Yesterday Reya said that tomm and dork knit were scum together. So in order for him to have been right both dork knight and tomm would have to have been scum. since dork knit was town, they weren't both scum.
Also people tend to repeat themselves, even when it doesn't make sense. Reya referred to tomm as scummy earlier in his post.
Most of why Tom was scummy was his early day hypocrisy and that DK was trying to protect him. I am quite confidant he is scum now based on DK being town.
Also note how he used the past tense to refer to Tommy's scumminess.
Why do you think it's more likely he made a mistake while typing than he made a mistake remembering his stance?
Because the post where he says tomm is scum makes no sense at all.
Dork Knight and Tom were scum buddies (raya's hypothesis from yesterday), so (DKscum*TOMscum). Since (DKscum) was false, (DKscum*TOMscum) also must be false. Which is to say dork knight and tomm88 are not both scum.
He also used scum to refer to Tom earlies in that post (if you look), which supports the brain fart theory. He copied something he said before when the context was different.
Every reaction this entire game has been labled as scummy by someone or other, tomm.
People this game seem to think that they can so easily tell the difference between scum reactions and town reactions (hint: most of you are wrong most of the time)?
This "I don't like your reactions" argument shouldn't even be passable after day one (when it was used to lynch a townie). It's just poor argumentation and a refusal to approach the game of mafia logically.
I also think it's kind of weird that everyone is completely ignoring what happened day one and looking for some little slip-up and acting like that's a real strategy. Are we just going to have day one of this game over and over?
@Ximbad: Did you seriously just make a post saying "kpaca has done nothing this entire game. He is town."?
Actually I saying that he's near the top of my list of scum. As long as I was putting together what I though and why I figured I'd throw it out there for reactions/counterpoints/some sort of logical debate.
And saying you're town, lol.
@iso: Do you think that Reya's post where he calls tom scum makes sense as it was written? Do you not think it's possible that he made that mistake as a townie?
Greymon proved he could vote no lynch. Zelderex didn't prove he could hammer. Also how bad would a role where you can only hammer be when you don't know when the hammer is going to drop.
Dork knight was vanilla townie, just like he claimed. Yanni has since flipped town, so keep that in mind.
Also you might not have noticed this, but there were only six votes showing on dork knight. This is odd because seven votes should have been needed to lynch him. Since no one claimed to know why this happened, there is likely a member of the mafia who has a voting related ability. At the time of dork knights lynch tom88 and zeledrex weren't voting. Maybe one of those two has a voting related ability? Mmm, zeledrex claimed to be an actor (he can't vote unless his vote is the final vote). That's odd for two reasons. He voted and wasn't mod killed (it was noted that this is the usual procedure). Also the day ended as soon as he would have been able vote, so he never got the chance to vote. Effectively this means that he wouldn't have a vote if he was an actor. Given the contex Greymon's inability to vote except no lynch (more or less proven) Zeledex's claim seems dubious.
Most of why Tom was scummy was his early day hypocrisy and that DK was trying to protect him. I am quite confidant he is scum now based on DK being town.
doesn't make any sense AT ALL. He said he meant to say that instead of scum he meant to say town. That causes this post to make some non zero amount of sense.
Well, I started a fire. Some newbies got upset about that and thats pretty genuine so theyre probably town. Youre likely town, not cleared but I feel good about you. I honestly think Ximbad is town, unrelated to any of this. Yanni appaears to have coat tailed me. Zelderex looks less than town.
And in all of this, all the crazyness and suspicion and lunacy going on, greymon has actively done nothing. Like large posts saying nothing.
vote: greymon.
Hes nervous.
Here he throws out a bunch of opinions. I feel like he was trying to buddy up to me with his "you're town/no reason". He also post directly after me a few times to say he agrees with what I'm saying.
Also note he voted for greymon who is 100% town if Zeledrx was scum.
Lcol.
How is what kpaca saying that is anti-town? He's pushing for an Iso lynch and pointing out that Iso doesn't support anything he's been saying. Do you not like his posting style? That doesn't have anything to do with what side he's playing on. What does he need to defend agsinst? You said he's anti-town so he needs to jump? That doesn't make sense. Maybe try posting some reasons that you think Iso is town and that kpaca is scum?People were voting for me without stating reasons. I asked for the reasons they were voting. In what way does that bring suspicion? Should I just ignore the post were the entire content was a vote? I don't like letting people slide by with the bare minimum of contentless posting. Then I asked manders how her vote wasn't random. She said her vote wasn't random, but it looked to me to be completely random.
I'm asking people questions. You're saying that is defensive; I'm saying it is inquisitive. Or you could keep barning scum, whatever works for you.
Two votes out of six (or five, if this lynch threshold reducing thing still is a thing), a lynch does not make.
Your lack of hesitation from hopping from one side of the fence to the other bothers me. And he's more likely to make that mistake as mafia, being as he is having to falsify his reads.
OK, I was wrong, two votes away. I wanted to see if kpaca started making sense. He didn't.
Is this because of the flavorlynch, which I assumed was sarcastic, or because he claimed a neutral? I'm not actually all that opposed to lynching him purely on grounds of being neutral, since that sort of role could just as easily be a Mastermind/Autocrat type role (one that steals a win from the town). Hell, he may have given us a partial claim, neglecting to mention whether or not he wins WITH town.
