Quote from ManiacmanWhich Magi, exactly? There were 9 of them, If I recall correctly.
Also, Mortal Combat only really serves to confuse the plan of the deck, as you don't know whether you want to play out all your rats and attack or just Damnation into the graveyard. I prefer the attacking route myself, so I'd replace the Mortal Combats with Bad Moon to pump up all your rats.
Quote from /agentORANGEDoesn't it cost money to call? Is it really worth it? It's not like you can do anything about your score. The best choice is simple to wait. I'm not letting the college board put their hand on my money. They claim their non-profit but I still believe they're greedy people.
Quote from Hunted CharlieUgh... SorryGuy was soooooo scummy near the end there, and I was afraid AoK was leaning towards Cyan.]
Quote from kabalthanks for the info. The interesting thing is that Alex stated that he just swapped out Werebear, but the list he played at Lille was Ugw
Anyhow, if you find out anything more please post it here. Thanks.
Quote from Cyan »Some of these arguments might work against someone that doesn't know better. I'm not that someone, I have mafia experience. The argument that HRothGar 'had' to kill whom you guys said is rubbish. If he was scum, he would simply have stalled for a day, vigged someone, single-vote-lynched someone else, and the scum would win. And also, daykill is *almost always* a town ability, very rarely is it given to scum. You're not going to get away with peddling statistically invalid arguments against me, I know better.
Nice way to pass the buck to someone else. You still haven't explained why Loran claimed a unique role/PM, to which you then tried to claim Vanilla.
Of course he didn't talk about what was in his role PM. There would be no reason to do so. Then, after AoK discussed what was in her role PM, he realized that their PMs were essentially the same. Then he used this to catch you in a lie. Now Archy has come along and confirmed that he, too, has received the same message. The only logical conclusion is that all three are telling the truth, leaving you as the odd man out.
Please. Never do people that are investigated get informed of it. Almost never do people that are Doc protected get informed of it. Almost always, people that are roleblocked get informed of it. The dynamic of a roleblock is different than that of an investigation or a protection. Please, stop trying to use arguments that can't possibly work against someone that has any decent mafia experience. It's insulting.
Wow, way to try to turn this into an emotional battle against me. You praised his play in an obvious attempt to cover what was essentially a non-argument attack on him. You're contradicting yourself even now. You've praised him as the best townie all game, but are suddently convinced that he's scum? Seriously, if you cannot make a logical argument, don't make one at all. Banking on emotional response from people is as scummy as possible.
It's not what the post was saying? Those are his *exact words from the post*. So yes, it is what the post is saying.
It is blatantly a fabrication, like everything you have said in the last two days. You got caught in a lie, and came up with 'I'm the town RB!' as a last ditch cover, knowing that the existence of a town RB was extremely unlikely, because A)the mafia had a roleblocker and B)no mention had ever been made of a town RB throughout the entire game.
@SG: I'm still waiting for you to make an actual case here. Saying 'HKKID must be the last scum because I know it isn't me!' means absolutely nothing. One day you're convinced that HKKID must be town, the next day you're doing a complete 180. Hell, Kenji said *exactly* the same as you did here regarding RafK recently in DotA Mafia. What was the end result? Kenji was scum.
I am condemning SG in entirety because he is the only one that can possibly be scum. Not only do all of his actions bear this out, but again, there is the vanilla flavor text situation. As town, it is a person's responsibility to hunt down scum. In this situation, it is necessary for me to be direct and aggressive. I replaced into a situation where the last scum of the game, SG, was one vote away from winning the game, and could acheive that vote in multiple ways. The dwindling clock leaves no room for missteps nor soft play.
Honestly, I thought about responding to this post and saying 'Take your time, I won't keep posting about all of this, I'm sure you'll make the right decision'. While I do have confidence that, in the end, you will see that the only logical conclusion to these events is that SG is scum and I am town, I find myself unable to sit by and hope that you both choose correctly without as much information as possible. Such is not in my nature. Look at what I have said in my posts. There is no deceit, no attempts to mislead. All I have done is point out scummy actions by SG, which he has either not anwered, or answered poorly. SG has lied at every single turn, and put forth answers that simply don't make any sense.
I can accept that HKKID's actions made him suspicious to you. You really should take into account that HKKID was opposed to HRothgar being lynched, and lead the crusade against Cubus. Both of these were correct decisions, and it is highly unlikely that HKKID's play yesterday makes any sense as scum.