All users will need to merge their MTGSalvation account with a new or existing Twitch account starting Sept 25th. You can merge your accounts by clicking here. Have questions? Learn more here.
Dismiss
 
Treasure Cruisin' Gifts Storm
 
The Role of Ecosystems in Fantasy Worldbuilding
 
Life's Legacy: Delving into Delver
  • posted a message on Pirates Mafia - Day 2 - The Woes of the Sea
    Quote from Rodemy »
    Feeling town from Rodemy. The lack of attention to the game... I feel that scum have to be more careful with their words and actions. I get a very genuine stream-of-consciousness read here.


    For future reference, this is not a tell, trust me. I am absent minded on both sides

    Thoughts on az being the only person able to successfully target?
    Can confirm. He literally botched his own fake claim in the scum game he just played.

    As far as Az successfully targeting; that is actually very peculiar.

    @Az: do you have anything in your role that stipulates you having magical powers that cause you not to be affected by abilities (prior to you gaining 2 souls)?
    Posted in: Mafia
  • posted a message on Pirates Mafia - Day 2 - The Woes of the Sea
    Quote from tomsloger »
    Having a little trouble fathoming both of you making judgment that it's too easy, in a less than 48 hour period since he posted, more than 2 weeks before deadline.
    Shrugs
    Thats just it though, I could not get hardly anyone to consider Nancy yesterday, and now a replacement and one real post earns him an entire thread against him that quickly? That’s like definitively too easy, what do you think it is?
    Posted in: Mafia
  • posted a message on Pirates Mafia - Day 2 - The Woes of the Sea
    Dota’s post was not as scummy as I think people are saying. It kind of depends on why he did it this way, but the surge of people onto him isn’t natural. So yeah, it could be bussing, but if people were going to bus Dota, why wait until you have a replacement that could potentially salvage the slot?

    Frankly, as it’s still only day 2, I’d be fine lynching him based on Nancy’s play alone, but outside factors make me want to dot my i’s and cross my t’s just to make sure this isn’t a more sinister plot.
    Posted in: Mafia
  • posted a message on Pirates Mafia - Day 2 - The Woes of the Sea
    Quote from Grapefruit21 »
    Quote from tomsloger »
    Not really convinced a buddy would put themselves out there in any way over that slot, grape. And hasn't really been enough time for resistance anyway.

    He's scummy. Go with it.

    I'm already voting Dota (via Nancy) just wanted to point it out. It's happening very easily right now, but it still feels right.
    This is exactly where I’m at; I pushed Nancy half the day yesterday and met a brick wall, and now it’s just effortless and I’m just a little bit spooked.

    Regarding the argument that it’s hipocritical for Dota to push a low poster when his predescesor was a lurker themselves: No, it’s not; regardless of his alignment, there’s nothing he can do about how Nancy played, and ignoring scumminess (perceived or actual) of another player just because it resembles a slot he replaced into doesn’t make sense. Anyone voting specifically because of this argument is wrong, and has earned me as a skeptic.

    Unvote for the time being. I still think it’s just largely likely that Dota is scum, but I’m less convinced than I was 24 hours ago.
    Posted in: Mafia
  • posted a message on Pirates Mafia - Day 2 - The Woes of the Sea
    @Terry: Same question to you as to AE, do you think the argument that Nancy posted very little actually holds water as a counter to Dota’s point on AE?
    Posted in: Mafia
  • posted a message on Pirates Mafia - Day 2 - The Woes of the Sea
    Quote from DoTArchon »


    Third, everyone should go and read the 17 posts made by Archmage Eternal. He has done nothing constructive in this game:
    Day 1
    So according to you we should also be voting you for your predecessors activity.
    Do you legitimately believe this is a good counter to Dota’s point on you or are you just being pedantic?
    Quote from D_V »
    I agree with Tom to an extent.

    But frankly I'm tired of feeling held hostage by any neutral.

    I'm tired of watching MTGS let claims like this stand. Lets just get this out of the way now instead of panicking when the bodies hit the floor.
    The reason claims like this stand is because our designers make creative roles; it’s a double edged sword in that we can have really unique and interesting setups but also have lots of room for scum to invent fake roles.

    I understand not wanting to be stuck with Az being deadweight or worse later in the game, but do you truly believe his claim is a lie?
    Posted in: Mafia
  • posted a message on Pirates Mafia - Day 2 - The Woes of the Sea
    Quote from tomsloger »
    Quote from shadowlancerx »
    So just so that I have it on record: Do you actively believe that Dawning and I are dichotomized? As in, do you actively believe we both can’t be town?

