2019 Holiday Exchange!
 
A New and Exciting Beginning
 
The End of an Era
  • posted a message on Why Did So Many Cards Have Different Artwork in Seventh Edition?
    It was a gimmick to try and get people to actually buy the Core Set for once, and it failed for two reasons:

    1 - Players use card art to recognize cards, so changing all of them kinda screwed the pooch there.
    2 - A lot of the art sucked.
    Posted in: Magic General
  • posted a message on [SCD] Haunted Platemail
    Quote from aeonflux
    It's playability also depends a bit on how many Putrefys will get played. Because attacking with a platemailed creature opens you for a nice two-for-one against Putrefy.
    How is Putrefy a two-for-one against Plate Mail? You can only blow up the Mail or the creature, not both.
    Posted in: Standard Archives
  • posted a message on [[M14]] Magic 2014 Underwhelming
    Quote from Xcric
    the thing that irks me the most, more than that if i spend 4 dollars on a pack i have almost no chance of opening 4 dollars in cards, is that the lgs suffers when they design crappy sets.

    It's like that with pretty much every set though. For every good rare, there's like ten bad ones. It's always been this way. Return to Ravnica spoiled people IMO.
    Posted in: New Card Discussion
  • posted a message on So.... Goyf
    Quote from darksteel88
    If you don't like 5/6s for 2, I don't know what's wrong with you.

    I think everybody likes 5/6s for two, they just don't like $110-20 5/6s for 2, because then there's divisiveness between the haves and the have-nots. For what it's worth though, Goyf isn't an auto-include in green decks. Neither Pod deck plays him, presumably because Pod decks are half creatures, and Scapeshift doesn't play him either. He's really at his best when paired with a heavy amount of removal and discard spells or counterspells. The countermagic is kinda lacking in Modern, so the BGx shell is really the best place for him.
    Posted in: Modern
  • posted a message on [Primer] Kiki Pod (7/2012 - 1/2015)
    Quote from FredWilson
    Has anyone considered running Loxodon Hierarch over Obstinate Baloth in the SB? I feel that being able to defend your combo is better than protection from Thoughtseize.

    I like this idea. It's technically easier to cast than Obby in the deck, and anti-sweeper tech is sweet. That being said, I don't play Obstinate Baloth to begin with, as my sideboard is as follows:



    I'm experimenting with the Wear/Tears in place of Ancient Grudges, because Blood Moon is such a beating against this deck, I'll sacrifice a little of my Affinity match-up to deal with it, but I think the overall amount of instants in my sideboard's notable. Basically, I try to make my maindeck as combo/Domri-friendly as possible, then sacrifice a little bit of that games two and three for relevant hate. Path is definitely the most important card. It deals with opposing Pod-fueled combos, Goyfs, Collonades. Pretty much everything except for dorks and Geist.
    Posted in: Modern Archives - Established
  • posted a message on [Primer] Kiki Pod (7/2012 - 1/2015)
    Quote from Ale^^
    Hi guys, what do u think about Phantasmal Image after the new rules? he can't kill linvala (and so on) anymore but he can make the 1 and 2 drop pod chain.. perhaps would agree to remove it to make room for another? Just 1 exarch ( 2 drop chain and help A LOT vs GR tron) or another silver bullet..

    Image has to stay, as the one-two chain is too important to the deck.
    Posted in: Modern Archives - Established
  • posted a message on Probability of opening Mythic Rare, Foil Mythic Rare?
    Quote from cardboardcrack
    Roughly, the odds of any mythic rare is 1 in 8 packs, and there are 11 mythics in Dragon's Maze, so the odds of getting a Voice are 1 in 88 packs.

    Foils are 1 in 6 packs. Assuming that they have the same rarity distribution as non-foils, there's 1 foil Voice in every 528 packs.

    Putting this together, there's a 1 in 46,464 chance of opening a pack with both a foil and non-foil Voice.

    Your math is slightly off. Maze's End only appears on the land sheet, and shouldn't be considered for these calculations. Theoretically, it's possible to get three mythics in one pack when opening DGM.
    Posted in: Magic General
  • posted a message on [[M14]] DailyMTG Previews 7/3 - Blightcaster ; Haunted Plate Mail
    Quote from Guesswork
    Likewise, I will honestly be surprised if Theros doesn't have a tribal theme, given reprints like Mutavault and Door of Destinies in M14, not to mention the whole M14 Sliver thing that's priming that pump.

