That is a "missed trigger" and the ruling has changed recently that players must announce their triggers regardless if they are a may ability. If the player misses the trigger, it doesn't happen.
So, I was in a game and one of our players had an issue with how damage and negatives affect a creatures toughness. We know that damage wears off at ends of phases and negatives that aren't counters last until end of turn but here are the questions:
1. Does damage and negatives literally alter the toughness of the creature?
2. Can damage and negatives be stacked?
I read the first four pages and have only three things to say:
1. No matter what law could be passed to make guns harder to obtain/ban, these shooting can still happen.
2. Being an AR15 does not mean its automatic by any means. AR15's are civilian models of the M4 rifles. Both rifles are considered assault rifles. AR stands for assault rifle. AK47s are assault rifles as well. Both ARs and AKs are legal in almost all states and are generally not used for shootings because they are harder to hide.
3. Guns will be obtained by people no matter what the government does.
Activate Scion twice, choosing Skithiryx first, the Moltensteel.
Pay 12 life to pump the Moltensteel, then it becomes Skithiryx.
Give him Haste and hit for 10 infect.
Being able to identify the exact cards that are missing is crucial if you file a police report. Make sure you have a list and if you can remember, the editions of missing cards.
No, because your not playing it from anywhere. The plane is responsible for it and simply puts it onto the battlefield. Same goes for the second ability on the plane. When you roll a chaos, you will still be able to return a creature to the battlefield. The only thing Grafdigger's Cage does is keep cards like Gravecrawler from being casted from the yard.
Looking for mostly EDH stuff as well as a bunch of common cards that people usually don't ask for so dig out your old cards because I probably want it. I would like it if you would please post here, then PM me. Also, prices are firm but not set in stone so if you want to offer, go ahead.
Two simple rules:
--Shipping is $3.00 in the CONUS. This includes a bubble mailer, top loaders, and Delivery Confirmation.
--I can do credit or buy outright any cards in my Want list. I prefer to do credit.
This really doesn't change the answer to the question "Is the search mandatory?", but the real solution for the OP, every time, should be to call a judge. I'd encourage the OP to get in the habit of doing so in situations like this.
A search is mandatory, but finding something is not. So at most, the deck should have been shuffled.
If you play a Farseek, you may search but if you choose nothing, you would just shuffle your deck. I have played such cards just to shuffle my deck before.
Can Bioshift be used soley for the Heroic trigger and not move any counters?
Thanks, just asking.
1. Does damage and negatives literally alter the toughness of the creature?
2. Can damage and negatives be stacked?
Thanks in advance.
1. No matter what law could be passed to make guns harder to obtain/ban, these shooting can still happen.
2. Being an AR15 does not mean its automatic by any means. AR15's are civilian models of the M4 rifles. Both rifles are considered assault rifles. AR stands for assault rifle. AK47s are assault rifles as well. Both ARs and AKs are legal in almost all states and are generally not used for shootings because they are harder to hide.
3. Guns will be obtained by people no matter what the government does.
Is that how this thread works?
Skithiryx, the Blight Dragon
Moltensteel Dragon
Activate Scion twice, choosing Skithiryx first, the Moltensteel.
Pay 12 life to pump the Moltensteel, then it becomes Skithiryx.
Give him Haste and hit for 10 infect.
Two simple rules:
--Shipping is $3.00 in the CONUS. This includes a bubble mailer, top loaders, and Delivery Confirmation.
--I can do credit or buy outright any cards in my Want list. I prefer to do credit.
