2019 Holiday Exchange!
 
A New and Exciting Beginning
 
The End of an Era
  • posted a message on [M12] More reprints and a couple of new cards
    Quote from KBH
    How does Torches not have wither? I think wither is a great way to denote burn damage. Blistering Barrier would've been great with wither as well.


    Because it's not in a set with wither?

    Quote from jturphy
    Vapor Snag is not strictly better than Unsummon. Reclaim and Revival... yeah, I've got nothing on those. Maybe one was added late to fill a hole.


    Hey now, Noxious Revival can be Redirected to target one of your opponent's binned cards...! ;D
    Posted in: The Rumor Mill
  • posted a message on What to do when Commander isn't fun anymore?
    Quote from shneakyshneaky
    hahaha have you played the card game Bang! that's what it exactly sounds like! I might try something like this with my playgroup


    My playgroup plays Bang! almost as often as we play Magic! It's a lot of fun.

    "YAY, GENERAL STORE!"

    Quote from Pogo17
    because I run Aura Shards, the artifact deck said I was guilty of hating on it


    Whaaaaaaaat? That's a terrible argument on their part. Aura Shards has all sorts of applications, with the most common one being a way to answer many staples (Lightning Greaves, Sensei's Divining Top, etc.), acceleration (Sol Ring, Mana Reflection, etc.), and problem cards (Defense of the Heart, Grave Pact, Dream Halls, Blightst- ...well, not Blightsteel Colossus) that are seen in pretty much every game of EDH.
    Saying that Aura Shards is a hate card against artifact decks is like saying that Diabolic Edict is a hate card against Voltron decks. Yes, it answers your deck exceptionally well, but it isn't specifically intended to hate you out of the game.
    Posted in: Commander (EDH)
  • posted a message on [M12] Blood Ogre
    Wow, this guy's pretty good. As others have pointed out, he's quite nice in Limited.

    Quote from Vividice
    Don't the people in Mexiko speak spanish? Neigbour Countries and stuff.

    Because you mixed up german and spanish Grin
    But I have to thank you. Made my day Smile


    Boy, are you gonna be embarrassed!
    Posted in: The Rumor Mill
  • posted a message on [M12] Scepter, Crown, and Throne of Empires [Complete]
    Aw, I was hoping their names would be slightly different.

    Like "Scepter of Empires", "Crown of Monarchies", and "Throne of Kingdoms" or something.
    Posted in: The Rumor Mill
  • posted a message on Things that make you a little sad when you play
    Quote from DanceOfEternity
    - Playing against 'that guy' who brings his friends that sit beside him and constantly says "look at this", "oh God he's toast", and they all laugh;


    I have a couple of friends who are sort of like this. They'll sometimes show off their hands to me, but I do my best not to react during sanctioned matches because 1) it would be rude to the opponent, and 2) a reaction would give away more information, and I don't want to be accused of providing outside assistance.
    Posted in: Magic General
  • posted a message on [M12] Visions of Beyond
    I find it funny how Visions of Beyond can be fueled by Jace's Archivist in reaching "super-threshold", and also how Jace's Archivist can be fueled by Visions of Beyond after said "super-threshold" is reached.

    Anyway, about the card itself... I recognize its potential, but I wouldn't claim that it's broken until we're given thorough time to test it. Personally, I like it.
    Posted in: The Rumor Mill
  • posted a message on Help with my EDH Rhys
    Earthcraaaaaaaaaaaaaft~!

    It turns Squirrel Nest into a win condition, and it's just great on its own.
    Posted in: Multiplayer Commander Decklists
  • posted a message on Crazy Plays in EDH.
    Fun times were had today with Riku.

    I was in a four-player game, running Riku of Two Reflections against Memnarch, Numot, the Devastator, and Azusa, Lost but Seeking.

    It's still fairly early in the game. I have Riku, Lightning Greaves (on Riku, of course), Sol Ring, and Cloudstone Curio on the board. Memnarch had gotten off to a fast start, playing several mana rocks and a Clock of Omens. Numot was getting scared of Memnarch, so he cast Armageddon and passed the turn to Azusa. Azusa dropped a couple of Forests, then cast Collective Voyage. Memnarch used Clock of Omens to pour some mana into the Voyage, I used my Sol Ring to add two more, and we all search for six basics.

    My turn. I untap, and draw my card.

    Earthcraft.

    I look through my hand and survey my options, when I spot something interesting.

