Please explain how "we didn't need the scum getting this much information so early" knowing that. A.) This rule might not even exist in this game, it's just a possibility and B.) Why do you think this is actually useful to the scum team more so than town?
@Tom
Hey tom. You enjoying your this game so far?
@Everyone else
I think hans is my biggest town read right now.
This game has weird rules. I learn possible rules (these rules might exist, might not). Today I learned the rule that if someone's role contradicts a game rule, the role will win.
Also about NPCs. Didn't porcelain mafia have them?
Pretty sure the best way to play it is try and lynch scummy behavior. I wanna say one of the NPCS was scum and we thought it was a waste of a lynch so we lost, but I think a previous scum player that died got to replace one of the npcs.
If I said I'm considering claiming and leaning towards it, do you think I would do so without a valid reason?
I don't understand the point of the question you asked me. If I share my reasoning for wanting to claim, I can't really do that without claiming because it won't make sense.
I know some information that might be useful. If I tell no one, it helps one town. If I tell everyone then it helps town and scum.
Given that the information doesn't seem super useful I'm leaning towards just saying it.
Tom town firmed hans without good reasoning. I asked for a better explanation and crap was given.
There is one thing that he said that makes me wonder if I'm wrong about him but I'll let him respond to TS before I elaborate. I think if I add more pressure to him he might implode regardless of alignment which would be bad.
@Proph
What do you think of GJ's no lynch suggestion/opener?
I thought hans was lying about being the cause of starting on day 2 because this game is screwy and I thought he was being cute and trying to take credit and lie for no reason.
Whether he did or didnt, tom and anak both said that was towny? I could only see this as null andd the spred of towning hans seems off.
I'd like a better explanation from both tom and anak now.
Hey tom you enjoying your game thus far?
I must have screwed something up while phone posting.
Please explain how "we didn't need the scum getting this much information so early" knowing that. A.) This rule might not even exist in this game, it's just a possibility and B.) Why do you think this is actually useful to the scum team more so than town?
@Tom
Hey tom. You enjoying your this game so far?
@Everyone else
I think hans is my biggest town read right now.
Claiming was my personal choice and I think it helps the town more to get information like this out in the open.
Pretty sure the best way to play it is try and lynch scummy behavior. I wanna say one of the NPCS was scum and we thought it was a waste of a lynch so we lost, but I think a previous scum player that died got to replace one of the npcs.
It's been a while and if have to look it up.
If I said I'm considering claiming and leaning towards it, do you think I would do so without a valid reason?
I don't understand the point of the question you asked me. If I share my reasoning for wanting to claim, I can't really do that without claiming because it won't make sense.
I know some information that might be useful. If I tell no one, it helps one town. If I tell everyone then it helps town and scum.
Given that the information doesn't seem super useful I'm leaning towards just saying it.
Tom town firmed hans without good reasoning. I asked for a better explanation and crap was given.
There is one thing that he said that makes me wonder if I'm wrong about him but I'll let him respond to TS before I elaborate. I think if I add more pressure to him he might implode regardless of alignment which would be bad.
@Proph
What do you think of GJ's no lynch suggestion/opener?
I thought hans was lying about being the cause of starting on day 2 because this game is screwy and I thought he was being cute and trying to take credit and lie for no reason.
Whether he did or didnt, tom and anak both said that was towny? I could only see this as null andd the spred of towning hans seems off.
I'd like a better explanation from both tom and anak now.
I agree with GJ on LAL, not no lynching.
Why does it matter if you are voting someone at the end of the day?