Quantity/Name/Price I will pay for
WANT LIST:
1x Genesis - $9.00
1x Woodfall Primus - $8.50
1x Chord of Calling - $8.00
1x Elesh Norn, Grand Cenobite - $7.00
1x Idyllic Tutor - $6.50
1x Phyrexian Altar - $6.00
1x Mirror Entity - $6.00
1x Stoneforge Mystic - $6.00
1x Karmic Guide - $5.50
1x Kitchen Finks - $5.50
1x Gaddock Teeg - $5.00
1x High Market - $3.50
1x Eladamri's Call - $3.00
1x Leyline of Sanctity - $3.00
1x Green Sun's Zenith - $3.00
1x Reveillark - $3.00
1x Fauna Shaman - $3.00
1x Greater Good - $3.00
1x Pattern of Rebirth - $3.00
1x Grand Abolisher - $2.00
1x Spike Weaver - $2.00
1x Dryad Arbor - $1.50
1x Emeria, the Sky Ruin - $1.50
1x Parallax Wave - $1.25
1x Birthing Pod - $1.25
1x Martyr's Bond - $0.75
1x Mortarpod - $0.75
1x Ashnod's Altar - $0.75
1x Saffi Eriksdotter - $0.50
1x Melira, Sylvok Outcast - $0.50
1x Qasali Pridemage - $0.50
1x Krosan Verge - $0.50
1x Spore Frog - $0.25
1x Riftsweeper - $0.25
1x Fiend Hunter - $0.25
1x Harmonic Sliver - $0.25
1x Ouphe Vandals - $0.25
1x Wood Elves - $0.25
1x Yavimaya Elder - $0.25
1x False Prophet - $0.25
1x Acidic Slime - $0.25
1x Archon of Justice - $0.25
1x Nature's Lore - $0.25
1x Cultivate - $0.25
1x Martyr's Cause - $0.25
1x Mistveil Plains - $0.25
1x Stonehorn Dignitary - $0.10
HAVE LIST:
Standard:
1x Overgrown Tomb - $10.00
1x Temporal Mastery - $8.50
1x Rest in Peace (Foil) - $6.00
1x Rakdos's Return - $5.50
1x Isperia, Supreme Judge (Foil) - $5.50
1x Desecration Demon (Foil) - $3.50
1x Niv-Mizzet, Dracogenius - $3.00
1x Ash Zealot - $2.50
1x Jarad, Golgari Lich Lord - $1.50
1x Epic Experiment - $1.50
1x Necropolis Regent - $1.25
1x Precinct Captain - $1.00
1x Isperia, Supreme Judge - $1.00
1x Slaughter Games - $0.75
2x Pithing Needle - $0.50
1x Pack Rat - $0.50
1x Underworld Connections - $0.50
2x Nivmagus Elemental - $0.50
1x Collective Blessing - $0.50
4x Corpsejack Menace - $0.50
3x Havoc Festival - $0.25
2x Righteous Authority - $0.25
1x Volatile Rig - $0.25
2x Grove of the Guardian - $0.25
2x Palisade Giant - $0.25
1x Martial Law - $0.25
1x Search the City - $0.25
1x Sphinx of the Chimes - $0.25
2x Conjured Currency - $0.25
2x Chaos Imps - $0.25
1x Guild Feud - $0.25
1x Deadbridge Goliath - $0.25
3x Death's Presence
2x Mana Bloom - $0.25
2x Wild Beastmaster - $0.25
3x Azor's Elocutors - $0.25
1x Carnival Hellsteed - $0.25
1x Firemind's Foresight - $0.25
1x Mercurial Chemister - $0.25
1x Archon of the Triumvirate - $0.25
2x Jarad's Orders - $0.25
Everything else:
Red:
3x Through the Breach - $3.50
1x Akroma, Angel of Fury - $2.50
1x Splinter Twin - $2.50
1x Mana Flare - $2.50 (Revised)
4x Dragonspeaker Shaman - $2.00
1x Dragon Mage - $2.00
2x Two-Headed Dragon - $1.50
2x Pyromancer's Swath - $1.50
1x Crucible of Fire - $1.50
2x Greater Gargadon - $1.50
$1.00 List
1x Blistering Firecat (Played)
1x Kilnmouth Dragon
4x Seething Song (3x 9th/1x Mirrodin)
1x Countryside Crusher
1x Bringer of the Red Dawn
$0.75 List
3x Lightning Serpent
1x Predator Dragon
1x Comet Storm
1x Decree of Annihilation
1x Pandemonium
$0.50 List
1x Goblin Assault
1x Form of the Dragon
2x Fiery Gambit
1x Molten Disaster
3x Furnace of Rath (Played)
2x Tarox Bladewing
