2019 Holiday Exchange!
 
A New and Exciting Beginning
 
The End of an Era
  • posted a message on Team Mafia Game 3 - Monster Manual Mafia (End Game - Open Your Eyes)
    my only regret was reading as much as i did

    thank god i'm out of this stupid game
    Posted in: Mafia
  • posted a message on Team Mafia Game 3 - Monster Manual Mafia (End Game - Open Your Eyes)
    Vote: Wheat
    Posted in: Mafia
  • posted a message on Team Mafia Game 3 - Monster Manual Mafia (End Game - Open Your Eyes)
    There's a lot of things that would have been nice but didn't happen.
    Posted in: Mafia
  • posted a message on Team Mafia Game 3 - Monster Manual Mafia (End Game - Open Your Eyes)
    Quote from Tammy »
    How man entrances did you practice in the mirror before settling on that winner?


    how many times did you hit the post reply button

    Quote from Tammy »
    How man entrances did you practice in the mirror before settling on that winner?


    how many times did you hit the post reply button
    Posted in: Mafia
  • posted a message on Team Mafia Game 3 - Monster Manual Mafia (End Game - Open Your Eyes)
    what happened last night was really uncool
    Posted in: Mafia
  • posted a message on Team Mafia Game 3 - Monster Manual Mafia (End Game - Open Your Eyes)
    Quote from Foopme »
    Quote from Wheat_Grinder »
    oh hey mtgs isn't crashing repeatedly anymore

    for now, anyway.

    With the downtimes as well as a crunch time at work, I still haven't gotten off of page 13. I'm planning to get up to speed overNight moreso now as a result.

    I'm willing to hammer Grape. I'll do so sometime toMorrow if someone else hasn't already.
    Yeah I’m probably speed lunching you toMorrow so glgl

    sounds tasty

    Either way I've made my peace with it. I think my flip will prove you and Tammy scum so I think it's necessary.
    Posted in: Mafia
  • posted a message on Team Mafia Game 3 - Monster Manual Mafia (End Game - Open Your Eyes)
    oh hey mtgs isn't crashing repeatedly anymore

    for now, anyway.

    With the downtimes as well as a crunch time at work, I still haven't gotten off of page 13. I'm planning to get up to speed overNight moreso now as a result.

    I'm willing to hammer Grape. I'll do so sometime toMorrow if someone else hasn't already.
    Posted in: Mafia
  • posted a message on Team Mafia Game 3 - Monster Manual Mafia (End Game - Open Your Eyes)
    I read page 13 yesterday and the site crashed when I went to page 14, catching me up short.

    I won't be able to read much today either unfortunately due to plans. I'll try to read a few pages but no promises.

    I don't mind voting Grape at this point to end the Day. I could catch up during the Night and make one last catchup mega post.
    Posted in: Mafia
  • posted a message on Team Mafia Game 3 - Monster Manual Mafia (End Game - Open Your Eyes)
    If work isn't too busy tomorrow I'm hoping to catch up a bit faster on mobile but I probably won't comment on much at all if I do.
    Posted in: Mafia
  • posted a message on Team Mafia Game 3 - Monster Manual Mafia (End Game - Open Your Eyes)
    I'm probably going to be fairly brief in most of my remaining catchup in the interest of catching up since I'm feeling good on my reads.

    Tammy's #359 has more lines I dislike. "I want empoof to be town because I just like empoof's posting. Also he called me town." "Again the only real read I have right now is a town read on RE" < as of post 359 in the game (if I'm being generous I think this is actually only after having read to some undefined point past 225).

    Tammy also says "I am a bit concerned about grapefruit here, but I'm reserving any thoughts until I catch up because I know there's a wagon on him and I'm interested in the reaction and people's reasons and because I need to step away now."

    I see this as laying the ground for a bus without having to commit. Unfortunately scum having daytalk makes it weaker than normal since without daytalk it indicates to a buddy "hey, shape up so I can read you as town without going out on a limb for you" but I think here it's still valid as a move to cover bases and prevent suspicion if grape flips.


    oh hey marko finally posted in #411. ...but I don't get a whole lot of motive from it.

    Quote from Tammy »
    Oh empoof - I left you a message this morning from my team. It was just a drunken trolly way of saying hello and being silly.


    @Tammy: Please explain this, now. And I'm really sad no one picked up on this Frown

    Empoof makes a bunch of reads but also fails to call anyone scum in #444 which I really don't like.

    I disagree with the content of #476 from SR but I think it implies a townie mindset - the reasoning feels organic. I'm willing to upgrade SR to full town at this point.

    #538 from Empoof: "Kind of unlucky considering my slot is like... probably the most contentious slot in the game, with the most tug and pull."

    I did not get this impression at all and am curious to hear why Empoof thought this. But I think asking now is useless, let's play "Did anyone ask about it?"

    Empoof has been NOTICABLY concerned about marko all game and at first I thought it was some sort of joke but the fact it's still going on page 10 is really weird. But I don't get the impression they're buddies, so why is it happening?

