Because the internet is at a point in which many people want all the attention but don't return it. Its like telling a joke and then laughing during the punchline (and being the only one that does). Things, not just magic related, have shifted to a "look at me" approach. Spotlight stealing/one upping. Or people that read your feedback and reject it without even a modicum of tact or respect to the time it took to provide.
Myself? I feel like I'm playing a different game from most, this awkward limbo of high and competitive where I'm too competitive for the casual table and too casual for the competitive. This coupled with my dedication to one wedge leaves me in the belief that my feedback may not be helpful to others - unless it's about Kaalia due to my rep with that commander.
Green having access to ramp would give them an unfair advantage if you don't allow non green from playing with fast mana. I guarantee the power level from simic to boros will be wide. I don't think every deck will need sol ring but some will need it to be able to keep up.
I understand your desire for equal manabase but if you split it like this I feel you'd have to avoid green based ramp because you're taking fast mana from boris. Things aren't so cut and dry when building different color combos. I'd just build an equal power level deck each.
I try to work one in every deck more or less as a this game has gone on too long let's switch up commanders and get a second game in. I won't necessarily tutor for all pieces as I normally just wait till the board state allows it. But if its turn 20 and I have the tutor to win I might be persuaded
My whole najeela list is maya. Now I have some 5 color lands in the deck but I'm not playing any black or blue duals. It's a fun list it's more about turning sideways and less about going infinite.
Or just make scooping available without penalty at sorcery speed. Fixes most problems allows lockout player to possibly rack up a little more points on others turn.
I hope we don't get partner with because the fun of the original partners was mix matching what you want to play. having two single colored partners in a deck and a main dual color pw would be great
teferis protection also stops the biggest boogeyman in the format cyclonic rift. completely off subject but if you're on a fixed income splurge here. it's a great card.
I understand she wants a wanderer deck but in her meta she won't enjoy it and would probably feel like she wasted some money on making it. you don't have to build kalia mld but she does great around it.
I really think you guys are setting her up for disaster. maelstrom wanderer is at 8cc the MLD guy should be dropping his first land destruction before that. if she already casted wanderer then it now costs ten and probably won't get back up there.
Kalia may be the most hated but honestly she does great running MLD herself. drop her blow up lands. that's what I would do and get ahold of teferis protection and boros charm and the like.
if all else fails play jhoria and become enemy number 1.
in my scarab God list(yes I still play him as s although I play a reanimate strategy) I really like draining whelk and nosegraf mob. both are better when eternalized
I'm not going to lie you will be targeted when you play the commander because it can do some degenerate things but there is a lot of room to build.
I live in the same limbo.
Green having access to ramp would give them an unfair advantage if you don't allow non green from playing with fast mana. I guarantee the power level from simic to boros will be wide. I don't think every deck will need sol ring but some will need it to be able to keep up.
wouldn't this just end up being a weaker gitrog at that point?
I understand she wants a wanderer deck but in her meta she won't enjoy it and would probably feel like she wasted some money on making it. you don't have to build kalia mld but she does great around it.
Kalia may be the most hated but honestly she does great running MLD herself. drop her blow up lands. that's what I would do and get ahold of teferis protection and boros charm and the like.
if all else fails play jhoria and become enemy number 1.