    I tap two lands and cast Earthcraft, tap Riku to untap one of my lands, then tap out and cast Siege-Gang Commander.
    I stack Siege-Gang's trigger on top of Riku's, then tap him and his pals to untap four lands and tap them again, floating four mana. I then spend GU for Riku's trigger and make a copy of Siege-Gang Commander, getting three more tokens. I use Cloudstone Curio to bounce the original Siege-Gang Commander to my hand, then tap the copy and the three Goblins to untap and float four more mana. I now have six in my pool.
    I rinse and repeat, with a net gain of one mana each time, until I have an arbitrary number of Siege-Gang Commanders, Goblin tokens, and mana. I then use the mana to kill all three opponents with Siege-Gang Commander shocks.

    It was awesome.
    Posted in: Commander (EDH)
  • posted a message on [EDH]Donate THIS! Zedruu the Greathearted
    I think Copy Enchantment could have a nice home here. It can copy your enchantment-based removal, the harmful enchantments that you want to donate, or even Paradox Haze for more Zedruu triggers.
    Posted in: Multiplayer Commander Decklists
  • posted a message on Best Creature Token General?
    Personally, I think each one has its own unique strengths that makes it no better than the others.

    Rhys is fast, consistent, and can get out of hand very quickly.
    Rith, Hazezon, and Ulasht have access to red, which allows for all sorts of crazy interactions.
    Ghave has access to black and all of its tutors and removal (Grave Pact, anyone?), and is just good on his own.

    Quote from Raguel
    I had a Darien, King of Kjeldor deck for a while. The downside was that you needed to get punched in the face (or punch yourself in the face) to make tokens. The plus side was that surviving lethal damage usually left you with a sizable army to swing back with.


    I've found that Soul Warden-esque effects usually alleviate that drawback, though they're kind of frail.

    It's utterly awesome if they can't find an answer before you find a way to protect it, though.

    "Okay, I take 33 and get 33 Soldiers."
    "Great, so what's your life total now?"
    "Uh, 41?"
    "But what about all that damage you took?"
    "Soul Warden, bro!"
    "...Oh."
    Posted in: Commander (EDH)
  • posted a message on Things that make you a little sad when you play
    Another thing that makes me sad... When my casual friends complain about bad decks or bad cards.

    I milled one of them out with a Sanity Grinding deck that has Twincasts, four of each blue Spirit Avatar from Shadowmoor/Eventide, a few Wizards for Sigil Tracer, and 20 Islands. No control cards at all.
    His response? "That deck is unfair."
    I asked him to explain his logic. He simply reiterated, "That deck is unfair."
    I explained to him why mill is a subpar strategy, that he didn't do anything to stop me throughout the whole game, and that he wouldn't bother reading any of the cards I played unless it affected his progress of reducing my life total from 20 to 0. Again, I was met with a simple, "That deck is unfair."

    Similarly, I also find it sad when people dismiss really good cards as mediocre.

    I was negotiating with another friend of mine for his Sensei's Divining Top, and his thoughts on the card were, "Eh, it's all right. I can see how it can be good, but I don't think it's that great."

    Quote from Mubutu
    When I sit down with a double sleeved, perfect-fitted legacy deck, and my opponent begins riffle shuffling an unsleeved deck with Bayous, Tarmogoyfs, Dark Confidants, and Phyrexian Dreadnoughts in it.


    That would drive me crazy!

    Ever since I got into TCGs as a kid when I collected Pokémon cards, I would always keep my rarer cards well-protected. I don't think my Charizard has ever come into contact with human hands, aside from when it went into the sleeve.

    If I were to ever encounter a player like that, I would immediately get up, buy him a nice set of sleeves, and say, "Please... For my sanity."
    Posted in: Magic General
  • posted a message on [M12] Chandra, Garruk and Jace aren't in Lorwyn Form
    This might have been noticed already, but it looks like Jace's ultimate says, "Target player puts the top X cards of his or her library into his or her graveyard, where X is the number of cards in that player's graveyard."

    Used Keening Stone's text as a reference.

    Of course, this doesn't contribute to the discussion of the legitimacy of the cards (it's been made pretty clear that they aren't real), but every bit of information helps, right?
    Posted in: Rumor Mill Archive
  • posted a message on [M12] 6/21 New Cards from Card Image Gallery
    Whoa, those Islands look nice!
    Posted in: The Rumor Mill
  • posted a message on Things that make you a little sad when you play
    Quote from Spawnman62
    Playing against someone who proxies their ENTIRE deck.


    This, definitely. It's even more annoying when the person doesn't even know the mana costs or stats of the cards they're proxying.

    One guy I know who has a 100% proxied Arcbound deck thought that Master Transmuter was a 2/2, and tried casting Doubling Season for 3G. Within two turns of each other in the same game, no less.

    And on some of the proxies, the only text he put was the card title and "Just ask."
    Posted in: Magic General
  • posted a message on [M12] Arcana: Art Gallery
    The Terese Nielsen piece reminds me of Flow of Ideas.
    Posted in: The Rumor Mill
  • To post a comment, please or register a new account.