1x Voracious Dragon
1x Hunted Dragon
1x Avatar of Slaughter
$0.25 List
1x Worldheart Phoenix
1x Fortune Thief
2x Warp World
1x Hammerfist Giant
1x Caldera Hellion
1x Rukh Egg
2x Ashling's Prerogative
1x Scoria Wurm
1x Veteran Brawlers
1x Vicious Shadows
1x Fatal Frenzy
1x Latulla, Keldon Overseer
1x Breath of Fury
1x Karplusan Yeti
1x Pardic Dragon
1x Excruciator
1x Megatog
1x Bloodshot Cyclops
1x Bloodfire Colossus
1x Boldwyr Heavyweights
2x Titan's Revenge
3x Borderland Behemoth
1x Earthquake
2x Disintegrate
4x Citadel of Pain
1x Galvanoth
1x Rite of Ruin
2x Shimatsu the Bloodcloaked
1x Shunt
3x Grip of Chaos
3x Confusion in the Ranks
3x Recoup
Artifacts:
1x Engineered Explosives - $12.00
1x Mycosynth Golem - $12.00
2x Chalice of the Void - $8.00
2x Darksteel Colossus - $4.00
1x Deathrender - $4.00
1x Platinum Angel - $3.00
2x Serpent Generator (Legends) - $3.00
1x Tormod's Crypt (The Dark) - $3.00
1x Font of Mythos - $2.50
1x Darksteel Reactor - $2.00
2x Belbe's Portal - $1.50
1x Sentinel - $1.00
1x Scythe of the Wretched - $1.00
2x Power Matrix - $1.00
$0.50 List
1x Umbilicus
1x Lodestone Myr
1x Clearwater Goblet
1x Krark's Thumb
1x Gauntlets of Chaos
1x Summoner's Egg
1x Door to Nothingness
4x The Rack (Revised)
$0.25 List
1x Sigil of Distinction
1x Razormane Masticore
2x Gemini Engine
1x Worldslayer
1x Bloodletter Quill
1x Triskelavus
1x Sphinx-Bone Wand
1x Blinkmoth Urn
1x Nullstone Gargoyle
1x Tooth of Ramos
1x Sarpadian Empires, Vol. VII
1x Candles of Leng
3x Pentavus
1x Lich's Tomb
5x Urza's Armor
1x Grindclock
1x Gate to the Aether
3x Conjurer's Closet
Black:
1x Temporal Extortion - $2.00
1x Fallen Angel (Legends) - $1.50
1x Persecute (Urza's Saga) - $1.00
1x Mad Auntie - $1.00
2x Midnight Banshee - $1.00
1x Skeletal Vampire - $0.75
1x Conspiracy - $0.75
1x Royal Assassin - $0.75
$0.50 List
1x Aether Snap
1x Reiver Demon
1x Rhystic Tutor
1x Shriveling Rot
2x Death Pits of Rath
1x Sadistic Sacrament
1x Sorceress Queen (5th)
1x Curse of the Cabal
1x Ad Nauseam
1x Dread Cacodemon
1x Mindslicer
$0.25 List
1x Volrath's Dungeon
1x Empty the Catacombs
1x Desecration Elemental
3x Blood Funnel
1x Moonlight Bargain
1x Parallax Nexus
1x Larceny
1x Nihilistic Glee
1x Immortal Coil
1x Plague Sliver
1x Weirding Shaman
2x Auntie's Snitch
1x Midnight Ritual
1x Fendeep Summoner
1x Woebringer Demon
1x Painful Quandry
1x Call to the Grave
Blue:
1x Keiga, the Tide Star - $6.00
3x Time Stretch - $6.00
1x Master of Etherium - $3.00
2x Lord of Atlantis - $3.00
1x Intruder Alarm - $2.50
1x Acquire - $1.50
2x Cytoplast Manipulator - $1.50
1x Magus of the Future - $1.50
1x Wheel and Deal - $1.00
1x Vedalken Archmage - $1.00
1x Day of the Dragons - $1.00
3x Forced Fruition - $1.00
1x Fabricate - $.075
1x Parallax Tide - $0.75
1x Broodstar - $0.75
1x Decree of Silence - $0.50
1x Sigil Tracer - $0.50
$0.25 List
1x Animate Artifact
2x Notorious Throng
2x Vizzerdrix
1x Cerulean Sphinx
1x Ixidron
1x Eye of the Storm
1x Karn's Touch
1x Blinkmoth Infusion
1x Moonlace
1x Grozoth
1x Dream Leash
1x Mind Bend
1x Trade Routes
1x Psychic Possession
1x Mahamoti Djinn
1x Thought Devourer
1x Rimefeather Owl
1x Spawnbroker
1x Chromescale Drake
