@loran: i addressed your post in my catch up albeit inderectly. Your point was that i was reaching too far and thats it, i disagree.
i think i was weĺl within reach to state that a player who provides a list by the 9nth post and then goes rvs happy based on that post once rvs is done, only to later on state the list was a joke once questioned to be waffling and it strentgthened my view of vaimes being scummy.
@vaimes: ill get to your reply later tonight because im phone posting and i think a post break down would be better than a paragraph response
Yeah, no. I'm keeping my vote where it is since you:
A. ignored my attack
B. continue to insist a scum list in a person's first vote wasn't a joke and are attacking someone for it.
I dont really care about your point A.
Your point B baffles the mind, because:
1. That list was NOT provided with Vaimes first vote, in fact that list contained no vote he was already voting fulcrum at that time.
2. He then decided he 'was bored' (by his own admission) and decided to make a joke T/S list.
3. Checking the time stamps shows that there was no way Vaimes was actually bored.
4. He comes back to this JOKE list as a way to try to RVS vote people at post #40 when fulcrum was in heavy swing of her 'vaimes is scum' (which she later reveals to be a ploy because she thought Vaimes was obv town and was fetching for reactions a different can of worms and one Generic went into in more detail).
5. He doubles back on the list using the 'it was a joke list' defense because i was calling him on it, if you notice (although i did not at the time) the 'RVS vote to engage people' gives him a sort of excuse for dropping his vote on fulcrum even tho fulcrum was nailing him hard at the time for being scummy (again she later on states that she was just looking for reactions BUT the point here is that there was no way for Vaimes to know that, lest he can read her mind or has access to some form of outside communication).
It was his second post, right after his random vote post (so yes I was off by a post). You really expect us to believe such a list could be anything but a joke? Baloney. And yes, clearly you can see his state of mind to find whether he was bored or not (given his inability to wait for other people to post before posting 4 more times, seems plenty plausible to me).
@Generic - good news! All of us have totally read Hunts' prior games to be able to tell when he's playing differently. Wait, no we haven't.
So far loran my memory of you in this game in s telling people what not to do. I'm figuring it's about time you actually start doing something. Cos so far you haven't given me any reason to see why you think laying down the laws of what is best for scum hunting has any value...
Show me the wagon you think will bag scum. Because you sure as hell seem to think you know optimum play.
Okay Generic, let's explain.
A. You don't get to tell people what to do.
B. If you don't understand why these things I'm complaining about are wrong, well, sucks for you.
C. I won't show you the "wagon". I will aim to show you scum. (PS It's Sepiriel)
@loran: i addressed your post in my catch up albeit inderectly. Your point was that i was reaching too far and thats it, i disagree.
i think i was weĺl within reach to state that a player who provides a list by the 9nth post and then goes rvs happy based on that post once rvs is done, only to later on state the list was a joke once questioned to be waffling and it strentgthened my view of vaimes being scummy.
@vaimes: ill get to your reply later tonight because im phone posting and i think a post break down would be better than a paragraph response
Yeah, no. I'm keeping my vote where it is since you:
A. ignored my attack
B. continue to insist a scum list in a person's first vote wasn't a joke and are attacking someone for it.
Ps analyzing players by comparison to prior games is lousy - a. Not every player has read those games, so the evidence isn't helpful to everyone and b. if players have played a lot of games they basically have an example for any type of behavior.
Stick to this game.
Speaking of which, sepiriel, are you going to ignore me any longer?
1. Vaimes, stop quintuple posting. Sometimes you forget things and have to double post, but if you're doing it like this, YOURE DOING IT WRONG. Cut it out.
2. Also Generic, stop with the swearing. Seriously.
3. Generic, you're "gut response" is not an argument. It doesn't lay out a reason why fulcrum is scum.
4. A reminder: A player isn't obliged to put any amount of analysis into any post. (Seriously)
Anyhow. Kind of waiting for Sepiriel to actually post anything at this point. Nothing since my vote. And he's still made the scummiest stuff so far this game.
You're waiting on an explanation of a first post vote? This is not exactly difficult to understand.
In the meantime, can we all just slow the hell down? There is no reason less than 24 hours in, before basically every poster can check in, that we have a freaking wagon already. Cut that out.
