Quote from indomitablebugYou may see the point as moot, I don't. If you just weren't paying close enough attention, that's fine I guess, but I expected you to be keeping better track of things for some reason. I'm not trying to blow something I see as minor into something larger, I'm trying to investigate something that concerns me.
Quote from indomitablebug I wasn't insinuating your post was devoid of content, just that line. Your fist pump there just seemed a little over the top, like "Called it! Look how town I am! Follow me!" Is it possibly from a town perspective? Sure. But it pinged my scumdar.
Quote from indomitablebugTracker, doc, 1shot, vs RB.
Quote from indomitablebug My memory tracks scumtells better than towntells. Shalaktopus hasn't really pinged my scumdar, so I haven't worried about him much. Could he be scum? Sure. He could be pulling a huge WIFOM gambit to try to get out of the lynch today.
Quote from indomitablebug As I explained previously, my presence faded due to awkward working hours and not catching up on the excessive posts in the game. Did it look like lurking? Sure. But look at my posts: They have content. Pretty much all of them, I'd imagine.
I don't really post unless I have something to say. Does that mean I'll read the thread sometimes and not post? Sure. I don't always have something to say, and sometimes I'd rather keep my thoughts to myself instead of letting scum know what's going on in my head.
Quote from indomitablebugIt felt like a slip because it's the first post you've made that's pinged my scumdar. Which means the townfront you've been using slipped, or I just misread your intentions in the post. I haven't decided yet. So I have my eye on you.
Quote from indomitablebug While having a CC would create an interesting situation that we could possibly benefit from, I still don't like the idea of the vig claiming because that means the scum can kill them. I've lost to singleton scum after 2 successful nights before, and I don't want it to happen again. If the vig has more shots, claiming guarantees they only get one more. We can still guide the vig without knowing who they are, or at least discuss enough that they can make an informed decision.
Quote from indomitablebug As I've pointed out, this isn't really correct. Also, I don't like town that talk in absolutes like this. It doesn't look townie to me. Haven't you said before that town should never be 100% on anything? You're pretty black and white here.
Quote from indomitablebugAnd I disagree.
Quote from indomitablebugWIFOM. "Look, obviously I'm town because of all the effort I'm putting into this." You don't sound like you're looking for "serious consideration," you sound like you're looking for the claim. Consideration involves discussion. You've stated that there are no downsides. Not no downside that you can see, simply that there is no downside.
Quote from The Ice KingIndombug, tacky, anything go on with you guys last night?
Quote from indomitablebugYou're not paying attention, Tacky. Draco also told us what was up with him. You're pointing fingers with little reasoning.
Quote from indomitablebugReads like an attempt to gain townpoints rather than content. Reminding us how he called it earlier.
Quote from indomitablebugCan't remember our time together in Shrek mafia? I'm crushed. I was the tracker there, and even though you thought I was scum the whole game, I was definitely town. Bad at town, but town. Anyway, Shalako read town to me the whole time. Much more so than Naka or Poggy.
Quote from indomitablebugSo you go from thinking I'm obvtown and being happy to have me in the game to thinking I'm scum without posting any evidence for it at all? Please explain, sir.
Quote from indomitablebugI'd been thinking Tacky was town, but this post feels like a bit of a slip. IGMEOY.
Quote from indomitablebugWhy would we want to vig to claim if they had more shots? So we can give up another power role? Even if they were a 1 shot I don't see why they should claim. Might as well make the scum worry about the vig shot tonight, right?
Feels like you're fishing so hard Tacky.
Quote from quietfishContradictions. Get your story straight.
A tracker is useless to the town, and yet having a cop and a tracker would be imba. I don't understand how you can believe both of those statements. You seem to be twisting facts, possibly to lynch Shalako?
We should use the vigs second shot as a second lynch, but most basics only have a one-shot vig.
It strikes me that revealing poggy as town via scum death gave you some serious townie points, Tacky, since you defended him all game. Totally WIFOM, but interesting.
BTW, Shalako claimed watcher, not tracker.
Quote from dracofaustIf shalako is scum tracker, then that means mafia has two powerroles. If town had only 3 powerroles, would the setup be balanced?
Quote from dracofaustSaid already. I wasn't here for day 1 because of my internet. I requested replacement but kpaca didn't respond so now I'm back. I accused you of lurking because I didn't see you anywhere during Naka's lynch.
Quote from Nakamura
It's being rehashed because it's not being paid attention to. People, like you, are passing his Scum plays as inexperience, pressure, and claims without reasons (when those reasons have been provided).
Quote from NakamuraWhen, not if.
Quote from NakamuraTown don't have a reason to flail. They defend themselves, not flail.
Quote from NakamuraHe's investigation material. Poggy is either clear Scum or really, really bad Town.
Quote from ExLight1. read above barned ppost of indomitables. he beat me to it. some games dont have cops. but might have some other role of a watcher type.
2. nope, poggy's early thread flailing is also a reason why he and naka where on my scum list.
3. as far as i know, this is poggy's (first?) maybe second game, neither completed and he hasnt done this in the other game.
revised scum list.
SCUM-1. Poggy-ealry flailing and the cop counter claim distraction
Naka-even though claims cop-could be lying never know. so IGMEOY
Quietfish-very fast flip off of TIK onto me based on obviously barn and blind following of Tacky, i dont like this.
Tacky-Even though his attack on me is weak due to not reading everything, he has some valid questions which needed to be answered.
1. Indomitable bug- logical posting and sense throughout, so far, nothing pings even remotly on my scumdar, so here he goes for now
Quote from ExLighti am scumhunting. i contributed my thoughts on the naka and poiggy situation.
even though i sorta belive naka's claim, i think we should still be wary of her.
and i see no logic involved at all in poggy's constant harping of cops in past games. thus, i believe this is a distraction and it hampers the town.