1x Dreamborn Muse
1x Skill Borrower
2x Slithermuse
1x Supreme Exemplar
1x Inexorable Tide
1x Djinn of Wishes
White:
1x Ethersworn Canonist - $6.00
1x Stonehewer Giant - $4.00
3x Reya Dawnbringer (10th) - $3.00
1x Decree of Justice - $2.50
3x Blinding Angel - $2.00
1x Twilight Drover - $1.50
1x Knight of the White Orchid - $1.50
1x Benalish Commander - $1.00
1x Bringer of the White Dawn - $1.00
1x Nomad Mythmaker - $0.75
2x Kinsbaile Borderguard - $0.75
1x Cradle of Vitality - $0.75
2x Pentarch Paladin - $0.75
1x Divine Sacrament - $0.75
1x Celestial Convergence - $0.50
1x Avatar of Hope - $0.50
1x Serra Angel (8th) - $0.50
1x Hold the Line - $0.50
1x Voice of All - $0.50
1x Restore Balance - $0.50
2x Celestial Dawn - $0.50
$0.25 List
2x Ghosts of the Innocent
1x Degavolver
1x Glarecaster
1x Voidstone Gargoyle
1x Three Dreams
1x Master Healer
1x Earnest Fellowship
1x Light of Sanction
1x Hoofprints of the Stag
1x Imperial Mask
1x Weathered Bodyguards
1x Chronosavant
2x Feudkiller's Verdict
1x Catapult Master
2x Barren Glory
4x Humble
Green:
1x Life from the Loam - $10.00
3x Seedborn Muse (9th) - $4.00
1x Scapeshift - $3.50
1x Enchantress's Presence - $3.00
2x Jugan, the Rising Star - $2.50
1x Golgari Grave-Troll - $2.00
1x Asceticism - $2.00
1x Wren's Run Packmaster - $1.50
2x Shape of the Wiitigo - $1.00
1x Protean Hulk - $1.00
1x Wurmweaver Coil - $1.00
1x Gaea's Blessing - $0.75
1x Helix Pinnacle - $0.75
1x Protean Hydra - $0.75
1x Cytoplast Root-Kin - $0.75
1x Vernal Bloom - $0.75
1x Bringer of the Green Dawn - $0.75
1x Biorhythm - $0.50
3x Symbiotic Wurm - $0.50
1x Roaring Slagwurm - $0.50
3x Verduran Enchantress - $0.50
2x Life and Limb - $0.50
2x Rites of Flourishing - $0.50
1x Plated Slagwurm - $0.50
1x Lifegift - $0.50
1x Mythic Proportions - $0.50
$0.25 List
1x Spike Tiller
1x Force of Nature
1x Squall Line
1x Skullmulcher
1x Primordial Sage
1x Ursapine
2x Magus of the Vineyard
1x Lhurgoyf
1x Elemental Resonance
1x Cylian Sunsinger
4x Earth Surge
1x Upwelling
1x Ancestral Mask
Multicolored:
1x Voidslime - $3.50
2x Decimate - $3.50
1x Angel of Despair - $3.00
1x Razia's Purification - $1.50
3x Mystic Snake - $1.50
1x Bladewing the Risen - $1.00
2x Dovescape - $0.75
1x Experiment Kraj - $0.75
1x Genju of the Realm - $0.50
3x Gleancrawler - $0.50
1x Teysa, Orzhov Scion - $0.50
1x Invoke the Firemind - $0.50
1x Oros, the Avenger - $0.50
1x Mishra, Artificier Prodigy - $0.50
1x Djinn Illuminatus - $0.50
1x Sedraxis Specter - $0.25
1x Fight to the Death - $0.25
1x Brilliant Ultimatum - $0.25
1x Titanic Ultimatum - $0.25
1x Violent Ultimatum - $0.25
1x Realm Razer - $0.25
1x Stalking Assassin - $0.25
1x Prophetic Bolt - $0.25
1x Blood Tyrant - $0.25
1x Agrus Kos, Wojek Veteran - $0.25
Lands:
1x Academy Ruins - $9.00
1x Kjeldoran Outpost - $3.50
2x Yavimaya Coast - $2.50
1x Gilt-Leaf Palace - $2.00
1x Shelldock Isle - $0.25
1x Rustic Clachan - $0.25
A search is mandatory, but finding something is not. So at most, the deck should have been shuffled.
If you play a Farseek, you may search but if you choose nothing, you would just shuffle your deck. I have played such cards just to shuffle my deck before.