we were supposed to work as a team to kill the scum. Part of working as a team is hearing what everyone else thinks on various subjects.

But there are times when you need to act on your own. to a certain point, you are right. but i must say that i think the description "working as a team" better suits the scum themselves, imho. because you are not even a hundred percent sure about a player's alignment.

Quote from MH »

It had nothing to do with r_0 being my scumbuddy, which I assure you he is not.

WIFOM.

Quote from Syrenz »

I don't understand why you would be RB'ed instead of killed. I don't either think that it makes much sense that we have a Doctor and a Bodyguard. But why on earth wouldn't Seppel- a clearly experienced player, not come to the same conclusion? Seriously, Seppel has me really confused right now...

Which would slightly show the possibility of both a bodyguard and doc in a game. but honestly, both of those in a basic is questionable.

Quote from SGT Chubbz »

if the scum have an RBer and i've claimed doc, what do they have to lose? they RB me, then kill someone else. i can't do anything being RB, so i'm no threat.

True. it would be reasonable to successfully RB and kill rather than risk RBing a vanilla.

Quote from Syrenz »

Unvote, Vote MandersHex

wait. so you make a pretty strong case on MH and vote her for that. then suspicion on Chubbz arises and you decide to change your vote to him instead. then when someone defends chubbz, you quickly go back to your first accusation? scummy. FoS Syrenz.

This Christmas break is sooo tiring! every day, we spend the whole day going somewhere. Right now, i think im already gonna faint because of tiredness. damn.

anyway, anything happen lately here?

Quite busy nowadays guys. ill post maybe tomorrow.

unvote.

damn guys, we're still barely off random stage haha. get to posting everyone! (yeah, although that'll be pretty hard since it is the holidays.)

okay, got enough rest last night.

Quote from TMF »

Because between posts 250 and 265, those were the players that implicitly understood that Zebi's role pm was accurate. MandersHex and Sgt Chubbz did not realize that it was. Later on, as it became more obvious that the claim was correct I figured that it became more likely that people were able to simply bandwagon on.

The only thing that struck me in your list was the fact that you put yourself there. I dunno if you really were mildly self claiming, or you were just trying to save yourself from suspicion.

Quote from MandersHex »

This game is moving very slow. Seeing as how we are less than a week from Christmas and I know once that hits, it'll be days before we all start posting regularly again, I would really like to resolve this situation with TMF before then. He has posted several times in the past day, and none of his posts have convinced me, or apparently anyone else of his innocence. We only need two votes, guys. Let's end Day 1 and enjoy our Christmas!

Yes, with the effect that Thanksgiving has put on this game, i doubt that Christmas wouldn't do the same, if not, even worse. But to be honest, i'm not entirely sure, but my gut feeling at the moment is that TMF isn't scum.

Quote from Cyouni »

Wait a minute - this is interesting.

Let's sum up the two quotes, shall we?
#1: You believe Zebi's claim of vanilla town.
#2: You call Zebi scumbuddies with TMF.
What's going on here?

Ah, apparently i wasn't clear. I asked if r_0 thought or was implying if they were scumbuddies or not.

Quote from Syrenz »

And KoZ. Both of you need to answer some questions.

RL, sorry.


more tomorrow. i need some rest.

Sorry I haven't been active these past few days. Too much plans and things to do this Christmas.

Anyway, gonna read up from when i last was and then post.

Welcome to the clan, Jaid.

Quote from Zaz »

Did you say extendo?

Quote from AI »

Also, the obligatory question: Are you really a lady? We actually already have a female member, but she hasn't been around much due to her hectic situation IRL.

Yeah i know, right. nonetheless, i wish her the best of luck with her kid.



Other than that, did anything interesting happen here while i was gone?


-EDIT- Scribe Time!

Quote from Ravus »

How long must this joke live on?

Until i get it.

vote Phoenix. only scum FoS themselves.

Quote from Tekno »

FOS: MandersHex

Thanks for stating that. Apparantly you are a PR or scum as well, since you have doubts with Zebi's claim. Maybe we want a claim from you as well?

Another one. lol.

Quote from Seppel »

HELLO I HAVE REPLACED IN AS SOMEBODY IN THIS GAME

Will figure out who that is and so on later tonight.

Unvote

Welcome to the game. good luck with rereading.

Quote from Tekno »

Unvote

EDWOP: So that brings us to Manders Hex. Blah. I should stop hitting the reply button so fast.

Vote: Mandershex

why the sudden unvote? could you explain on why you did such and then immediately averted your eyes to another?

Quote from Seppel »

Unvote.

I support lynches of Syrenz, The Motley Fool, and Emo_Pinata.

Please elaborate.

Quote from Cyouni »

It's possible, I'll admit, but highly improbable. I'll say no more.

To this i agree. It is unlikely that he would false claim in this light.

Quote from r_0 »

You did it again! Why would you keep feeding him ideas before he has a chance to respond.

I see what you mean there. Scumbuddies, perhaps?

Quote from SGT Chubbz »

1.) she keeps talking as a "we", so she's either schizo, or talking for some group (could be town, could be scum)
2.)she keeps saying that 'we' are lynching X person. then X2 person. she seems to be flopping quite a bit...just a thought.

Saying "we" isn't that strong a scum tell, imo.

@mod; votecount please.

Quote from AK »

I agree with you but, it dosen't give you the green light either, especially when two other people just voted.

Please explain on why coming back to the game after not posting for a relatively long time and giving a vote right there and then, which, as you said earlier, "came out of nowhere", doesn't give me the green light to vote.

Quote from Zebi »

I'm a townie.

No flavor given.

I believe your claim. unvote

More content to come.

Quote from red 0mega »

Not when he said it, no. I felt that it might reflect badly on me to bring it up when he was the main one casting suspicion on me at the time (as well as voting for me). I don't want to be retaliatory.

Even if the guy is the main person casting suspicion on you, you should still be able throw an accusation to him, if it is truly genuine.

Quote from Zebi »

Yes. The only thing we have to go on for day 1 is behavior. If someone's play isn't sitting right with me, that's all I have to go on.

To this, i have to disagree. Just because it doesn't sit right, it doesn't mean that you already have a green light to lynch; which would almost surely be a mislynch. vote: Zebi.

Quote from AK »

Edghyatt
DarkNightCaviler
Drop And Die
KrackShott

C'mon. You forgot me.

10/10 @genyus. Hey bud.

Quote from Zebi »

There's nothing to be said. Nothing has happened yet except random people getting suspicion for nothing. Except..

Vote: MandersHex

Something about your play isn't sitting right with me.

So you come back after more or less a week of inactivity in the game, and go straight into voting someone because their play simply doesn't sit right with you? Any other reasons why at least?

No school today! and only 3 days of school (starting tomorrow) before a two-week Christmas break.

Does anyone know how wamyc is doing in the CC?