He gave everyone town points exclusively except for the scumspects he pulled from it
This is in direct contradiction to what you've just pointed out.
Read that more carefully, it's saying everyone you didn't call out as scum as the result of your reread got entirely town points. There are plenty of sketchy moments for everyone, because no one's a perfect townie. I could understand if you're just crossing people off the list of probable suspects such as Wheat and Teia, but then why did you bring these people up when they did something townie? This part of your reread is buddying.
It does not have to do with anyone you gave scum points.
I don't follow your logic here. If I saw posts that interacted with things I already had in my notes, I followed up on it. If I saw things that were questionable behaviors, I noted it. If I saw a strong town behavior, I noted it. If Teia or G_M or Jay posted "plenty of sketchy moments", I didn't see them, & this just seems like you're blanketing my re-read as suspect without analyzing the content, ending with you characterizing my scumspects as easy targets;
First off, let me apologize for offending you. Not my intention at all. This is just a game, after all.
No, my bad. Long days & early mornings means I let my irritation at KK get out. I only skimmed your post & the line I paraphrased jumped out at me like a fish slap to the face. I can't stand the presumption he's thrown around that if someone doesn't respond immediately they're avoiding the conversation, & aside from the glazed eyes that our kind of back & forth causes, it also means I don't have time to do anything else while I'm here, meaning my main scum candidate is succeeding at preventing me from otherwise engaging with the game.
At least there is the payoff of BV's blatent target of opportunity vote.
Where? All I've found is you calling Jay's suspicion of Void's claim 'setup speculation' (536), which is obviously pointing out his incorrect terminology. Jay on the other hand picked up on his incorrect terminology but didn't realize the significance of it, or at least didn't mention it (586).
The more I look at it, that 'Eh, setup speculation' comment seems like a subtle attempt at trying to cover your scumbuddies false claim.
Jay doesn't differentiate between abilities & moves in the post you link, & I don't think he's making any difference there. Immediately after that I post this;
Eh, setup speculation. I can't say I've seen a game like this. Maybe Islander Mafia, I'd have to dig it up. There are a lot of games in this sub I haven't read, though.
Void, do you have an ability in addition to your moves?
You read the Eh line, you didn't see the question directed at Void?
Single shot, 1pp. I was going to track Iso, but then Wheat threatened to kill him. I thought of tracking Wheat, but felt that if he was legit, he might draw the NK, or if there was a 'real' vig, he might still end up dead. So I went with Teia, based on basically the same reason I early-wagoned her in MM6 – she's tough to get a read on, & a formidable player.
I apologize for losing my cool earlier. KK put me on tilt repeating his 'never responded to my post!' cry when I'm doing the best I can.
I'm Tyranitar.
My ability is Sand Stream, which does nothing.
My move is Pursuit, which is single shot but lets me track a player over consecutive nights as long as they don't die. N1 I chose Teia. I'll claim her targets if she wants me to.
Excellent, run and hide after failing to come up with any decent responses re: your scummy reread.
Everyone: make sure you understand the exchange ria and I just had.
*Snip* I just said I'm time poor, I'll respond to your garbage, as I have repeatedly, when I have more than a minute to sit down. Just because I don't constantly say "gee, I have IRL responsibilities, V/LA 48 hours" doesn't mean I'm not going to respond to you. Get a grip – this kind of smug post ignoring that I have a real life makes it miserable to participate in this game.
@kaburi – repeatedly people have said Jay was the first person to point it out, when *I* was.
& I can't have an exchange with KK without you saying I'm just letting him hang himself, & I can't excuse myself from bobmarding the thread with more of the same, I can't point out posts that give me a town read on someone. . . I guess I'll eat worms?
Just a heads up Megs – if the site moves over to the new build, I will need to be replaced.
He gave everyone town points exclusively except for the scumspects he pulled from it
This is in direct contradiction to what you've just pointed out.
As for ignoring your example, this?
"He also ignored points that could make these players not scum, such as how I was the first to call BV scum by a wide margin, yet I'm 100% scum in his opinion. "
I never stated you were 100% scum, what is your deal with putting words in people mouths? Townies don't need to misrepresent the thread. I am confident you are scum, I've put a lot of effort to show why I think that. There is no need to overstate it like I am face-humping or claiming to be infallible. I'm not Iso.
& yes, when I did that re-read, I didn't look at you very hard – the whole point was so I could get a better look at other players. & you were super-lazy in your 'push' on BV. You kept tossing him out there, so you could point & say 'look, I pushed on BV!'. . . but you never actually push on BV. I'm happy as to discuss that, & I'm pretty sure I've brought it up already.
And I'm not saying they can't be scum, but the way ria wrote that reread was not townie. He gave everyone town points exclusively except for the scumspects he pulled from it and the moment someone got scum points for anything, scum points were all they got for the rest of his posts, no matter the contortions he had to do to make them fit.
What a load of rubbish. My points on kaburi don't align with what you're claiming. Instead of making **** up, why don't you point out those contortions or quote some posts. . . oh, because every time you do, it doesn't match what you're selling.
At least there is the payoff of BV's blatent target of opportunity vote.
Single shot, 1pp. I was going to track Iso, but then Wheat threatened to kill him. I thought of tracking Wheat, but felt that if he was legit, he might draw the NK, or if there was a 'real' vig, he might still end up dead. So I went with Teia, based on basically the same reason I early-wagoned her in MM6 – she's tough to get a read on, & a formidable player.
I'm Tyranitar.
My ability is Sand Stream, which does nothing.
My move is Pursuit, which is single shot but lets me track a player over consecutive nights as long as they don't die. N1 I chose Teia. I'll claim her targets if she wants me to.
*Snip* I just said I'm time poor, I'll respond to your garbage, as I have repeatedly, when I have more than a minute to sit down. Just because I don't constantly say "gee, I have IRL responsibilities, V/LA 48 hours" doesn't mean I'm not going to respond to you. Get a grip – this kind of smug post ignoring that I have a real life makes it miserable to participate in this game.
@kaburi – repeatedly people have said Jay was the first person to point it out, when *I* was.
& I can't have an exchange with KK without you saying I'm just letting him hang himself, & I can't excuse myself from bobmarding the thread with more of the same, I can't point out posts that give me a town read on someone. . . I guess I'll eat worms?
Just a heads up Megs – if the site moves over to the new build, I will need to be replaced.
Please do not flame other users.
~Iso
As for ignoring your example, this?
"He also ignored points that could make these players not scum, such as how I was the first to call BV scum by a wide margin, yet I'm 100% scum in his opinion. "
I never stated you were 100% scum, what is your deal with putting words in people mouths? Townies don't need to misrepresent the thread. I am confident you are scum, I've put a lot of effort to show why I think that. There is no need to overstate it like I am face-humping or claiming to be infallible. I'm not Iso.
& yes, when I did that re-read, I didn't look at you very hard – the whole point was so I could get a better look at other players. & you were super-lazy in your 'push' on BV. You kept tossing him out there, so you could point & say 'look, I pushed on BV!'. . . but you never actually push on BV. I'm happy as to discuss that, & I'm pretty sure I've brought it up already.
Referring to Day 1; I think you mean kababs joined the hanswagon?
& why the heck didn't I know they made a TMNT-themed SF2 clone for the NES? This would have changed my life 20 years ago