    Consider that a wager, if you like. Wink

    Why would you be surprised when both of those rares are pricey (one waaaaay more than the other but still) yet not so pricey as to anger 'collectors' with a reprint, and they're both pickable for Sliver limited. Mutavault and Ooze alone guarantee this set will sell. Hell, I might just start going to drafts and forcing Slivers every time I go so I can pick Vaults and Doors without feeling bad. They just did tribal with Innistrad, so even if it is a theme, it's going to be a minor theme, while enchantment stuff might be meaty enough to be a landfall-worthy mechanic.

    On the cards at hand, Blightspeaker is junky and Plate Mail, while flavorful, isn't that awesome either. All the awesomeness has been released. Spoiler season is in the dying embers, alas.

    On second thought, Plate Mail both in and against decks with Supreme Verdict makes sense. In the decks with Supreme Verdict, you can stick it to your Aetherlings, and against it, you have a Batterskull-equivalent buff to P/T to let you slow-roll your creatures and a dude for when they sweep.
    Posted in: The Rumor Mill
  • posted a message on So, how do you think the RtR storyline will end?
    I'm quite surprised that nobody's posted this yet, but I'm curious as to how the threesome of novellas ended. If somebody could spoil it for me, I'd be most appreciative.
    Posted in: Magic Storyline
  • posted a message on WU Aura Deck
    Quote from dotmatrix
    Anyone tried tossing around the old Mythic Conscription deck or something?

    Heck, looks like it's even in Modern archives somewhere...

    Mythic Conscription doesn't work without Jace, the Mind Sculptor to prop it up. You need him as both a solid plan B in case a Pyroclasm wipes out your dorks and as a way to shuffle drawn Conscriptions back into your library.
    Posted in: Modern
  • posted a message on [Primer] Kiki Pod (7/2012 - 1/2015)
    Quote from Xopar
    Okay thanks. And yeah two people at my LGS play mill and one doesn't play extractions so they just lose to it.

    In that case, I'd recommend Loaming Shaman over/in addition to Emrakul. It doesn't auto-shuffle when it hits the 'yard, but you can Pod into it, blink it, and copy it, and once it's done it's job, you can keep moving up the chain.
    Posted in: Modern Archives - Established
  • posted a message on [Primer] Kiki Pod (7/2012 - 1/2015)
    Why is there an Emrakul in your sideboard? You can't cast it or Pod into it. Is it just anti-mill tech?

    Also, Back to Nature is some pretty sweet anti-Bogle tech.
    Posted in: Modern Archives - Established
  • posted a message on Modern Masters Draft Prices?
    Wow, I can't believe my LGS is the highest-priced so far. $50 a draft. I don't know what the prize support is because there's no way I'm shelling out that much to play a format I don't like.
    Posted in: Magic General
  • posted a message on How much will Innistrad decrease in value after standard rotation?
    Quote from Xenphire
    Not tryint to bust your balls, but can you tell me any of the decks that play the cards that you quoted?

    For reference:

    Huntmaster of the Fells
    Falkenrath Aristocrat
    Olivia Voladaren
    Gravecrawler
    Geralf's Messenger
    Restoration Angel

    I don't know of any that play any of those, and honestly, considering how quickly Modern picks up on playable cards, if they were Modern playable they'd already be played consistently.

    Restoration Angel is a solid 3-4 of in Kiki-Pod, you know. Couple that with the fact that it's an Angel and it should hold some value.
    Posted in: Magic General
  • posted a message on Elesh norn's price
    Norn is one of the two creatures that's part of the Gifts Ungiven/Unburial Rites reanimation package that is featured in some decks in Modern. The other one is Iona, Shield of Emeria. As a Kiki-Pod player, which means I play a lot of small creatures as well as four different colors, Norn is much more devastating against me than Iona. I can't combo off with it in play because Kiki's toughness is reduced to 0, and the debuff coupled with the 4/7 vigilant body means I probably won't be winning the beatdown game either.
    Posted in: Market Street Café
  • To post a comment, please or register a new account.