**** it, Yanni, you convinced me to convince myself.
Damn iPod controls..... I need to get my pc up again. I ment , You went from like an opportunity vote to an unvote. Why did you you change your vote?
It was a typo, your explination makes sense, while if you meant what you said it makes vrey little sense. I just chalked it up to you being an idiot when you posted. We were one vote away from another weak lynch, just like yesterday's.
I think as mafia you're less likely to make that mistake, and you clearly have been trying to say the same thing all along.
Dork knight was vanilla townie, just like he claimed. Yanni has since flipped town, so keep that in mind.
Also you might not have noticed this, but there were only six votes showing on dork knight. This is odd because seven votes should have been needed to lynch him. Since no one claimed to know why this happened, there is likely a member of the mafia who has a voting related ability. At the time of dork knights lynch tom88 and zeledrex weren't voting. Maybe one of those two has a voting related ability? Mmm, zeledrex claimed to be an actor (he can't vote unless his vote is the final vote). That's odd for two reasons. He voted and wasn't mod killed (it was noted that this is the usual procedure). Also the day ended as soon as he would have been able vote, so he never got the chance to vote. Effectively this means that he wouldn't have a vote if he was an actor. Given the contex Greymon's inability to vote except no lynch (more or less proven) Zeledex's claim seems dubious.
Yesterday Reya said that tomm and dork knit were scum together. So in order for him to have been right both dork knight and tomm would have to have been scum. since dork knit was town, they weren't both scum.
Also people tend to repeat themselves, even when it doesn't make sense. Reya referred to tomm as scummy earlier in his post.
Also note how he used the past tense to refer to Tommy's scumminess.
Dork Knight and Tom were scum buddies (raya's hypothesis from yesterday), so (DKscum*TOMscum). Since (DKscum) was false, (DKscum*TOMscum) also must be false. Which is to say dork knight and tomm88 are not both scum.
He also used scum to refer to Tom earlies in that post (if you look), which supports the brain fart theory. He copied something he said before when the context was different.
People this game seem to think that they can so easily tell the difference between scum reactions and town reactions (hint: most of you are wrong most of the time)?
This "I don't like your reactions" argument shouldn't even be passable after day one (when it was used to lynch a townie). It's just poor argumentation and a refusal to approach the game of mafia logically.
I also think it's kind of weird that everyone is completely ignoring what happened day one and looking for some little slip-up and acting like that's a real strategy. Are we just going to have day one of this game over and over?
And saying you're town, lol.
@iso: Do you think that Reya's post where he calls tom scum makes sense as it was written? Do you not think it's possible that he made that mistake as a townie?
How does this not add up?
I voted for reya because there was an obvious contradiction in what he was saying, highlighted by Tomm here
However this post:doesn't make any sense AT ALL. He said he meant to say that instead of scum he meant to say town. That causes this post to make some non zero amount of sense.
Here kpaca defends Zeledrex, who is scum
Here he goes from a vote on iso saying he's definitely scum to saying he's definitely town, with no real change in between.
Here he throws out a bunch of opinions. I feel like he was trying to buddy up to me with his "you're town/no reason". He also post directly after me a few times to say he agrees with what I'm saying.
Also note he voted for greymon who is 100% town if Zeledrx was scum.There is no content here, he's just kinda barning me.
Same here.I though he really meant that Tomatoes was scum, which is idiotic. I forgot about his first post until tomm juxtaposed the two.
So, yeah. Gandering dan is scum: confirmed.
That makes Iso most likely town
That makes Greymon 100% town.
Kpaca: Something to look into at least. What made you sure I was town? Same for Iso?
Someone on the Dork Knight bandwagon is third, not sure who. Maybe Vossimus.
Hey guys,mremember when zeledrex forgot his role until it was pointed out that his vote didn't count?
vote gandering_dan
I've also got more to say, but this is good for now.
I think as mafia you're less likely to make that mistake, and you clearly have been trying to say the same thing all along.
@Reya: You made a mistake, fair enough. More substantive post later.
unvote vote: Reya Cookiebringer
Hey, you might have missed the end of the last day, but here's the people who were voting for dork knight.
Dork Knight (6): Yanni, Reya Cookiebringer, Knifehand1371, Iso, Voxxicus, MandersHex
Dork knight was vanilla townie, just like he claimed. Yanni has since flipped town, so keep that in mind.
Also you might not have noticed this, but there were only six votes showing on dork knight. This is odd because seven votes should have been needed to lynch him. Since no one claimed to know why this happened, there is likely a member of the mafia who has a voting related ability. At the time of dork knights lynch tom88 and zeledrex weren't voting. Maybe one of those two has a voting related ability? Mmm, zeledrex claimed to be an actor (he can't vote unless his vote is the final vote). That's odd for two reasons. He voted and wasn't mod killed (it was noted that this is the usual procedure). Also the day ended as soon as he would have been able vote, so he never got the chance to vote. Effectively this means that he wouldn't have a vote if he was an actor. Given the contex Greymon's inability to vote except no lynch (more or less proven) Zeledex's claim seems dubious.