    Not sure where i would even get such information barring a CC. But I strongly believe dawning to have been scum, and in the offchance she wasn't your scum equity goes way up.

    Actually... sure. I think there's exactly one scum in you/dawn 95% of the time.
    But you make up ~rand of that percentage.
    Okay, justify this. Specifically what makes it impossible for us to both be town?
    (As an aside, this conversation even happening is beyond frustrating, because I’m not even sure it’s going to be relevant.)
    Posted in: Mafia
  • posted a message on Pirates Mafia - Day 2 - The Woes of the Sea
    Quote from Nancy Drew 39 »
    Vote: Shadow
    Vote Nancy Drew
    If you’re town you need to make a miraculous turn around right now and actually do something that shows it.
    Posted in: Mafia
  • posted a message on Pirates Mafia - Day 2 - The Woes of the Sea
    Quote from Rodemy »
    If you are a loudmouth, then whoever targets you would be revealed. So if someone targeted you, we'd know.
    I actually would like clarity to this as well.
    Quote from vezokpiraka »
    @shadow: The post in question (I'm on phone and can't quote) added nothing of value and told others not to claim if they got redirected. Almost everyone should realise why it's a bad idea, but you said it to appear useful. As an aside scum are the ones who get furious for getting caught for wrong reasons. Town don't really care.
    I said it because several people started referencing it, meaning it was clear that something major happened, and enough people who hadn’t said something might not have thought about the ramifications of speaking up.

    As far as your other point...yes? By definition a townie that’s “caught” is always for the wrong reasons, but I’m not really sure why this is relevant unless you are accusing me of being cftwr?
    Quote from tomsloger »
    On the other hand, i don't think he was conspiring with dawning. And making him walk the plank would all but garauntee we only get one the first two days.
    Which isn't terrible in no flip but not amazing.
    So just so that I have it on record: Do you actively believe that Dawning and I are dichotomized? As in, do you actively believe we both can’t be town?
    Posted in: Mafia
  • posted a message on Pirates Mafia - Day 2 - The Woes of the Sea
    Quote from vezokpiraka »
    Antyone have one good reason why Azrael shoudln't be dealt with today?

    I have Rodemy as solid town even though I think he's kinda dumb.

    The post from shadow seems like a typical scum post. I kinda want him dead. It seems like he knew dbs was not going to flip and that's why he kept that charade going.
    Oh yeah? So why didn’t you vote me then?

    What makes my post a “typical scum post”?

    I’m sick of the 9000 people saying I’m scum with like literally nothing to back it up or put substance to it. If you don’t agree with a read I have or a post I made, call me out so we can have discourse about it.
    Posted in: Mafia
  • posted a message on Pirates Mafia - Day 2 - The Woes of the Sea
    Quote from Rodemy »
    Quote from shadowlancerx »
    Quote from Rodemy »
    Vote Azreal

    Probably controls the kraken.

    Also stole my soul last night.

    Pretty sure he is lying about his wincon. Just, can we kill. Please?
    What makes you think the bolded?

    I was redirected last night. I was told specifically because of fear of the Kraken -_-


    Oh it is total flavorgaming at this point.
    )


    Davy Jones controlled the Kraken in POTC.

    We need to **** the **** outta this kraken (Which i tried last night. Got my soul stolen instead :/)

    Who did you target?

    Are you claiming Vig that attempted to shoot at Az? Cause that’s what it sounds like you are claiming. Probably you shouldn’t say either way unless you have pertinent info, but I have a theory :thinking:
    Posted in: Mafia
  • posted a message on Pirates Mafia - Day 2 - The Woes of the Sea
    Hmm, I think probably most (if not all) people with active abilities were affected; I think no one else should say anything because we don’t need scum knowing who all has active abilities.
    Posted in: Mafia
  • posted a message on Pirates Mafia - Day 2 - The Woes of the Sea
    Also “Normal”
    -_-
    Posted in: Mafia
  • posted a message on Pirates Mafia - Day 2 - The Woes of the Sea
    Quote from Rodemy »
    Vote Azreal

    Probably controls the kraken.

    Also stole my soul last night.

    Pretty sure he is lying about his wincon. Just, can we kill. Please?
    What makes you think the bolded?

    I was redirected last night. I was told specifically because of fear of the Kraken -_-
    Posted in: Mafia
  • posted a message on Emperor Mafia - Game Over: The Empire Reigns Eternal - TOWN WIN
    Scum got onto the back foot early email just couldn’t recover, though it is interesting that if Dawning had been lynched, pod could have attempted the hero shot on Tom and won.

    Overall quick game and looked fun!
    Posted in: Mafia
  • To post a comment, please or register a new account.