    I don't have an answer for it, I'm just writing it out so I keep it on my mind as I continue reading.

    If RE reads this post despite being dead: I respect you as a mafia player, particularly for #586.

    Empoof's post #594 is weird. It reads as though Empoof thinks my slot is town but is mad at my slot for playing badly, while calling it scum. I just don't like it.

    That brings me to the end of page 12. Changes in reads:

    SR to town from lean town
    Empoof to scum from lean scum
    marko from "literally no posts" to null
    Posted in: Mafia
  • posted a message on Team Mafia Game 3 - Monster Manual Mafia (End Game - Open Your Eyes)
    Tammy and Empoof's first reactions to my post are "holy ***** he scum"

    feels good to be a gangsta

    Quote from Scarlet Rage »
    Quote from Wheat_Grinder »
    I haven't actually read any of this game because I'm not a good teammate. I'm starting from the beginning now.

    Wait we can sub for our teammates?


    I can't talk about this I think but I think generally not.

    I forgot to quote your post where you questioned my list but I knew I was forgetting something. You're actually at lean town.

    Weird thing from the 6 page catchup @Wheat_Grinder, you have Tammy and Empoof at different levels on your scale despite reading them off the same interaction. What made Tammy come off as worse than Empoof?


    I already answered this question in my scumlist. It's because Empoof suddenly started making decent points, enough to make me question the read, and Tammy hasn't had a post that makes me reconsider.
    Posted in: Mafia
  • posted a message on Team Mafia Game 3 - Monster Manual Mafia (End Game - Open Your Eyes)
    I'm mostly not going to comment on the dead.

    Page 1:

    SC and Trob's interactions seem town/town.

    Empoof's opening seems like he's trying too hard. I actually get a similar vibe from Tammy, and the fact that they talk to each other while trying too hard is an interaction that to me indicates the possibility of scummates.

    Tubba's entrance is weird and that probably means it's town.

    I really don't like Tammy's #30.

    I dislike Grapefruit as well. His lack of commitment on trob looks really weird and out of place on page 1. "I think this guy is scummy, better...not actually do anything about it"???

    I strongly dislike Empoof's #50. He's lining up to vote Trob which is seeming like a pretty bad wagon and not just that, he won't commit to it either.

    Page 2:

    Tammy's #60 seems really forced and once again Empoof is involved.

    i wish empoof would stop posting broken image links

    I'm starting to like Voxxicus. Nothing stands truly out but #91 is enough for a town lean.

    ...then #92 happened. yuck. back to neutral on voxx.

    Page 3:

    oh hey my slot appears...and I disagree with all the reads Frown

    maybe i should've read this game after all

    SC is still my strongest townread.

    Ara's alignement taken in retrospect, I particularly dislike Tammy's #149 praising the push.

    Page 4:

    SR's #157 feels like a townslip - "Considering I have little confidence in my read of you, a direct fight does nothing for me either." I don't see a scum saying those words.

    Page 5:

    I hope tubba starts playing the game because I actually feel like he's probably town.

    Page 6:

    yuck #260 from grapefruit 'But yeah saying "I'm currently gut reading ScarletCelestial as scum." and then never voting them isn't really scum reading them.'

    grape doesn't actually believe this

    empoof is beginning to sound less scummy but I'm not over the interactions with Tammy yet.

    all right that's six pages. I'll be reading more tomorrow but for now...

    worst (r. trob) - town (good interactions with SC to start, and the reactions to other players along the way felt organic)
    SC - town (good interactions with trob, intentions seem unfailingly pure)

    voxx - lean town (Reads seem organic even when against people who flipped town, but I didn't like a failure to go after an early scumread in #92)
    tubba - lean town (doesn't post much content but scum would be too self-conscious to do that RP game)

    SR - null (I haven't seen a post that really moved the dial on SR for me.)
    marko - has not had any posts as of the end of page 6.

    empoof - lean scum (early interactions with tammy point to buddies but by page 6 is starting to make more sense. Gonna keep a close eye here)

    grape - scum (several yucky posts, but the real killer is #260 where he persists with a terrible read for bull***** reasoning)
    tammy - scum (early interactions with empoof point to buddies, and nothing has pointed me away from that feeling since)
    Posted in: Mafia
  • posted a message on Team Mafia Game 3 - Monster Manual Mafia (End Game - Open Your Eyes)
    I haven't actually read any of this game because I'm not a good teammate. I'm starting from the beginning now.
    Posted in: Mafia
  • posted a message on Team Mafia Game 1 - The Death of Stalin - Game Over
    I agree with 1274.
    Posted in: Mafia
  • posted a message on Team Mafia Game 1 - The Death of Stalin - Game Over
    Roz probably won't show up. They disappeared right after a reveal I really wanted to read.

    We should have had an extension
    Posted in: Mafia
  • To post a comment, please or register a new account.