Anyhow, Necarg's posts read as bad townie, not scum. Generic reads as ANNOYING townie. Vaimes just reads as annoying. This many annoying players is going to be a problem, sigh.
Oh and this:
Quote from Sepiriel »
you are now trying to spin it as a joke list, that doesnt make it less of a good justification, specially considering what i explained above.
is just reaching HARD. Like incredibly hard. Guess my vote just lost its randomness.
PS: Quick note about availability - I can make decent lengthed posts only during my lunch break and after work. So if you ever want to hear from me, you'll have to wait usually till night time EST.
So....I think the only one of yall I've played with before is Sep? Actually not even sure I was ever in a game with him. Geez, bunch of younguns here. Whatever, Vote Sepiriel
Also, FFS, STOP SPAMMING already, good god. Driving this old guy insane.
Also insane? Four votes on someone in the random voting stage. And I don't have a vote on me yet. What is wrong with you people? Anyhows,
Only one signup at a time? Did the mafia playerbase contract greatly or something?
Thanks Az! Huh, sucks about the playerbase. Not sure I have the time to commit to many games myself, but I can probably handle a mini and do reviewing for other hosts to help speed up game supply. Hope it helps.
LORAN!!! Welcome back.
We are a good bit smaller in the wake of curse, maybe 33% smaller, but we are now on a rolling queue basis where there could be an unlimited number of minis going - just only one sign up at a time. Our problem recently has been getting enough folks with completed designs queued up to meet the surge in demand. For the moment, everything has switched into de facto FTQ mode.
Is there a reason the new signups are a specialty instead of a mini? There's currently a specialty just starting AND an FTQ. For those of us who don't want a special game, why is there yet another one?
(If it's lack of setups, let us know, I'm sure people could whip up mini setups)
It was his second post, right after his random vote post (so yes I was off by a post). You really expect us to believe such a list could be anything but a joke? Baloney. And yes, clearly you can see his state of mind to find whether he was bored or not (given his inability to wait for other people to post before posting 4 more times, seems plenty plausible to me).
@Generic - good news! All of us have totally read Hunts' prior games to be able to tell when he's playing differently. Wait, no we haven't.
Okay Generic, let's explain.
A. You don't get to tell people what to do.
B. If you don't understand why these things I'm complaining about are wrong, well, sucks for you.
C. I won't show you the "wagon". I will aim to show you scum. (PS It's Sepiriel)
If this is still true in later days, we'll have a problem. Better we stop the problem now.
Yeah, no. I'm keeping my vote where it is since you:
A. ignored my attack
B. continue to insist a scum list in a person's first vote wasn't a joke and are attacking someone for it.
Stick to this game.
Speaking of which, sepiriel, are you going to ignore me any longer?
No.
1. Vaimes, stop quintuple posting. Sometimes you forget things and have to double post, but if you're doing it like this, YOURE DOING IT WRONG. Cut it out.
2. Also Generic, stop with the swearing. Seriously.
3. Generic, you're "gut response" is not an argument. It doesn't lay out a reason why fulcrum is scum.
4. A reminder: A player isn't obliged to put any amount of analysis into any post. (Seriously)
Anyhow. Kind of waiting for Sepiriel to actually post anything at this point. Nothing since my vote. And he's still made the scummiest stuff so far this game.
You're waiting on an explanation of a first post vote? This is not exactly difficult to understand.
In the meantime, can we all just slow the hell down? There is no reason less than 24 hours in, before basically every poster can check in, that we have a freaking wagon already. Cut that out.
Anyhow, Necarg's posts read as bad townie, not scum. Generic reads as ANNOYING townie. Vaimes just reads as annoying. This many annoying players is going to be a problem, sigh.
Oh and this:
is just reaching HARD. Like incredibly hard. Guess my vote just lost its randomness.
Also, FFS, STOP SPAMMING already, good god. Driving this old guy insane.
Also insane? Four votes on someone in the random voting stage. And I don't have a vote on me yet. What is wrong with you people? Anyhows,
Anything honestly
Mazel Tov Az!
May I ask why?
(If it's lack of setups, let us know, I'm sure people could whip up mini setups)